Weddingbee boards

There's a Michael's in Queens--easy to get to via the R train, I think. I've been there three times for wedding stuff. Depends on what kind of crafts you're looking for, too, you can try to get them at various locations throughout the City--there's Paper Presentation if you're looking for paper goods for invites, glues, stencils, they have ribbon and other types of things. There's Pearl Paint, which is okay, but has some stuff you might need--there's Blick on Bond Street which is better, has a ton of arts supplies. There's M&J Trimming on 6th Ave which has a ton of stuff: appliques, lace, buttons, all kinds of trim, flowers, ribbons, etc. And it's near the garment district, which has everything you'll ever need in terms of fabric and some of the stores have lots of buttons, feathers, trim, too.

Hope that helps!