Stupid stuff people say to pregnant women
more by firsttimemom
Excruciating Pain when I sneeze
Cloth Diapers: Prefolds or Inserts?
more in Babies
All in a name ?!
Cheesecakes! Pick your favourite flavour!
more in Boards
Rose Ceremony

Breast Pump Debate

posted 1 year ago in Babies
  •  
    1.
    Member
    1,848 posts
    Buzzing bee
    firsttimemom    December 18, 2010  

    I've been doing my research on breast pumps since I found out I was pregnant, because I believe it's one of the more important things (see my priorities?) and I've been having a lot of issues choosing. I know the general statement is more expensive=better, and the one I'm leaning toward is $300. That doesn't include collection bottles. To be fair, I've been looking at Double Electric Pumps, but I was wondering if you ladies had any experiences you'd like to share. Here's the pump I'm leaning towards:

    http://www.simplisse.com/double-electric-breastfeeding-companion/?gclid=CKjj2YPvyqcCFYLc4AodeFAgAw

     
    2.
    Member Icon
    Member
    181 posts
    Blushing bee
    TessaDL    October 19, 2007   Orange County, CA

    A pump was important to me too but not quite as important because I stay home with my son so I knew I wouldn't need it as much as women who go back to work.  But for a women going back to work I would suggest a good top-of-the-line one.  Only because you're going to have to pump at work and you want one that you won't have problems with.  

    A tip of mine: Think about or have a picture of your baby with you while you are pumping, it will help with letdown of the milk.  Oh and relax! 

    Also, most hospitals sell pumps cheaper (they usually have a little store) than you would find in a retail store or even online sometimes.  Check the hospital where you are delivering and compare prices with pumps online.  

    Good luck on finding your perfect pump!! 

     
    3.
    Member
    622 posts
    Busy bee
    ktdid23    November 7, 2008   Annapolis, MD

    I have been using the Medela Pump In Style multiple times daily for the past 6 weeks (since I've been back to work) and I love it.  It's quick, faily quiet, and I like that I can walk into Target/BabiesRUs and pick up spare bottles and parts very easily.  Mine was about $300, but I caught a sale at BRU where it came with a pack of freezer bags, wipes, cream, and a box of nursing pads (total of $45)... and then I was able to use a 20% off coupon.  I got everything for just over $200.  I personally love it would highly recommend the Medela PIS.

     
    4.
    Member
    6,301 posts
    Bee Keeper
    SoontobeMrsA    June 2012   MA/NH line

    I pumped exclusively for six months (girl was determined not to nurse!). I highly highly recommend the lifesaver that is an electric pump. We had a Medela. 

    It saves time, is more comfortable, and does not require you to pump with your hand which can get sore.

    My insurance paid for it because my daughter would not nurse. 

     
    5.
    Member
    786 posts
    Busy bee
    MrsE.ToBe    October 1, 2011   MA

    for those looking to buy breast pumps, just wanted to make sure you knew that now you can use your flex spending accounts for them! 

     
    6.
    Hostess
    7,921 posts
    Bumble
    Beekeeper
    Lillindy    September 2008   Bay Area, CA

    @TessaDL: I'm in the same position where I'll be at home with my baby, but still want a pump.  I registered for an expensive Medela one, but did you end up finding a cheaper option since you didn't have to exclusively pump?

     
    7.
    Member Icon
    Member
    181 posts
    Blushing bee
    TessaDL    October 19, 2007   Orange County, CA

    @Lillindy: I was going to just get a cheaper one, but my grandma offered to buy the more expensive Medela one.  So I really didn't look into the cheaper options too much.  Even though I didn't use it much, I still think it was worth the investment.  Because a good pump is important.  I think Playtex makes a more basic, cheaper one.  I saw it online, I think on Amazon, but I can't remember.  But, yea it doesn't have the back pack or anything (like the Medela), it's just the pump. Which would be fine for you I'm sure since you won't have to pump in public or at work or anything.

    I actually wasn't sure if I was going to go back to work at first, so that's part of the reason I got the more expensive one.  But I ended up being a stay-at-home-mom and not using it much.  But like I said, it might be worth the investment.

     
    8.
    Hostess
    4,169 posts
    Honey bee
    yrret107    November 28, 2009   Seattle, WA; Married in West Chester, PA

    @MrsE.ToBe : Thanks for the tip.  That's good to know I can use my flex account for that.

     
    9.
    Member Icon
    Member
    1,479 posts
    Bumble bee
    mrstilly    May 15, 2010   Ithaca, NY

    keep in mind that Medela is the only brand (that I know of) that makes a double electric pump that is not a closed system. Because it's not a closed system, only one person can use it. You aren't supposed to sell them after using them or buy them used. Because of that, I would never buy a Medela. They are far too expensive to be the only main brand that doesn't offer a closed system. 

    I have heard some rave reviews of the Hygeia Enjoye, which is also a double electric pump. It has a 3 year warranty that covers more than one user, has a 21 day money back guarantee, and is cheaper than a lot of comparable pumps. My second choice is the Ameda Purely Yours.

     
    10.
    Hostess
    5,255 posts
    Bee Keeper
    Sulli301    June 26, 2010   Michigan

    @Tessa @Lillindy

    I will also be staying at home but I purchased the Medela Pump InStyle with a coupon we recieved as part of our baby classes. It is a little pricy, $250 with coupon, but I want to be prepared incase she doesn't nurse well and to catch all that extra milk for bottle feedings. 

     
    11.
    Bee
    1,099 posts
    Bumble bee
    tiramisu    July 19, 2008   Maine

    After reading a ton of awesome reviews, I decided to go with the Hygeia Enjoye that mrstilly mentioned.  I just received it and will be doing a review of it on my blog as soon as I use it.  There's a really good review of it on the blog "My Life In Transition" if you're interested. 

