- Blog
- Bios
- Boards
- Classifieds
- DIY
- Gallery
- Vendor Reviews
- Shop Weddingbee
In companion to my other thread, what is your personal preference?
I like cloth, because leather can be oh so cold or way too hot, depending on what time of year, but it definitely can make the interior look nicer....what is your preference?
I prefer cloth, because it's more temperature neutral and most car companies don't make fake leather seats. If they made fake leather with butt warmers, I might have to go with it! Leather's miserable in the summers, though, so I'd say cloth in Orlando.
Cloth. My legs don't stick to it in the summer! But I don't have a major preference either way, I'm simply more used to cloth. :)
I have leather, and while they can be quite nice when the seat warmer is on, in the summer and in the winter before the seat warms up they're just terrible. If I have a choice in the future I'll go with cloth. (I bought this car used, so I didn't have much say over the options.)
@Minutiae - I agree - we test drove cars this past weekend and it wasn't even "hot" yet, about 70 degrees maybe, and those leather seats in some of the cars made me really uncomfortable. Hubs said the better leather won't do that, and I somewhat agree, as I never get that hot in his current car (leather seats in his MINI) but sitting down on a cold or hot seat initially is never fun. My car has cloth and I like how it stays pretty neutral.
Cloth. My butt gets stuck to the leather but my parents are all about leather though. I hate hate hate leather couches, which is all they have. Ugh.
When we were car hunting I was adamant about having cloth seats. Which made getting all the features we wanted a little more difficult to find, because apparently to have fog lights and cruise control you have to have leather? We found that it was weird that "luxury" packages would have the features we wanted but always included leather. We have dogs and I'm not a fan of scratched leather. Also, I'm just not a fan of sticking to the seats or the look of it.
Hmm, we have both currently. I agree, the seat warmer is a necessity in a leather car, my FI's leather honestly isn't bad in the summer. My old Pilot with leather was hit or miss in the summer. In texas the seatbelt can burn you so I didn't care about the leather being "warm." lol
I have an X-Terra now and leather wasn't an option, but, I hate that the seats are almost permanently looking like they need help. I have a 50 lb dog that thinks it's a person riding in the seats all the time, but they always look horrible. I don't even want to think about future kids....
I've had both. The cloth got dirty and can't be cleaned - it wasn't good and I don't even eat in the car and i don't have kids. The leather just requires a leather wipe and looks great forever. I never want cloth seats again even if they do get a bit warm in summer (though I've never really noticed this; in the winter I'm wearing pants so I don't feel the seat anyway).
Great opinions, bees! Keep 'em coming...I do like the seat warmers that hubs' car has with his leather, and I do agree, it is easier to clean...good points!!
Leather all the way! You will never be able to talk me into cloth seats again now that I have bought a car with leather ... I have a 140 pound hairy dog, I can take him to the dog park, let him roll around in mud, he goes right onto the leather and it all wipes clean afterwards. Cleanup is amazingly easy, I have never noticed a scratch in the leather from dog claws. I have never stuck top the leather personally (but I am not a sweaty person, so maybe that is part of it), occasionally I find them cold in the winter, but they warm super fast with the heated seats. I haven't been "burned" by them in the summer (I actually find my black leather seats just as hot as my moms black cloth seats in the summer).
@Miss Mini - haha, I guess I am a sweaty person...but that might have something to do with me living in Florida ;)
I looooove leather seats. I hate cloth for the following reasons:
--Pet fur, clothing fuzz, cookie crumbs, etc all get stuck on it.
--Some of the fabrics will pill up.
--If it's a light color, you'll end up with dirt stains on it. I don't care how clean you are - dark colored jeans will wear their dye in to the seats, etc. This happens on my tan leather too, but it's easy to wipe off with a towel and some leather cleaner. Cloth seats - not so easy.
--Most cars now with leather have heated seats (for winter), and I have heard that some companies (like Ford and Cadillac, not sure about others) have COOLED seats also for you southern girls. (Personally, I'm a cold woman and I really LOVE sitting down on my hot seat at the end of an airconditioned day in the summer.)
--This is personal preference but I tend to see a lot of cars with patterned cloth. I'd get sick of the pattern. Some (like the Kia SOUL) even have the car's name printed in the pattern. Seems a little tacky to me. This isn't a commercial airliner, it's your car.
