Can I see your all-rose bouquet?
more by MaraBeth
Colored Uplighting Inspiration Pics?
What did you read to prepare for parenting?
more in Parenting
Spinoff: Drinking While Parenting
Photo Intensive Recap 2: Getting Ready! (pic heavy)
more in Boards
Strange things happening to body- assuming it's pregnancy related!

Do you subscribe to a specific method of parenting? How did you decide?

posted 7 months ago in Parenting
  • 1 Members Subscribed To Topic
  •  
    1.
    Member
    2,247 posts
    Buzzing bee
    MaraBeth    December 3, 2011   Dallas, TX

    We're not really close to TTC yet, but a friend of mine is pregnant and we got to talking about spanking/discipline and all of the books she's read and it made me curious to hear some moms' opinions! I keep hearing about all of these things like attachment parenting, etc and wanted to see what parents have to say. I've been wondering:

    Do you subscribe to a specific method of parenting (a specific expert, strategy, book, etc)?

    How did you pick it?

    Do you raise your children in a similar way to how your parents raised you? How did you reconcile that with the different experiences of your DH/SO?

     
    2.
    Member
    3,001 posts
    Sugar bee
    vmec    May 12, 2012   Vancouver

    I susbcribe to "cry all you want... you ain't getting it."

     
    3.
    Member
    2,169 posts
    Buzzing bee
    regberadaisy    August 14, 2010  

    I'm pregnant now and it's hard to say until I'm actually a parent.

    But I can tell you I won't be following any "method" because some individual came up with it. We'll parent how my husband and I deem best not because of some book or blog.

     
    4.
    Member
    2,247 posts
    Buzzing bee
    MaraBeth    December 3, 2011   Dallas, TX

    @regberadaisy: Talking to my friend, that's sort of how I felt, too, but she brought up a lot of parenting ideologies I'd never heard of and it got me thinking about how we would decide what's right for us. I know there's no perfect method, but I'd be curious how parents are influenced by research or results of certain styles of parenting.

     
    5.
    Member
    1,398 posts
    Bumble bee
    Miss Sapphire    December 2009   Seattle

    We use the "children have manners, use them", "children can cope without being talked to like a baby", and the always helpful "children can adapt as long as their parents don't coddle them".

    Most of the baby books end up pissing me off at some point.

     
    6.
    Member Icon
    2,541 posts
    Sugar bee
    piglet_625    January 1, 1991  

    I'm not a parent yet, but I think that DH and I will likely look to our parents and close friends who have great kids for advice and help along the way.  Both sets of our parents are incredible people and were even more incredible parents, so I will likely do a lot of the same things they did or ask for advice from them. 

    While I think books or specific methods can be helpful, I think seeing it in real life with real kids is more effective.  Obviously all kids are different and what works for one won't always work for the other, but on the whole, I think seeing it in action is the best thing for me.

     
    7.
    Hostess
    5,534 posts
    Bee Keeper
    Mrs. Spring    May 10, 2009   California

    I felt really drawn to attachment parenting when I first heard about it because a lot of the philosophies fit with my personality and personal beliefs.  Having a child is bound to change your pre-concieved notions of parenting, though, and like every other parent I know, we've learned to adjust our parenting techniques to DD's unique personality and individuality.  Now, I would say we're don't really parent by a "label."  Although we have stuck by some of the principles we originally liked with AP, we've had to consider alternatives to others because they just didn't work out.

    I don't think we're raising DD like our parents raised us; I think our parents were a lot more authoritarian in their parenting styles.  It is hard negotiating parenting decisions, especially because disagreements are bound to happen and compromising on parenting decisions is a lot harder (at least for us).  Our current arrangement is that, if we have a disagreement on a particular decision, we both discuss our opinions.  If one person feels really strongly about the issue, and the other person isn't as invested, one of us will usually "give in."  If both of us feel equally strong about the issue, whoever "wins" gets to deal with the consequences of that decision.  So far, we've only had to resort to this on one issue; the rest of the time we eventually come to a consensus or compromise of some sort.

     
    8.
    Member
    2,441 posts
    Buzzing bee
    jjmomma    March 11, 2011  

    I'm reading How To Behave So Your Toddler Does, Too and I like it.  It's not a methodology as much as it is a practical breakdown of discipline.  I wish I had studied more of the theories out there, but my sister is a parenting educator so I just turn to to her for advice! 

    I have little insights about what works for me and what doesn't, if you're interested in hearing those.  I wish I could speak to specific methods for you... I know I've seen some good discussions on this site, so you're certain to find some bees who are more informed.

     
    9.
    Member
    2,247 posts
    Buzzing bee
    MaraBeth    December 3, 2011   Dallas, TX

    I know one method is usually not a catch-all for all situations, but I'd like to know how people decide a certain strategy or ideology meshes with their parenting style. For example, I've read the threads here on things like elimination communication and co-sleeping--how did you decide something like this was right for you?

