(Closed) Am I being unreasonable?

posted 7 years ago in Bridesmaids
Post # 3
Member
1104 posts
Bumble bee

I think it would be nice if you could cover at least $100 of the cost of their new dress, since they weren’t able to get a refund last year. I would be put out if someone expected me to buy a second dress when there was nothing wrong with the first one, they’d just changed their mind. It’s not about money, it’s just the principle of it.

And as Betty Draper would say (something I keep telling myself anytime I wonder at other people’s financial choices because I am certainly guilty of it myself), “Stop counting other people’s money” 🙂

Post # 4
Member
247 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: March 2011 - The Viceroy

I totally understand why you want a new dress, but this is the second dress your cousins have had to buy.  No matter what their financial situations I think you should offer to pay for the old dress or give money towards the new dress.  It sounds like you and your fiance made the right decision with changing the date for your situation, but they still have to buy 2 dresses per no fault of their own.  I would pay just to keep the peace.  Good luck!

Post # 5
Member
3979 posts
Honey bee
  • Wedding: January 2012

I don’t think it’s ever fair to assume someones financial situation. My FI was judged for years based on his career & position in life… if they only knew he really had $100k + in student loans & was up to his eyeballs in debt due to poor choices in his twenties.

Anyway… I don’t think you’re being unreasonable, but you aren’t being very understanding. I would feel the exact same way as your cousin. I don’t think she’s saying that you two won’t work out. She’s just doesn’t want to waste money on a dress in the event that the plans change again. Can you blame her since she had to bite $100 on the previous dress?

Post # 6
Member
1777 posts
Buzzing bee
  • Wedding: September 2009

While it is nice you are picking a gdress that hopefully can be worn again, I am totally in agreement with your cousins.  I would have been upset that you changed the wedding to save yourself a lot of money and then didn’t pay for the extra expense you cost them.  Why don’t you go with the dresses they already have (through no fault of their own), or at least pay what they were out the first time? 

Post # 7
Member
1120 posts
Bumble bee
  • Wedding: July 2009

I’m in agreement with the others on here – it doesn’t really matter how much money they make, that’s not a reason to expect them to buy two bridesmaid dresses without complaint. Would it be possible for you to pay for the money that they lost on the first dress, or offer to put that amount toward the cost of the new dress?

Post # 8
Member
837 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: October 2010

Yes, I think you’re being unreasonable.  It has nothing to do with her financial situation either, regardless of what she or her husband makes.  You asked her to buy a dress once and she did and you didn’t offer to pay for it when YOU canceled YOUR wedding so YOU could have YOUR college paid for.  See a trend here?  These are all decision that you made and she shouldn’t have to shell out another $100+ to pay for another dress.  You should have offered to pay for the first dress, had you done that, she more than likely would have declined (as most people do in these situations) and you wouldn’t be having this problem.

Post # 9
Member
529 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: October 2009

Keep in mind that you’ve mentioned they have a new house and new cars.  Do you know how much debt they are probably in now because of that?  My husband and I also have a very nice house and I just got a “new” used car, but I’m in debt up to my eyeballs because of it and I wouldn’t want to buy a second dress either.

Post # 10
Member
1079 posts
Bumble bee
  • Wedding: August 2010

A 200k house isn’t expensive at all. Obviously they each need a car to go to work. They have a kid with expenses. And she probably has a lot of student loans from that masters. It sounds like they are living within their means, and being careful with money. I can understand why she’s not too excited about buying another dress, even if she can afford it. I’d definitely offer to cover the cost of the last dress. Why don’t you ask if they want to pick out some dresses – maybe you’d both like something they pick out. Spending money on your cousins’ weddings was your choice – a lot of bridesmaids decline the invitation if they can’t afford the cost. It’s not a reciprocal thing.

Post # 11
Member
529 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: October 2009

@rachelss – I think you should be careful about making assumptions like “a 200k house isn’t expensive at all.”  It’s really dependent on where you live.  Where I live in New England, a 200k house is not considered expensive, but in other areas of the country, I’m sure that it does.  Plus I know that different areas of the country are paid differently, and hence why costs are different.  So while 200k might not seem like a lot for a house to you or me, it may be a lot for them.

Post # 12
Member
124 posts
Blushing bee
  • Wedding: August 2010

Unfortunately, I do think you’re being unreasonable and I don’t think it’s fair for you to make assumptions about the way they spend their money and their income. I’d say that if you want them to wear a specific dress so badly then you should really pay for the dresses yourself. As for being bitter, I don’t think you should blame your cousins or bms for the decisions you made–to postpone your life 3 years. This also shouldn’t be a tit for tat kind of thing, just because you spent upwards of $300 for one of them doesn’t make it fair for you to expect all 6 of them to do the same for you. Sorry! I’m sure this wasn’t what you wanted to hear but the bottom line is yes, I think you’re being a bit unreasonable. Good luck!

Post # 13
Member
2373 posts
Buzzing bee
  • Wedding: December 2009

If this was the first dress and she was complaining, yeah, that would really suck.  It’s kind of a given that BMs pay for their dresses.  However, this isn’t the 1st dress and no where in the unwritten BMs rules does it say you should be required to buy two dresses.  I would feel very uncomfortable asking them to do so.  Being a BM is already enough of a financial commitment when you factor in the costs of showers, bachelorette parties, gifts, dress #1, hair, nails, etc, etc, etc.  So, to ask a bridesmaid to pay an additional $150-$200 on another dress because you changed your mind?  Yeah, that’s a tad bit unreasonable. 

And I agree with the other bees that said it’s unfair to judge your BM on what her financial status appears to be.  I highly doubt she shares her monthly total of bills with you.  Maybe she doesn’t have the extra $200 because she is paying for the $200k house, student loans on her master’s degree in nursing, and the expenses of her kid.  You really have to look at that side of things.  When my DH and I got married, my MIL made the comment of how nice it will be to have all that extra money now that we would have a combined bank account?  UHHH HELL NO!  Just because we got married, doesn’t mean all our previous financial obligations went away.  We still have the same situation as before.  It’s just not safe to assume someone’s financial situation/status.

Post # 14
Member
2641 posts
Sugar bee

 I agree with the others. 

Post # 15
Member
455 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: May 2011

I think your cousin’s response was probably a result of some frustration from her having to keep a dress that she bought for your event.  I understand you wanting a new dress, I understand her not wantign to buy a second dress.

Maybe just call (or email if you’re an anti-caller) and just express that you understand it DOES kind of suck that she has a dress she’s stuck with, but that you really would love her to have this new dress to.  Take a little bit to understand her frustration and then talk to her about it.

Also, I don’t think how she spends her money is relevant so try not to raise it or the fact that you took care of your grandmother.  The dress is not such a huge deal that it should become one of those times where something little skyrocketed into a HUGE fight.

Clearly she means alot to you if she’s your BM!  Communication is key 🙂

Post # 16
Member
516 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: November 2010

I think you need to put yourself in her shoes, and think about how you would feel. There is obviously some upset because she did not get a refund, maybe work out a way to pay them back for the refund or something like that- but don’t let this ruin your relationship!

The topic ‘Am I being unreasonable?’ is closed to new replies.

Get our weekly roundup of the best of Weddingbee.
I agree to receive emails from the site. I can withdraw my consent at any time by unsubscribing.

Find Amazing Vendors