Mr. Mary Jane and I have leather heated seats in our cars, and I'm so glad. I have a Honda Civic EX-L (2008) and he has a Nissan Rogue SL AWD (2008). Both great cars so far.
Previously I had a 2007 Honda Civic EX with cloth seats and they were awful. Cat hair, dust, fuzz, just nasty. I'd lint-roll them daily I swear. Honestly, they were THE reason I bought a new car the very next year - Honda released one with leather.
My car before that ('92 Saab) had leather though, and my first car (an old VW bug) had vinyl, so I was already spoiled by a nice, slick, easy to maintain interior.
Wow! thanks so much for your in-depth post, maryjane! I am starting to get convinced more about leather!!
I live in Central FL, too krissycake, and I currently have leather in my Tahoe. Honestly, I think it really depends on the car. Actually, I think cars in general just get hotter than SUV's. And while I don't particularly like the regular cloth seats, my last vehicle was an H3 which had that super tough cloth (but dark in color) and it stayed really cool.It was also a breeze to keep clean and would look like new even after the dogs mudded it up.
My Tahoe is black with light leather, and it stays relatively cool as well, although I wish it had seat coolers like a BMW for the summer around here! I still hate sticking to my seats.
Cloth! I don't like how you stick to leather in the summer and it really makes you sweat! Plus, it is freezing in the winter!
Cloth!! I can't stand anything leather. Not because I am morally against it but because the smell of leather makes me nauseous :( Plus I hate that whole cold in the winter hot in the summer thing.
I have a Hyundai Sonata with CLOTH HEATED seats :) :) I have a 80 pound red lab and his fur does get everywhere but it generally stays in the backseat where no one ever sits.
Definitely leather. While cloth is more comfortable, leather is more durable. I have a daughter and a dog and being able to just clean up their messes with a leather wipe or some warm soapy water is fabulous. No waiting for it to dry...no riding around looking like somebody had a mud fight in my truck...just wipe and go. In the summer months I keep a towel in the truck to sit on so I won't stick to the seats.
My car has leather seats and while I love the look of them (when they're new) I much rather prefer cloth. Aside from them getting hot and sticky in the summer, you have to condition them and clean them often to prevent cracking - which unfortunately my seats have begun to do.
My car has cloth and FH's has leather and I HATE getting into his car in the winter if he hasn't pre-heated it first. Burrrr, my poor bum!
I prefer cloth, but also want to get heated seats with my next car, which (as far as I've seen) is only available with leather seats. But seats being heated trumps whatever they are made out of! :)
I'll never buy another car with cloth seats, leather all the way! It's so easy to clean, I have the butt warmer in my seat (I live in Canada, this is a must) and I don't find them too hot in the summer. I know a lot of car companies are starting to offer air conditioning in the seats like butt warmers so that would be pretty neat! I'm car hunting too and if it has cloth seats it automatically gets crossed off the list.
Cloth, it's got more longevity especially here in the hot LA sun. Leather cracks so easily and cloth well it can get dirty but you can clean that up at least!
This is something we go back and forth on for our next car, and even now as we are furniture shopping for our family room!
I love how easy leather is to clean compared to cloth, but I hate how cold it is in the winter (except now they are making heated seats!) and how sticky it is in the summer. Sorry I'm no help, but I'd lean towards leather after reading this thread, especially Mrs. MJs points!
Cloth all the way! I'm from the south and those leather seats get HOT HOT HOT! When you're wearing a skirt, Being branded is NOT a nice feeling.
@gabrielleelise1981: my 2005 hyundai sonata has cloth seats with heated driver/front passenger seats :)
ahhh, i think leather is the worst--I can't believe how close the poll is!
Maybe it's because I started in a state (IL) where the cold leather just bites at your leg and takes forever to warm up (no seat warmers)
And now I live in CA where leather seats scorch my thighs because of the heat! No es bueno. Cloth all the way.
Wow, the polls are evening up! So glad to hear from bees from all over - of course, we live in FL now, but might not always live here, and this car we're thinking of getting will be a keeper (for at least 5-10 years)
@bree72 - interesting thought about car temps in cars vs. SUVs! definitely something to keep in mind!!
I've had both.
