- Blog
- Bios
- Boards
- Classifieds
- DIY
- Gallery
- Vendor Reviews
- Shop Weddingbee
Just curious, because I hear a lot of people stating how they absolutely don't want one. I've also heard of a lot of people saying they wanted one at first and then changed their minds.
If you've had one by choice or will have one by choice, what are your reasons?
Mine will not be my choice but I'm actually glad that my next birth will be a scheduled c-section. My first was an emergency one.
I had one, but not by choice. My labor had stalled and the doctor said I needed it. I honestly was in a lot of pain at the time, so I don't remember the exact reasons she wouldn't let labor continue.
So I reluctantly agreed. And I was actually surprised. I already had an epidural in, so all they had to do was turn it up. The c-section itself was amazing to me. I had zero pain or discomfort and was fully aware of what was going on. They handed the baby directly to me as soon as he was pulled out.
My previous labor had been very long with three hours of pushing, multiple episiotomies, tearing, forceps...just awful. Her head finally came out, then her shoulders got stuck. They had to break her collarbone to get her out. The c-section was a hundred times easier.
If I were to have another baby, I would request a c-section. I have learned that I have a narrow birth canal and my babies have had exceptionally large heads. I would never put myself through labor again. Yes, the recovery was much longer, but it was far easier than the three hour nightmare of pushing.
I want one for three reasons:
1. I suffered from vaginismus for a long time. It's gone away, but tends to come back in clinical settings. I had to get a cervical biopsy a few months ago and was crying for a week. It's downright traumatic for me. I honestly don't think a vaginal birth is possible for me.
2. I have herpes, which can transfer to the child through vaginal birth. I tend to get breakouts when I'm stressed. I don't want to take any chances.
3. I'm just a plain old wuss. Give me all the drugs you have, cut me open and take the baby out. I'll deal with the pain after.
I'm not pregnant but I've thought a LOT about this particular issue.
I would like to avoid anyone cutting through my abdominal wall at all costs. As a personal trainer I have seen the detrimental affects it has caused.
I do. But i MIGHT be able to be swayed to an vaginal birth with an epidural (extra strong please =o) ). My mom delivered both my brother and me via c-sec (brother was an emergency, and VBACs werent allowed back then), so Ive known about them from an early age. I also remember watching the birth video in either middle or high school and thinking, "I will never do that," and it still holds true. I'm TERRIFIED of tearing, episiotomy, incontinence, bad healing, lost sexual anything. I've witnessed the birth of my best friends baby, and while it was truly beautiful and a miracle, it didnt sway me much. I've spoken to my Dr about an elective c-section, and he said we will dsicuss it further and in depth in the coming weeks.
my coworker will only birth by c-section and she requested it through her doctor. she says recovery is a lot shorter and you avoid vaginal tearing. but i have to admit that i went to wikipedia, read about c-sections and saw a gross pic with a woman's abdomen wide open.
@pamplemousse: I don't know that the recovery is any easier. With a c-section you cannot drive for three weeks or go up stairs for at least the first week
@KellyV: Yes I would hope people would keep "anti-C-section" comments out of this thread as it's not the point of the post.
@SoontobeMrsA: You're right. I've had both vaginal delivery, with episiotomy and tearing, and a c-section and the c-section took a lot longer to recover from. The recovery wasn't that bad, but it did take longer.
@SoontobeMrsA:what! no driving for 3 weeks?? that's difficult! my coworker swears by elective c-sections and has told me on many occassions even though i don't plan to have a baby any time soon.
but i read about the scary parts of birth through mrs. dumpling's blog: http://omgmom.blogspot.com/search/label/Birth%20Story
@pamplemousse: Yes, three weeks. You are not supposed to drive until you know you could slam on the brakes if a child ran in front of your car. It is painful. I took heavy pain meds for probably the first week.
@camrie: Yeah, Ill probably edit my post and take that out. Probably dont need it here =o) Im used to defending my opinion though, force of habit
@KellyV: I hear ya, re: being TERRIFIED of tearing, cutting, ripping down there. I read birth stories and I literally cringe at the thought of it. At the same time, I would like to be able to have a vaginal birth (with epidural, of course!) because I'm also scared of surgery. I'm not even close to being pregnant yet, so I have a while to figure it out :)
Nope, not happy about it but have to have c-sections for any children due to the surgery I just had in November (or else my uterus could rupture..lovely!). It is nice to know that arriving at the hospital for a scheduled c-section will be calm and not painful since I will be scheduled two weeks before my due date, however, I don't like the idea of having a c-section. And after the pain I just had (abdominal surgery) a few months ago, I know what the pain is going to be like after a c-section and I'm not looking forward to having it again! But it's all worth it for a baby. :)
@KellyV: It's okay. I have many of the same fears as you do. While recovery time is usually longer I feel like c-section has more definites on "what to expect" while vaginal delieveries seem to run the gamut.
