Costco rings?

posted 2 years ago in Rings
Post # 2
2580 posts
Sugar bee

Costco has very good quality diamonds for very reasonable price.  Only drawback is you have to take it to a jeweler for any sizing or repairs ( not really a big deal). I almost bought a yellow diamond ring from them before I fell in love with my Verragio. I would say go for it.

Post # 3
314 posts
Helper bee

I read an interesting article where the people writing the article bought a ring from Tiffany’s and a ring from Costco.  They took the rings to a gemologist (I believe) who appraised the diamonds.  Long story short, he was absolutely amazed by the quality of the diamonds in the costco ring and the amazing value versus Tiffany.  Granted, he said you are paying for a name with Tiffany’s and that Tiffany’s is well deserving of the price increase for their products, but it still made me excited to see that there are great quality diamonds at Costco.    

We dropped our Costco membership because the closest one is now over 2 hours away, but now that we are ring shopping, I will definitely be dragging the boyfriend to the ring section in Sam’s Club for a look =)

 Edit:  I found the article.  Here it is:

  • This reply was modified 2 years, 1 month ago by  Oooh_snap.
  • This reply was modified 2 years, 1 month ago by  Oooh_snap.
Post # 4
1329 posts
Bumble bee

I think they have beautiful diamonds, high quality and excellent value.

Post # 5
106 posts
Blushing bee
  • Wedding: August 2014

I think we put too much value on the ‘image’ that comes along with an engagement ring. Some people may turn up their nose at the thought that maybe a ring was bought at costco/ walmart and not some high end jewellery store where the price of the ring somehow determines the greater value. I say if it catches your eye, it’s excellent in quality and ofcourse price, then go for it.

The downside though may come with things like resizing, maintenance and even insurance and replacement. My husband bought our rings from a jewellery store and our stones are replaceable should one fall out, free of charge, once we bring them in for maintenance every 6 months. Also if I want to upgrade my e-ring, I can bringsome it in and get a different ring of equal value or pay the diff for one of more cost of my ring’s original purchasing price.

So the prices from other jewellery stores do come with some benefits. So consider that in choosing.

Hope it helps.

Post # 6
12865 posts
Honey Beekeeper
  • Wedding: June 2011

Good price for good quality, I don’t see a problem with a ring from Costco.  My mom got a gorgeous 1ct princess solitare there.

Post # 7
74 posts
Worker bee
  • Wedding: September 2015

Bought my ring at costco! They offer 100% guarantee. You can return it at any time if you’re not happy even if it’s used. I replaced mine twice looking for the perfect size. The quality of the diamonds for the price can’t be beat. 

Post # 9
329 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: May 2014

I got my wedding band from there for under $1000.  My now husband took it to an extremely reputable gemologist for them to appraise it before he had it sized.  Costco guarantees their stones to be I in color and vs in clarity.  The sign at costco said the the ring was .70ct.  The gemologist told us it was at least .76 ct, the stones were actually an E in color and it was definitely at least a VS 1 but wouldnt be able to give the exact clarity unless she took the stones out of the setting.  Our appraisal then came back more than double what we paid for it.  When we told her where we got it and how much we paid, she told us we got one hell of a deal.


go for the ring you love.  Even if you don’t like it, costco has that amazing return policy!

Post # 10
382 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: November 2015

MarriedInOregon:  FI and I bought my ring there! Can’t beat the quality for the price – we had my ring re-appraised while it was sized at another jewelers (Costco only sells a standard size 7) and my ring just appriased for 37% more in value AND  they gave me a higher clarity rating (went from a VS2 to VS1)!! I’m jumping for joy! We did this second appraisal for insurance purposes so that we would not be underinsured – I would highly reccommend doing this if you get a ring from Costco!

However, a PP said you can return ring anytime – this is not always true – if the ring has been sized or altered in anyway it cannot be returned. Costco was very clear about that policy – however you still will have a 100% gaurantee if a stone or prong comes loose. Make sure you know that if this happens they send your ring away for 6 weeks for repair…. In my opinion – I would just find a secondary jeweler (like who ever does your sizing) and have them fix any loose settings rather than be without my ring for 6 weeks.

Just know the facts before you purchase- but I absolutely love my ring and we got such a great value for what we paid! Happy ring shopping!

Post # 11
382 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: November 2015

MarriedInOregon:   PS- if it helps, I haven’t gotten a single question of “Where did he buy your ring?” People don’t ask that! (I’ve told a few of my Aunts becuase they can’t get over the quality jewelry at Costco hehe) 🙂

Post # 13
2064 posts
Buzzing bee
  • Wedding: September 2014

MarriedInOregon:  I have a friend who has a stunning diamond engagement ring from Costco. It was not inexpensive- my fiancé was with her husband when he purchased it…I believe it was around 30k, but for the specs, you would be looking at paying probably upwards of 40k buying from any other source. There was a yellow diamond ring from Costco that I fell in love with, but it was sold out by the time I got engaged. Although I dont have a Costco ring, I would highly recommend one, because I think they are an excellent value and quality. Have to admit I’m a huge Costco fan in general….so this isn’t exactly an unbiased review 😉

Leave a comment

Sent weekly. You may unsubscribe at any time.

Find Amazing Vendors