    It's normally right around $300 but was recently on Zulily for $215.

     
    12.
    Member Icon
    Member
    1,479 posts
    Bumble bee
    mrstilly    May 15, 2010   Ithaca, NY

    The gentle nurturing website has the Hygeia Enjoye for the lowest price I've found online. There are three models, including the top one with an internal rechargable battery and accessory set that is going for $265. Plus they are offering 10% off all the models. I found out about gentle nurturing here.

     

     
    13.
    Member Icon
    Member
    533 posts
    Busy bee
    goodbuddy      

    I'm 35 weeks today with my first baby. I've been researching pumps like crazy too. Read rave reviews for the Medela Pump In Style, but I hear it is best for moms who are returning to work. They need it to be fast and powerful. I don't think I'll need something quite so beefy since I am staying at home. I am eying the Ameda Purely Yours double electric pump. Not super cheap, but less expensive than the Medela. Good middle-of-the-road pump. I MAY wait til I deliver to actually purchase though...just in case I have any issues with my milk. It's a substantial purchase, so I want to make sure I can actually USE it. And if I need it sooner, my hospital (and most hospitals) rent them. 

     
    14.
    Member Icon
    Member
    2,851 posts
    Sugar bee
    troubled      

    I'm just going to start off using a manual one and see if it's really a pain or not before doing a big purchase.  The Lansinoh one seems to get good reviews.  I just want to be able to throw something into my purse or pump whereever without having to lug a big machine around.  So far I've read some mixed reviews but some people seemed to prefer the manual one and I figure I'd want one anyways so I'll just start off with that.

     
    15.
    Member
    2,168 posts
    Buzzing bee
    cannotwait    February 1, 2009   TX

    My company gets us discounts on PIS & Freestyle Medelas.  I did read about the closed vs open system recently, so I can see the hesitations.  That being said, I think my freestyle rocks!  I have great supply (back to work full-time now), the parts are easy to find, and I like how portable it is!

     
    16.
    Member
    6,301 posts
    Bee Keeper
    SoontobeMrsA    June 2012   MA/NH line

    We used the PIS from Medela and then sold it after. We were told that was fine as long as your replace the tubing which did not cost much at all.

     
    17.
    Member
    1,002 posts
    Bumble bee
    MrsH1010       Chicago, IL

    I am currently renting a pump from the hospital but recently purchased one (NUK at walmart for $29). There are some obvious differences from the hospital gade, but I could not afford themore expensive pump and didnt want to spend all that money. I will be going back to work soon and I needed a quick and easy pump hat could accommodate my small office building (so everyone didnt know what I was doing lol). I have been using the NUK and although it is louder and slower than the hospital grade double Medela pump, I think it is a fine subsitute. It does the job, its handy, can be battery operated, and more comfortable.

     
    18.
    Hostess
    5,255 posts
    Bee Keeper
    Sulli301    June 26, 2010   Michigan

    Now that I have my baby girl I can better answer this thread. I bought the Medela Pump In Style and it was worth EVERY penny. I am a stay at home mom but have been pumping to get a stock of milk on hand (and my little girl is doing MUCH better now but struggled a lot at first with nursing and still isn't a quick latch-er). I use this pump atleast 3 times a day, every day and it is so easy to use! I love that I can get the parts right in town if I need them. 

     
    19.
    Member
    412 posts
    Helper bee
    shelliduke    October 17, 2009   New York, NY

    I haven't used it yet, but my sister and all of my friends who work have the medela freestyle.  It is pricey at $350 or something but they all give it rave reviews.  As to the medela pumps not able to be re-used because it is a closed system - my understanding is that the freestyle can be reused by someone else, because the motor is separate from the tubing.  You just have to buy new tubing.  My friends/coworkers say it is small, lightweight, quiet, and easy to use.  I haven't used mine yet (no baby yet!) but I do have the freestyle also. 

     
    20.
    Member
    148 posts
    Blushing bee
    wagamama    9/19/2009   Seattle

    I am renting a hospital grade pump, (my baby was born @ 35 weeks and lactation specialist wanted me to pump and breastfeed) but also received a medela pump in style for when i return to work. i really like the pump in style, it's pretty strong and does a great job. well worth the cost. i am not familiar with the one you are interested in.

     
    21.
    Member Icon
    Member
    1,479 posts
    Bumble bee
    mrstilly    May 15, 2010   Ithaca, NY

    This website has some great information on open system versus closed system breast pumps. All of the medela pumps are open system pumps. They are not meant to be used by more than one person.

    The medela site says the following on all of the models of their electric pumps:

    IMPORTANT:  This product is a single user item.  Use by more than one user may pose a health risk, performance questions, and voids the warranty.

     

    Reply

    You must log in to post.





    Visit our sister sites eHarmony
    Online Dating
    eHarmony Advice
    Dating Advice
    Project Wedding
    Wedding Songs
    JustMommies
    Pregnancy Calendar
    Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
     

    Find your vendors on Weddingbee

    Real reviews from brides in your area!

    Favors by Weddingbee

    • Favors by season

    Shop Now ยป

    Find Registry Find Registry Find Registry

    More
    User Posts Today
    ellisrobertson 24
    fishbone 22
    ndreighton 18
    Brielle 17
    Samantha7 16
    ladyartichoke 15
    rdownie1 15
    MsPanda 14
    mypinkshoes 14
    takemyhand 14

    Babies

    User Posts Today
    JewishBride 1
    SouthernGirl 1
    Beebug 1
    More