- Blog
- Bios
- Boards
- Classifieds
- DIY
- Gallery
- Vendor Reviews
- Shop Weddingbee
When did it happen that "feminist" started to mean "womb-shrinking harpy"?
I keep seeing all these interviews where celebs say things like, "I'm not a feminist, but...."
What's up with that?
Do people thing that being a feminist means not being allowed to shave your legs or wear pretty bras or have sex with guys or get married or have babies?
Being a feminist means believing that men and women are equal. That's it. Why is that so controversial?
Do you identify as a feminist? If so, why? If not, why not?
Yes, I definitely do. I'm a feminist, that is wedding obsessed and has a baby on the way. And I definitely shave my legs, lol. I'm very into the vintage glamour look, so I think it throws people when I get in to heated debates with the people who think "women should be barefoot, pregnant, and in the kitchen" jokes are funny.
I think it is very important for women to be aware of where they stand in the world and how to better it, and to have a means of being independent. That is how I was raised.
I am and always annoyed by the 'post-feminist' blah blah blah. However, i don't think it's anywhere near as difficult to identify as a feminist now as it was in say, 1914.
@Mollytov: I think you're totally right that it's less of a...shall we say...cultural calamity to identify as a feminist now as opposed to, let's say, a hundred or even thirty years ago. That's part of why I'm so surprised when people are so hedgy about the term even now...part of me thinks that these women think, "Well, I can vote, and something about equal pay was passed in the '70s (at least in the U.S., not sure about other countries...eeek)...so what's the big deal?" But part of me also thinks that women think it's unattractive to men or that we'll force them to wear pant suits or something...I don't know.
I'm really curious about the "no" or "yes, but" votes...is it the label that people object to? Or not wanting to stake their socio-political beliefs on sex/gender issues? Or is it not as important?
hmmm... I'd have to say I'm not sure if I'd define a feminist with the same words you do. I generally tend to think about it as more of a cultural thinking that men are now inferior and women are "better". I feel like men are now being demeaned, why is it that women can get on TV talk shows and bash men for hours, but if a man started doing that he'd be torn apart for trash-talking women? Why is it okay for women to trash-talk men?
I find that most "feminists" I've met have a very superior attitude, and have a sense of entitlement.
That being said, I would never identify myself as a feminist. I'm very traditional. I don't feel like i HAVE to be a housewife/SAHM, but I want to. But I know if I wanted to work FT, my husband would be okay with that.
Hell yeah I am a feminist. My feminism comes from my core belief that men and women are equal-- we should be paid the same, we should have the same rights, we should get the same respect and have to play by the same rules.
That doesn't mean I'm not allowed to love pink things, wear frilly dresses and have an unnatural obsession with fonts. These are the things that make me an individual, but that doesn't have to take away from my feminism.
I agree with that it's not right for anyone to get bashed anywhere based purely on their sex. We should be judged as individuals and by our actions, men and women equally so.
On the other hand, I don't believe that someone who is "traditional" can't also be a feminist. Being a feminist means you can choose to take whatever occupation/duties is out there, from CEO to SAHM. What matters is the equality of opportunity.
@Sazerac: feminism does not mean we want to be men, it means that we want to be EQUAL to men, as you said.
yes, i am a feminist. and you know what else? FI is a feminist too. (you see, you don't have to be a woman to believe that men and women should have equal rights, pay, opportunities, etc...)
@miss-spunkin: keep in mind that it was the feminist movement that gave you the CHOICE to be "more traditional", instead of forcing you to be that way. the man-bashing women aren't feminists, they're assholes (to put it bluntly). feminism is not about man-bashing.
In the way that I think men and women should be paid equally for doing the same thing? Yes.
But I'd also like to be a SAHM and let DH go to work every day. And I feel like that's not a very 'feminist' thought.
I also have to partially agree with @miss-spunkin:. We hear a lot about getting girls more interested in math and science (which is great), but when you look at the numbers - it's boys who are more likely to drop out of high school or not get a college degree. But you definitely don't see the same level of activism on that. Which I think is sad.
You also see a lot of commercials/tv shows now where the man is portrayed as dumb/helpless until the knowing woman comes along and shows him to do whatever is relevant to the commercial. Reverse the genders and sh*t would hit the fan. I'm perfectly fine with a little gender humor but not a fan when it's lopsided. I can handle a 'make me a sammich' comment as long as they are prepared to take a few of these gems :) My favorite:
What did God say after creating man?
