Post # 1
My DS will be 11 months next week. He has been taking less and less formula over the last couple of weeks, and this weekend, it came to a head. He would scream anytime we came near him with a bottle or sippy cup of formula. Nap and bedtime were a nightmare because he usually nurses (from a bottle) to sleep, and he refused, but couldn’t soothe himself well any other way, so there was a lot of crying and not much sleeping. However, he was wonderful when he was awake. Playful and happy. And he was eating solds and drinking water no problem, so I’m sure he’s not sick or teething.
I emailed his Peditirician and she said “sounds like he’s self weaning. Try starting cows milk.” That’s all well and good, but I have no idea how to do this. Do I just replace his normal bottles with milk? Do I put it in a sippy cup and drop the bottle all together? Do I warm it up like I did his formula? Do I need Organic or any other fancy kind of whole milk?
I’m just at a loss. Anyone with experience they can share would be appreciated!
Post # 2
I work at a daycare and I’d suggest just dropping the bottle totally and putting milk in a sippy cup. you shouldn’t need to warm it up, just straight from the jug. We just give whole milk or 2%, if theres no digestive concerns it really doesn’t matter
Post # 3
When we transitioned to cow’s milk, I tried it out with a 2oz portion- one ounce being cow’s milk. It went well, so I did half and half and over a week or so I gradually increased the proportion of cow’s milk. She never had any allergies to any dairy products (she had eaten my oatmeal made with skim milk before, she eats plenty of cheese and yogurt, never had any issues) so I knew allergies wouldn’t be a big problem. I went slowly more to get her accustomed to the taste. I think we started the transition around 11 months and by a year she was all cow’s milk!
Post # 5
I’d put the mild in a sippy and get rid of the bottles. If he is self weaning, may as well get rid of thoose things rather than teach him to drink something else out of them!
Post # 6
Ditch the bottles. At this point, he’s good to go with sippy cups. Start with small amounts of cow’s milk and don’t introduce anything else new for a few days. That way you can easily identify if there’s any allergies or problems. You’ll know it was definitely the milk. If he does fine, then go full force and loose the formula (and gain a little more money since formula is pricey!).
As for organic vs. not, that’s your personal choice. There are a lot of compelling reasons for going organic but it is more expensive and depending on where you live, can be harder to find. Personally, we only buy organic milk for all members of our family.
Post # 7
MrsN14: DaneLady: Mrs.Sawyertobe: just_another_dandelion: Thank you for the advice! So one quick question: Our current schedule is (1) 6 oz bottle at wake-up, breakfast about 1 hour later, (1) 5 oz bottle before morning nap, lunch, (1) 5 oz bottle before afternoon nap, dinner and (1) 4 oz bottle at bedtime (but he usually only finishes 2 oz before he falls asleep).
So should I offer a full sippy cup right when he wakes up like I used to with his bottle? Or should I go right to breakfast now and just offer the milk with breakfast? Do I just keep milk available all day or give it on a schedule like I did with his bottles? So lost here!
Post # 8
ExcitedScaredBee: Dirty Delete is a little older than your DS, but I am pretty sure when we started ditching bottles I just let her play until breakfast but pushed breakfast to an earlier time. Mostly I give her milk in a cup with each meal and let her drink as much water out of a cup as she wants. Sometimes I water down juice but not very often. Even at 16 months, we will do 2-3oz milk in a bottle either just before or just after her bath, but not to put her to sleep- it’s mostly to help get her mind to wind down since we snuggle in the recliner chair and read (it’s also the only way I can get her to sit still long enough to cut her nails!) I think it was around 9-10 months that we stopped using the bottle to get her to go to sleep, so as long as it’s not part of her bed time routine we don’t have problems.
Post # 9
ExcitedScaredBee: Keep in mind to not to let him drink too much milk. You can ask your pediatrician for their advice, but anything over 20-24 oz of milk per day might be too much, because milk does not have iron (as iron fortified formulas do), so toddlers who drink too much milk may run the risk of becoming anemic because they do not have enough iron intake.
Post # 10
ExcitedScaredBee: at first we warmed the milk
up for her and she’d have two bottles of milk a day- about 6 oz each. Now she’s older- almost 2 she has her milk in a cup before she goes to bed. She still won’t drink it cold though. I’d just move her on to warm cows milk straight into a cup, better for her teeth, and id only offer it out of the cup. At first she may refuse but she’ll get used to it. I’m not advocating this but a couple of my friends gave there little ones nesquick/ovaltine if they wouldnt take the milk plain on advice of there health visitor. X
Post # 11
Sounds like he’s ready for milk and more food/less bottle feedings. I agree with the pp, do milk in sippy cups with meals. I started switching my baby around 11 1/2 months to milk with meals instead of formula in bottles. I wouldn’t bother warming it unless you want to create the habit of always having to warm it for him to drink it. If he’s only used to drinking warm formula start with warm, then room temp, then cold to get him used to the change.
Post # 12
Winterbride_England: My SIL gives two bottles of nesquick everyday….I think it’s so strange! Apparently she thinks it’s a good idea? I even read nutrition literature in France and they recommend no sugar until at least 3…