I sure hope you’re doing a Yankess-ish garter! 🙂 haha
Here are some ideas I found from doing some searching online… Hope they help!
A Yankees that I feel like looks SO classy! You could simply remove the Yankees logo from the bottom so that it doesn’t compete with your monogram 🙂
A cupcake tower – Super easy to customize with blue cupcake liners and just Yankees symbols on top
Another way to do cupcakes
Baseball Cookies (Obviously, just use the Yankees ones 🙂 lol) (The site where I got these pics has instructions on how to decorate a baseball cookie… Sounds like the baker has perfected her technique)
Another option – Jersey cookies… These look super cute, but may be more difficult to DIY
A non-edible favor option… An ornament! You could easily DIY for these with clay that you bake in your oven
A cute tag for cracker jack favors
These favors used those tags – Beer mugs filled with peanuts and cracker jacks… Cute idea, but certainly more expensive than cookies! Could definitely do it without the mugs though
Baseballs in a large vase – Elegant and fun 🙂 I like the bats and confetti too!
Baseballs set in a low bowl with moss in it 🙂
Yankees in a tall cylinder, with flowers on top – Just color coordinate the flowers with your wedding 🙂
A Yankees glass? maybe – I’m not sure what it is. With a blue light in it and a small flower bunch on top 🙂 I don’t love the execution in these pictures, but the concept is good 🙂 I think this idea could also be done with a floating candle on top, instead of the flowers
I think it’s a “baseball rose” in the center?
And baseballs in the vase – definitely not a necessity with all that’s going on here, but a cute touch 🙂
Another centerpiece option… This is totally non-floral… Very tastefully done! I like it
Another option – I like it, but it’s hard to see… Baseballs in a tall vase, with an oversized baseball on top
Ok, I really like this one too – Yankees through the years… The years could also coordinate with table numbers… This idea could also be executed in a variety of ways – Doing the years, without doing these exact centerpieces
Cute table numbers
Random Basebally Wedding Things
Seating Chart “line up” (This was obviously a phillies and Yankees wedding – Could be done with just one team though)
Cufflinks – They’d be a cute gift for your Fiance 🙂
“Guest book” — I know you said no jersey… I also have seen pics of bats/balls being signed