     
    10.
    Member
    2,625 posts
    Sugar bee
    plantains    July 17, 2011   Live in NY, wedding in CT

    Honestly, all the various ideologies make me nervous. I just can't shke the feeling that I'm making some othe person rich for no reason.

     
    11.
    Member
    2,247 posts
    Buzzing bee
    MaraBeth    December 3, 2011   Dallas, TX

    @Mrs. Spring: Thanks for your perspective, that's really interesting! I've been curious, what exactly is attachment parenting?

    @jjmomma: I think that book is on my friend's list, too! As a very worried soon-to-be new mom, I think she's trying to read a little of everything to find what works for her.

     
    12.
    Hostess
    5,534 posts
    Bee Keeper
    Mrs. Spring    May 10, 2009   California

    @MaraBeth:  For me personally, co-sleeping and elimination communication just made sense.  My whole family co-sleeps (like extended family and all), so it was a concept very familiar to me.  I just did research on safe co-sleeping during pregnancy and bought a co-sleeper for the newborn stage so my husband would also feel comfortable the decision.  I didn't know anyone who had done EC before we had our daughter, but when I first heard about it, I thought it was awesome!  My husband was totally on board when I brought it up, so that was an easy decision.

    In other areas, some things are more trial and error.  I wanted to breastfeed, but it didn't end up working out, so we formula fed instead (and it was great for us!).  I wanted to co-sleep with DD until at least year, but we ended up transitioning her to her crib in the nursery at 11 months, when it became unsafe.  We kinda meshed techniques from Dr. Sears' The Discipline Book and Positive Discipline: 0 -3 to find a method for dealing with DD's tantrums.  As she gets older, we'll probably continue to research through books, blogs, and personal conversations for each challenging development and then try out the ideas we like best.

    ETA:  Attachment Parenting is a parenting philosophy created by Dr. William Sears.  He (and now his sons) have written books on the techniques and the basic philosophies of AP, and then others have expanded on it through websites, magazines, etc...  The basic premise of AP is that children who form a strong "attachment" to their caregiver(s) are more likely to grow into compassionate, caring, well-adjusted adults.  The whole AP style is about creating and nuturing that attachment through each stage of life (infancy through adulthood).

     
    13.
    Member
    2,441 posts
    Buzzing bee
    jjmomma    March 11, 2011  

    @Mrs. Spring:  Just curious why co-sleeping became unsafe at 11 months?

     
    14.
    Hostess
    5,534 posts
    Bee Keeper
    Mrs. Spring    May 10, 2009   California

    @jjmomma:  DD selpt between me and mesh guardrail on the side of the bed.  She started walking at 10 months, and got really good at it by 11 months, when she started waking up in the middle of the night to "practice."  I woke up once in the middle of the night just as she was standing up straight on the bed and started trying to walk toward the (2 foot) guard rail at the side of the bed.  At that point, we decided it would be safer for her to sleep in her crib all the time, because she can't fall out, even during midnight walking practice.  :)

     
    15.
    Member
    2,262 posts
    Buzzing bee
    bree72    December 31, 2008  

    @plantains: They make me nervous, too, but for a completely different reason. I am so afraid that I am not reading the right things and am going to miss taking advantage of some great ideal that is going to lead my (currently unborn) child to disaster; or at least really terrible behavior. I feel like I don't know what I should be doing and that I should be learning all I can during my pregnancy, which is just making me more and more nervous. 

     
    16.
    Member Icon
    Member
    568 posts
    Busy bee
    Lozza    September 1, 2007  

    @Mrs. Spring:  I just went and ordered both of those books :)

     
    17.
    Hostess
    5,534 posts
    Bee Keeper
    Mrs. Spring    May 10, 2009   California

    @Lozza:  I LOVED the Positive Discipline book.  :)  It totally changed my perspective on how to be nuturing but not smothering (which I have a tendency to do, lol).  Plus it puts a lot more emphasis on parenting to developmental stages, which I felt was a little lacking from the traditional AP books.

     
    18.
    Member Icon
    Member
    2,851 posts
    Sugar bee
    troubled      

    I knew I wouldn't be a one size fits all parent, we fostered lots of puppies (like actual puppies 8 weeks -20 weeks) and even with puppies their temperments gave way for different techniques working better for different ones. 

    I read a lot on forums and blogs and books and then would research on pubmed or wherever people had research listed.  I also got ideas from watching some parents of what I liked/didin't like.

    We're doing a form of elimination communication because that's how we were raised and it worked out well, I watched 3 younger siblings love the potty but some of my friends who've waited longer have had issues with potty fear.  We're kinda making our own way to do it for what works for us and baby.

    I was really turned off of attachment parenting by some forums I read and after watching a friend struggle with it.  But then I started to realize I'm more against strict labels and doing stuff for namesake rather than what works for baby and family.  