My mother gave birth to four via c-section - the only thing she mentioned is that our heads "weren't squished-looking" from coming thru the birth canal. :)
I think there are pluses and minuses to both and am just looking for some perspective and weighing my options (because my insurance covers both nearly equally).
@camrie: Wow, your insurance covers elective c-sections?! That's a rare find!
@camrie: My insurance covers both just about equally as well. I was surprised, but I asked specifically and they said yes. I do know there are distinct benefits (and disadvantages) to both. Im trying to weigh my options now. My doctor hasnt pressured me either way at all, but did tell me he would thoroughly fill me in on both options so I can make the best educated decision I could. Im leaning toward the c-sec. Very strongly. but Im only 14 weeks so I have some time to finally decide =o)
My mom said we didnt have squished heads either! LOL. I also, as an infant or child, never suffered from illness, infections, bronchitis, etc. Neither did my brother. So whlie c-sec babies might be more prone to such illness, I dont think it is the raging norm.
@Mrs. Spring: There's about a $300 difference...and yes, I have good insurance. :)
@camrie: That's incredible! It was my understanding that insurance companies have all but done away with covering elective c-sections. Most of the policies I've seen require submittal of a form by the doctor stating that it's medically necessary, or require some kind of pre-authorization. Even small insurance carriers and self-insured plans don't usually cover elective surgeries!
i would absolutely be HORRIFIED if i had to get a c-section...the whole experience of child birth has to do with giving birth vaginally and i would NOT want to miss that for the world, so unless it was a life or death emergency, i would NOT get a c section. Funny...hubby and i were just talking about this last night.
sorry camrie, i dont mean to be anti c section! just wanted to throw in my 2 cents :) good luck with your decision!
Yes, I want one. My mother needed one because she's very petite and I take after her. She had c sections with each of us and her and my brother almost died because he tore her up inside so badly. I am also very tight and my muscles are very rigid. My gyno always has to "persuade" my lady parts to even get a finger in. The amount of tearing that I would go through is terrifying to think of.
@alishadhs4: Everyone is entitle to their own opinion, and I definitely know a lot of people who share yours, so I do respect it. but I have to ask, how will you mentally handle if you do end up needing an emergency c-secion, or if they tell you from the start that you'll have to have one? I know a lot of people in your shoes struggle with that after the fact (feeling like they failed or something similar)
I am soooooo against C-Section sorry. Except for where it is an absolute necessity to save baby and mother. I've travelled to many countries and found that it is only in america that so many women opt for C-section, or are recommended to do so. This is because the health care system here has realized that it is cheaper and faster to delivery C-section babies, than to wait for nature to take its course. Its more xpensive for them to have doctor and medical staff "waste their very precious time" waiting around for natural labor, so they rather schedule an appointment for birth as if its not a big deal.
@bells: Actually, Brazil has the highest rate, followed by one or two other countries before America in regards to elective c-sections. I dont know about the stats for doctors pushing it (which I should add I dont agree with. If the mother doesnt want one and its not medically necessary, let her deliver the way she wants) but with electives, there are countries with higher rates.
@alishadhs4: I did not want one either but to be honest I didn't feel like I missed out not having a vaginal birth.
If you want one, have at it! I have to admit there are days that it sounds like the lesser evil. There is a solid chance I'll have to have one anyways.
I don't want one as I want to have Wombat naturally. With Moose, I only had meds at the last minute because I thoght they'd give me something for my mental anguish. However, I may end up having to have one. If I do, I will be devistated as giving birth to Moose really brought my husband and I closer than I could ever imagine as he coached me through everything. He is truly amazing and I want that with Wombat.
I'm open to it. My mother had to have them for both my sister and I, because her pelvis was too small and couldn't stretch out enough to let a baby pass through. Which ended up for the best, as my sister's cord was wrapped around her neck quite a few times, and that probably would have been fatal. Since the build of her body is genetic, and I'm pretty similar to her, I plan to mention it to my doctor just in case I'll need one too. I'm not opposed to it by any means, but if it's possible I'd like to give a vaginal birth to see what all the fuss is about. I feel like I've had enough surgeries to grasp the concept of a c-section, but regardless of what the books say, I'm pretty sure a vaginal birth just ain't the same as a bm. I certainly won't be disappointed if it's recommended for me.