Leather:
PROS
Cleans easily
Looks nice at first
CONS
Cracks! Requires upkeep or it will fail
Too hot in the summer, too cold in the winter
Expensive to repair (can be damaged by animal claws, or sharp things stowed on it, or heavy items stowed on it for long periods of time)
Cloth:
PROS
Durable
Comfortable
Cheaper to repair than leather
CONS
Gathers animal hair and lint
Not a luxe look
I prefer to buy cars with cloth now. Since I detail the inside of my car weekly, I don't have to worry about the animal hair, crumbs, lint, etc. It always looks nice!
I should point out for those who said leather cracks in hot climates -- I condition my leather every year in the fall. (for us, its winter when it's worrysome - with the extreme cold). Doesn't take much, just some leather conditioner (less than 6 bucks at walmart, comes in a spray bottle like most cleaning solutions). You just spray that on your seats and wipe them down. If you're worried about your leather cracking, what do you do about your dash?! Plastic/vinyl dashboards are much more prone to cracking than leather. [They sell a spray/wipe for that too.]
For those who said their legs stick to it... I swear I am not trying to be snarky here but um... this keeps coming to mind
...
Do you wear pants while driving? hehe. Generally the city laws frown upon driving around in your undies! (Yeah, I know y'all probably have better legs than old Mary Jane here so you wear cute skirts and shortyshorts.) But really thats what I keep thinking! "Wear pants and the seat wont stick!!" hehe. I never wear any shorts or skirts shorter than the knee, so that is probably why I don't have that issue.
Cloth all the way! Leather might look nicer, but I find cloth feels nicer.
I've had leather for almost a year now and I absolutely love it! Anything that spills wipes up easily. I can let people ride in the back seat without worrying about them getting dog hair all over them. And I've never stuck to them.
Leather will be on the criteria list for any car I get later in life.
Cloth, with the exception of my mom's Mini Cooper, which has a fake leather (doesn't hold temperatures like it though, AND has butt warmers!!!!!!) which I called pleather at the dealership and got MANY a mean glance, LOL. It's fake leather, but NOT pleather. It's really the best car interior I've ever seen.
@maryjane, lol, i dunno, i like to drive around in my undies
Not =]
Volkswagon also has heated cloth seats. My roommate just bought a new car. The cloth isn't super thick and plush, but really smooth and it's so weird to feel your bum warming up.
@Maryjane - lol, I wear short shorts I guess!? But really, here in FL, yeah, sometimes wear swimsuit cover ups and things in the car coming home from the beach and stuff.
I can't stand leather seats or leather furniture! It's either too hot or too cold.
I just replied to your other post.. i picked the Edge out of those. I personally don't care one way or another btwn leather and cloth.. my car is cloth, my husband's leather. If you like leather but are worried it'll be hot - just get window tint! i can't imagine why you wouldn't tint your car anyway, since orlando is hot and sunny as balls. If you have the tint, the leather will be just fine and look pretty slick, too.
Valhalla you wouldn't like my house! Leather sofa, loveseat, and chair. we have a big old leather club chair upstairs, too. If we went shopping today, we'd probably choose cloth for the sofas but stick to leather with the chair. SO much easier to clean and doesn't hold all the cat hair.
@MelissaBegins - excellent point on the window tint. Hubby has window tint in his car and I don't in my cloth seated Honda Civic, but I've never felt too hot in mine, besides the seatbelt and stuff. Thanks again - I cannot believe I didn't consider that!
depends on personal preference, obviously, i'm saying leather! i have 2 kids, who puke, eat, and all kinds of craziness in my car. I am prone to spilling things all the time! I am all about leather due to that. And yes its hot as hell in the summer, but i use one of those window reflecting things so the sun won't come into your windshield when i park, and its fine.
You must log in to post.
| Visit our sister sites | eHarmony Online Dating |
eHarmony Advice Dating Advice |
Project Wedding Wedding Songs |
JustMommies Pregnancy Calendar |

| User | Posts Today |
|---|---|
| aussiebee | 10 |
| MrsOliveBird | 9 |
| janetsnakehole | 8 |
| j_jaye | 5 |
| Rivendeler | 5 |
| simpleandchic | 4 |
| Scottish_lassie | 4 |
| Adalita | 4 |
| MabelleBliss | 3 |
| Sarahbear | 3 |
| User | Posts Today |
|---|---|
| MrsOliveBird | 1 |
| ticatica | 1 |