Weddingbee boards

We are having a "Vintage Hawaiian" themed wedding. Our wedding is going to be outdoors, casual, and laid back (so I hope). The boys are wearing tan suits, with Reef Sandals. It is not a destination wedding, but it is outdoors, on the beach/puget sound (seattle, WA).

THE BOYS:

This is my vision for the boys attire:

And I just purchased REEF SLAP II SANDALS from 6pm.com/zappos.com. They were having their 60% off sale so I got an AWESOME deal on 16 pairs of sandals.

THE GIRLS:

Here is a picture of the bridesmaid dresses:

When I started looking for shoes for my girls, I thought a wedge would look good with this dress. I found a sexy, dramatic, wedge and had to purchase it! Not even knowing if the color would match, or if it would even look good with the dress (thank god for 30-day returns).

Here is the "Sexy Wedges":

Shortly after purchasing...I found the 60% off reef sale online. I bought all 16 pairs of shoes for only $51 more than I purchased only 8 of these crazy wedge's for. I am sort of having buyers remorse....but love both shoes.

Here is the "Surfer Sandals":

Now that you see what the the boys will be wearing, what the bridesmaid dress looks like...and both shoes i purchased....which one would you chose? Because I am having a hard time making up my mind on this one. Thanks Ladies!