I can do so much better.
I'm gonna be weird here. I do not believe that men and women are equal.
There are things that men are better at than women. There are things that women are better at then men. We are not the same, one is certainly not superior to the other, but I have never wanted to be treated as if I'm a male... I deserve to be treated as a stong female... I am capable of doing things that most men cannot, but I can't do a lot of things than men can.
It's complicated.
@Orion: This 100% and I do consider myself a feminst and to @cardus: point I consider my FH a feminsit as well.
Men & women are equal in the sense of everyone deserves respect and dignity. But we are not the exact same nor should we strive to be. We should acknowledge that everyone has diffrent apptitudes and abilities. We can be similar but we will never be perfect duplicates of each other.
@miss-spunkin: I agree with that statement.
I absolutely believe that men and women should have the same opportunities, pay, rights, and status in society. If a woman chooses to work hard and become a CFO of a corporation, she absolutely should do so. If a woman chooses to stay at home and raise babies, cook, clean, and be June Cleaver, she should do so. I think that feminism helped women have the ability to make those choices.
However... I do think that the cultural acceptance of making fun of men or making them the butt of jokes is unacceptable, and I don't know if it came from feminism in general or more extreme forms of it, but I disagree with it. Men deserve respect just as equally as women do. I also think that sometimes men get overlooked with issues like breast cancer and being a SAHD. Those issues may be less common for men, but they're very real and I think men deserve more support for those types of issues that generally are viewed as more "womanly."
So, for me personally, I do agree with a lot of the basic tennants of feminism, but I don't like labeling myself as such because of some of the negative, cultural stereotypes that have arisen from it. I don't like labeling myself in general, though.
@hisgoosiegirl: You also see a lot of commercials/tv shows now where the man is portrayed as dumb/helpless until the knowing woman comes along and shows him to do whatever is relevant to the commercial.
This is because advertisers know women are the predominant shoppers in the household. They are just appealing to their market. Same reason why there are lots of scantily clad women in beer commercials.
@SoupyCat: excellent point.
@piglet_625: as soupycat alluded to in the previous post, i don't think we're any more a society that makes men the butt of jokes than we are a society that makes women sexual objects. that's not to say that men aren't sometimes the butt of jokes (which is unnacceptable), and that women aren't portrayed as sexual objects (which is also unnacceptable). however, to assume that portraying men as inept and make them the butt of jokes is a direct result or even a desired result of feminism in any way is completely off-base.
ETA: think of it this way...there are lots of christians who engage in un-christian behavior, and some who even engage in that behavior while invoking god or the bible as backup. just the same, there are a lot of really extreme women out there who claim to be feminist, but then make comments, support ideas, or engage in activities that really have nothing to do with feminism, and give the whole movement a bad name as a bunch of men-hating whackjobs.
@Orion: This is probably more where I am. Equal but different. There are some things that DH (and most men) can do better than I. The opposite is also true.
DH is much better at math than I am. No way around it. I think even some science backs up that men are better at spacial reasoning. Their brains are just better at it. Does that mean all men are better than all women at math or spatial reasoning? Not even close. A better comparison is probably strength and physical agility - can I jump, run, hit, swing as well as DH? No. But that's not always true.
I am much better with communication and intra-personal skills. I am better at recognizing peoples' emotions and feelings. That might sound less useful than being good at math, but when I'm in a meeting - I can tell who is thinking this is a great idea and who's zoned out much better than DH can. Even when we are with his own friends, I'll point out things afterward 'did you notice so and so didn't like you mentioning x' He just doesn't pick up on it. Is that the case for all men and women? Of course not.
Long story short, I guess I feel like we can be equal but still have our own talents. I think it would be boring if were the same. I like our differences :)
@SoupyCat: Probably very true - and I definitely notice it more on household items (that women would purchase). That's actually annoying now that you point it out. Because in a way, they're both continuing to perpetuate stereotypes - that women do all the cleaning and household duties whereas men drink beer and watch sports.
@cardus: I agree that it's also a marketing issue, however, it still was not culturally acceptable 75 years ago. So, the idea to portray men in that way somehow became acceptable somewhere along the way, and whatever was the cause of that, it's disturbing. I also find the sexualization of women for beer commercials or the like equally disturbing.
@piglet_625: it is absolutely disturbing, but to blame feminism in any part is short-sighted.
