Post # 1
FI and I are entertaining the idea of having an ice cream bar at our wedding. If we decide to do it we will definitely be using Stewarts ice cream. I’ve compiled a list of our favorites but we’ll need to narrow it down to 4-5. What are your favorites? If your fav. isn’t listed, feel free to leave some delicious suggestions for us to try.
ETA: I think we’re going to do Adirondack Bear Claw regardless since we’re having an Adirondack wedding.
Post # 3
- Wedding: June 2010 - Tannery Pond at the Darrow School
Hahaha, I LOVE Stewarts Ice Cream but you don’t have my favorite flavor up there! Mine is Cotton Candy but I think I’m probably the only person over the age of 6 who likes that…
Chocolate peanut butter is prob my second, followed closely by Peanut Butter Pandemonium!
Yay Stewarts! Every time I am upstate, I make sure to get a cone 🙂
Post # 4
@trailmix: I haven’t had the cotton candy in years. Maybe I’ll have to pick up a pint next time I’m there.
Thanks for the suggestions! Both of FI’s favorites are the peanut butter. He’s petitioning for both, lol.
Post # 5
My fave is Crumbs Along the Mohawk! I like the bear paw and caramel cone, too. And I think it’s Coffee Mocha Fudge or something? It’s not as good as it used to be, but still yummy.
Post # 6
I LOVEEEEE Death by Chocolate!! mmm it’s making me hungry just thinking about it! lol
I love when they have their ice cream sale! I buy it in bulk. The other day I went to have a bowl and the freezer wasn’t working and it all melted! I was so sad. It was a sin to have to put it in the sink 🙁 lol
Post # 7
I love Stewarts 🙂 FI and I both worked there in college. That is where we met!
Post # 8
I voted for choc pb cup, but they have a new one that I LOVE! Mud Season: coffee ice cream with a pb swirl, and a brownie swirl. It is a-mazing. not sure that it will work for your ice cream bar, but you should try it 🙂
Post # 9
@thewheelsonthebus:I was also looking for Crumbs along the Mohawk on the list. I love it! Although, I also love peanut butter everything.
This thread really makes me miss Albany/Saratoga. Just a few more weeks before I get to visit home!
Post # 10
I also love their Black Sweet Cherry! Yum!
Post # 11
LOVE this post. I’m planning my wedding in Troy next year from Australia and I’m loving the idea of the Stewarts Ice Cream bar. I look forward to it every time I’m home and would be so fun to introduce my out of town guests to it!
Post # 12
I LOVE Stewarts icecream….I live in Philly now and can’t get it – but everytime I go home to visit my parents I have to have some!
Post # 13
My FI and I are both from Upstate and met in college there. So many of our date nights from that time consisted of walking to Stewarts and getting “make your own sundaes” for $1.50 each – cheapest and most delicious date ever! Unfortunately we moved many miles away last year , but we still get Stewarts ice cream every time we visit home.
Post # 14
Star gazer 🙂
But I also love a shake with mint chip!
Post # 15
@Eva Peron: I forgot all about this thread!
Post # 16
@UpstateCait: lol.. I was so excited to see there was acutally a Stewies thread! I’m living out of state right now, but going home next month for a few weeks for a bridal shower/batch party and getting their icecream is high on my list of priorities…haha