Weddingbee boards

For those of you who've been to Aruba...

-All inclusive?? (and which one?)

vs

-Non all-inclusive?? (and which one?)

We are up in the air about whether the all-inclusive is worth the money due to the fact that Aruba is supposed to have great food/restaurants, for a reasonable price. We normally stay at all-inclusives, but don't know if we should this time around. Also, is it better to stay in the middle of the strip? If not, how do you get around the island (rent a car?) if you have stayed toward the end of the strip? Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated! (Note: We are on a tight budget, so the Hyatt may be out:)

Thanks:)