I just wanted to say I am really enjoying reading all the responses to this thread. I thought that after I posted my post, it might start getting a little dramatic with different viewpoints, but everyone is being so polite and stating their thoughts with eloquence. I like reading the responses to this thread.
@Orion: I really like this, because I agree on so many levels! Equal in terms of respect and opportunity, but it comes to a point where many women have to realize they will never be as talented as men in a certain field (like football haha!), and vice versa.
@piglet_625: I so agree! When my husband and I were engaged we talked about the possibility of him being a SAHD because I wanted to go to medical school and be a doctor. I changed my mind and decided I wanted to be the SAHM, but I have known several families where that was the case and it works out so well. I don't feel like it's feminist or anti-feminist, but I think it should be more widely accepted.
I did learn though that my husband has a need to provide for me though, and I do think if I had become a doctor and beein the breadwinner for the family that he might have had a hard time with it. So maybe it's not so feminist as it is that men and women have roles that nature has placed within them??
@miss-spunkin: "Equal in terms of respect and opportunity, but it comes to a point where many women have to realize they will never be as talented as men in a certain field (like football haha!), and vice versa."
this is very true, and i completely agree! but i think one thing that feminists want is that should a woman be able to actually hack it in football because she's big enough, strong enough, and has the skill, that she should be allowed to hack it, and not get paid less or otherwise descriminated against simply because she's female. if she can't hack it, well then she can't hack it. ;) (it's a ridiculous example, but it gets the point across i thnk.) the point isn't for the NFL to be equal parts men and women, but for women to be allowed and treated equally if they have the ability to warrant that. does that make sense?
@miss-spunkin: I think the roles you describes as nature-influenced are actually culturally-influenced. There are many tribal societies where men have a child-rearing role and women are the providers. Hopefully, as we strive more and more for equality to be reflected in our culture, we will see patriarchal dominance as "nature" less and less.
@hisgoosiegirl: I agree with you. Being feminist to me means men and women are equal, but I don't think that means they have to be the same. I still let FI open doors for me :) But I also make him cook, lol.
Also, going back to the jokes...
Why did God make man first? Because you always make a rough draft before a masterpiece ;)
@galloway111: ha, that's a good one! I need a few on hand. DH likes to whip out the 'make me a sammich' every now and then and I need some comebacks!
Funny though, he does most of the sammich-making :)
Yes, I'm a feminist. To me it means equality. I seriously hate the "man-bashing" stereotype.
@galloway111: lol My FI won't let me open doors. I joke that I'll forget how to open a door someday because he always insists on doing it for me.
@hisgoosiegirl: Lol, us also. DH is in charges of sammiches, and I do the eggs.
I 110% consider myself a feminist and it really annoys me to see feminism painted as women being shrill harpies or anti-man or thinking that it's not OK to be nurturing or traditionally feminine. While there certainly are women out there who hate men (and men out there who hate women), painting feminism as being about man-hating and judging women who take traditional roles is a very effective way of drowning out the true message that things are not always equal, women are often paid less for the same job, and are objectified and demeaned in ways that often get overlooked.
I'll also say that I consider myself somewhat post-gender in that I think that the variation among women and the variation among men (really among all individuals) is a lot greater than the variation between the average woman and the average man. Are there innate and conditioned differences that in the aggregate are more associated with one gender or another? Sure, but attributes like emotional nurturing or drive to be a financial breadwinner are things that vary greatly within each gender.
I also think that traditional gender roles are really limiting for men as well. While it galls me that women often don't make the same amount for the same job (some of this is due to womens' choices, some of it due to biases), it also upsets me that men are judged as less manly or less worthy if they are talented nurturers who would prefer to and be more successful at spending time with their children than earning the family paycheck. I think that's partly reflective of undue pressures on men to act a certain way (while the rules have relaxed some for women, the acceptable roles for men have barely budged), but also on a general discounting of anything traditionally feminine. Looking down on childcare or women-dominated industries or media aimed at women is just one more way of subtly undermining an agenda of true equal rights and equal treatment. You don't have to want to stay at home with children or take your husband's name or work in a caregiving profession (I don't, but that's just me), but demeaning them is definitely not what feminism is about.
@mrs-v-to-be: I believe you can be a stay-at-home mom/wife/partner and also be feminist. You don't have to be a career woman to be a feminist. :) If you believe in and stand up for the equality of men and women, you're a feminist in my book.
@SoupyCat: You said exactly what I wanted to say...but in better words :D
Yup, I'm a feminist.