@sand dollar: "I'm pretty sure a vaginal birth just ain't the same as a bm." I almost spit out my drink after reading that.
@hilsy85:i have the same conflicted feelings!
i really don't want a c-section (not pregnant currently), but my mom and her sisters all had them, so it's a real possibility i'll have to also.
I have given this some thought, and really lean toward a c-section over vaginal. I don't want to be all stretched out, don't want to tear, dont' want to be in prolonged pain for hours and hours only to be told I need one anyway. Also, is it horrible to say I'm a planner? I know other professional women who've scheduled the time and date of their baby's birth, and it sounds attractive to me. (On the flip side, other women in my family who have had one *not* by choice, are totally against having one...so I am influenced by their experiences to consider the 'normal' way as well.)
(And no, I'm not pregnant. Just saw this thread and it called to me.
After my 1st emergency C-section I would've said "Hell no!" to wanting another one, but after the 2nd planned one (had to take her out 5 weeks early because of some health issues) it was so much easier. That recovery was 1000x better, so the experience for me wasn't totally horrible.
I guess I'm technically choosing a c-section... I have a choice between trying for a vaginal breech birth {which has a high chance of ending in a section anyway} or just going straight to a section.
I'm choosing a section because while there are pros and cons and risks for both, at least with a section I know pretty much what I'm getting. And with such a high chance of ending up with one anyway I'd rather skip the labour, pain and potential risk to baby {forceps are often used in breech births, and if that doesn't work, well I won't scare you with what they do!}.
I'm actually quite disappointed that I'll be having a section (I'd hoped for a natural home birth) but have come to terms with it being the best choice for me and my baby... I don't feel like I'll be less of a woman/mother not having had any labour or a vaginal birth. A healthy and safe delivery is the ultimate goal!
Interesting though what a pp said about only 3 weeks with no driving, in my area {and possibly all of Canada, not sure} they suggest 6 weeks!
I've heard recovery is harder for a c-section, so I'm going to try to avoid it. I'm not going to be super upset if something happens where I have to get it though. I don't really care how the baby comes out, as long as it's healthy!
For those on the fence, I'd recommend the book Deliver THIS! by Marisa Cohen...she gives anecdotal stories from women who have had nearly every type of birth, ranging from at home antural birth (unmedicated) to elective c-section. It's all about knowing your options & choosing the right path/birth plan for you. I LOVED that it had really no judgment on any of the options & let me understand what I could choose if I wanted.
After reading the book I was drawn both to having a doula/midwife & trying for unmedicated (with the option of going with the epidural if I just coudn't go on) AND to elective C-section...there are so many benefits (and drawbacks) to either option, in my eyes. The deciding factor for me (& Hubs, since we're making these decisions together) was that C-sections, and really ANY abdominal surgery, weaken the uterine wall & can affect any future attempts at pregnancy & full-term birth. Now, many women who have had C-sections, whether emergency/non-elective or elective, have gotten pregnant a second, third, even more times...but factor in the fact that I'll be 34 when I give birth to our first & that we'd like to wait 2-3 years before trying for a second, & that my mom had 3 miscarriages before having me, then 2 stillborns afterwards, I'd like to give my uterine wall all the help I can. But if we were only planning to try for one, this Kid could have been born through elective C-section...in part because Hubs' biggest fear is dealing with the Kid all alone if I didn't make it, & elective C-section seems a LOT less traumatizing upfront than vaginal delivery.
@ms.pascua: Good for you for reading and deciding what's best. Reading about birth actually made it a lot less scary.
@TheFutureMcBride: have you looked into hypnobirthing? That may work wonders for your anxiety.
I have ALWAYS said if i ever have a baby I will be requesting a C-Section... I know years back you werent aloud to request one... Has anyone had any trouble requesting to have a C ? My mom delivered both my sister and I via C , but my hips are wider and I am a larger woman than my mother was at birth so I am sure I could have a baby via vag but I prefer NOT to!
You must log in to post.
| Visit our sister sites | eHarmony Online Dating |
eHarmony Advice Dating Advice |
Project Wedding Wedding Songs |
JustMommies Pregnancy Calendar |

| User | Posts Today |
|---|---|
| ellisrobertson | 24 |
| fishbone | 18 |
| MsPanda | 14 |
| aduarte3201 | 14 |
| ladyartichoke | 12 |
| mypinkshoes | 12 |
| pengoala | 11 |
sylvia.riggle |
11 |
| ShellVee | 10 |
| ndreighton | 10 |
Sorry, there are no users yet.