I'm a feminist but I'm a stay at home mom so I guess I confuse people. I just don't like working and I do like my son... I always believed life is short do what you love, so I am. =D
@hisgoosiegirl: Haha yep, FI always tells me to get back in the kitchen... but he does all the cooking, lol. No seriously, ALL the cooking.
@honeyoats22: My FI always has to open doors too. Sometimes we make it a competition- I try to run to open the door first and he tries not to let me.
@galloway111: Why did God make man first? Because you always make a rough draft before a masterpiece ;)
lmao
@miss-spunkin: "So maybe it's not so feminist as it is that men and women have roles that nature has placed within them?"
Nature isn't the only thing at play when it comes to gender roles. The breadwinner-homekeeper roles are also culturally ingrained in our society, and we learn these roles at a young age. Things are changing a lot now, but when I was a child, I had dresses and a little kitchen and baby dolls, while my brother had none of these things. It may be just as much learned as it is nature.
Since we probably all don't agree on the creation of Earth, its date of Creation and how people came along its hard to argue nature versus nurture.
Barbie dolls and trucks are one thing, hunting down mastodons and giving birth to babies is another thing.
i'm so glad to see that feminism is so welcome here! it seems like everywhere i turn, "feminist" is a bad word or something. i'm a feminist because i believe that women and men are equal. there are still so many issues where women are underepresented. likewise, feminine ideas or ways of thinking are shoved to the sideline so often. there's is defnitely a lack of understanding of feminism, and it's hurting everyone.
@Eva Peron: It's true only women can give birth to children, but in some societies, the Mosuo of western China for example, it is the male's responsibility to rear the children. I'm sure the men there do not find it unnatural.
@honeyoats22: I can't agree more with your post. This is a very interesting topic.
Has any of the bees read "The second sex" by Simone De Beauvoir? It is some heavy stuff, read it twice, but indeed it is interesting. I would suggest some of you girls might be interested in reading this aswell. I hope anyone finds this book as interesting as I did!
And a movie worth recommending: Iron Jawed Angels. It is about the American Suffragettes. You guys should watch that movie! Great actors, great music, and an interesting storyline.
I think in todays media, we are overwhelmed with ideals with what today's woman should be like, well I guess the ideals change over time, but the media has always been there for us (Hint: Mad Men). But for me, I am trying to find my own way without getting too much affected of those factors, because those ideals are not giving me anything, nor to my intellect or my self value. It's nothing wrong trying to be pretty and taking care of yourself to feel good and create selfvalue through a good career, self development etc. But I do believe that alot of emphasis today is extreme when it comes down on us to be the "perfect" women, as well as "perfect" men. We should look perfect, have the perfect life/lifestyle, career, perfect kids/family etc etc... Men today have so much pressure on them as well as women. The only difference with women from men through the centuries is that we as a gender have been struggling to have our rights and being as equal to men, and through centuries we have been without any say. So from that point of view I do believe that we are the stronger ones since we have had to face these battles in order to gain equality. We may not have fought the real battles here, but we are the ones maintaining this balance right now. It wasn't something that was handed to us (well some things were, but still). We actually had to get it ourselves. It's kinda cool that we have come so far over the past decades that has been! :)
@SoupyCat: Great point! Things that have become ingrained certainly feel natural. I think thats an awesome concept I'd be curious to study more about that particular culture!
@Eva Peron: Yes, it is a very interesting society! I actually got to see some of their customs and intricate dress when I visited China. Also, the African Aka tribe is similarly known for their high male participation in child-rearing.
You must log in to post.
| Visit our sister sites | eHarmony Online Dating |
eHarmony Advice Dating Advice |
Project Wedding Wedding Songs |
JustMommies Pregnancy Calendar |

| User | Posts Today |
|---|---|
| ellisrobertson | 24 |
| fishbone | 21 |
| MsPanda | 14 |
| ladyartichoke | 14 |
| aduarte3201 | 14 |
| mypinkshoes | 12 |
| pengoala | 11 |
sylvia.riggle |
11 |
| Brielle | 10 |
| likelimeade | 10 |
| User | Posts Today |
|---|---|
| ShellVee | 8 |
| MsPanda | 7 |
| ellisrobertson | 5 |
| Potatoes | 2 |
| UpstateCait | 2 |
| Paigey | 2 |
| MissAsB | 1 |
| lisalew5472 | 1 |
| keepsmiling19 | 1 |
| Niqs | 1 |