    Most of what we do is because it optimizes baby/mommy/daddy happiness and has research to say it's beneficial or at least not harmful while taking into consideration her age.  Babywearing to me makes life easier and she likes it but it's not like we never put her down, she's out of our arms a lot too.  I like her sleeping in our room but not in our bed and roomsharing is another thing in addition to sleeping on backs thats supposed to protect against sids.  Happiest Baby on the Block is a wonderful thing.  Most other books though talk in absolutes but really you have to take them with a grain of salt.  I was really annoyed with my LLL nursing book until a few weeks after I had baby and was comfortable in mommy skin and knew what stuff just to get over and what part of advice I needed.  

     
    19.
    Member
    2,247 posts
    Buzzing bee
    MaraBeth    December 3, 2011   Dallas, TX

    @Mrs. Spring: Very interesting, thanks for all of the information! Even though we're not currently TTC, I am really interested in positive discipline. I work with children and I've learned a lot through experience and interaction with parents about what I think are effective/ineffective means of discipline.

    I feel consistency, fairness, and follow-through are all extremely important factors in discipline, so to me, I think it would probably be helpful to at least start with a book or particular strategy. Even though I'm sure we would have to alter it to suit the child, I feel like it would help to be on the same page as your partner about basic ways of dealing with things like misbehavior.

     
    20.
    Hostess
    5,534 posts
    Bee Keeper
    Mrs. Spring    May 10, 2009   California

    @MaraBeth:  I think talking with your partner about your individual experiences and parenting expectations is a great way to start the dialogue.  You can have these discussions even before TTC, just to get a feeling of how each of you view parenting.  Through discussion, you'll discover a parenting path that reflects you as a couple, and from there, you can start formalizing your approach.  Good luck!  I'm sure you'll figure it out.  :)

     
    21.
    Member Icon
    Member
    1,479 posts
    Bumble bee
    mrstilly    May 15, 2010   Ithaca, NY

    I read a lot of books and just got overwhelmed so I took them all back to the library and haven't opened a parenting book since. We didn't co-sleep (just a few times in the first 2 months) because DH didn't feel safe doing so. I got better sleep with DS out of our bed and in the cradle right next to me, and ended up waking up all the way to feed/change him anyway. We just do what feels right and seems to work. It's constantly a work in progress.

     

    @MaraBeth: I feel consistency, fairness, and follow-through are all extremely important factors in discipline.

    This is how DH and I plan to start off. If we have trouble or disagree, we'll figure it out.

    DH was raised with a much heavier hand than I was, but our priorities are the same - trust, hard work, honesty, compassion. Consistency is the number one factor in getting a child to behave. Set an (age and developmentally appropriate) expectation, and then model and follow through every single time! Being inconsistent because you don't want to make a scene or be inconvenienced will shoot yo in the foot every single time and make it worse the next time.

     
    22.
    Member
    5,232 posts
    Bee Keeper
    amnystik    April 9, 2011   Texas

    With DS I was pretty structured in daily routine and sleep in his first 2 years so that eliminated alot of the issues I saw some of my friends had with having no order in the day. DS, along with the other babies I watched, really thrived on routine and consistency so that's a BIG thing for me.

    As for disciplining, DH and I really really love a series by Joe McGee called "Biblical Parenting 101". Even if you're not a Christian the concepts of encouragement, filling with good praise, and consistently punishing or not allowing rebellion (without acting in anger) are just awesome! It's more about building up your child so they can make the right decisions on their own, as opposed to some disciplinarians that are more about "because I said so" (which we do not do in our house) We seriously re-watch it every few months when we can tell we've been getting a little lax, or lazy, in certain areas. I recommend it to EVERYONE b/c it covers everything from the young years to growing your children to adults and how to still parent (from a different position) while their in college years. And the guy is HILARIOUS! You will surely laugh! We're fixing to add his "8 things No Kid Should Leave Home Without" as well =)

    I know this go round will have a whole new set of things since now instead of 1 I'll have 2 kiddos, but again I just get a good refresher course and start again. lol

     
    23.
    Member
    1,117 posts
    Bumble bee
    MissEdamame    July 2009  

    @amnystik: From witnessing the experiences of close family members and friends, it seems to me that most infants and toddlers are much better at physically and emotionally coping when they have a fairly structured daily schedule (which makes sense to me, since they're less likely to be hungry or tired!)

    When my sisters and I were small, I know our parents had a fairly strict schedule, but this made things predictable for us as toddlers. Our youngest nephew is held to a fairly similar standard for his daily routine, and he is a very well-behaved and happy toddler.

    Some of their behavior definitely depends on temperment, but I think ensuring that they have a predictable, stable schedule, allowing them plenty of time to rest, goes a long way towards raising physically and emotionally healthy kids.

     
    24.
    Member
    2,219 posts
    Buzzing bee
    Beluga    July 16, 2011  

    I follow the Spartan method. 

     
    25.
    Member
    2,179 posts
    Buzzing bee
    bklynbridetobe    December 2011   Brooklyn Born

    @mrstilly: was, but our priorities are the same - trust, hard work, honesty, compassion. Consistency is the number one factor in getting a child to behave. Set an (age and developmentally appropriate) expectation, and then model and follow through every single time! Being inconsistent because you don't want to make a scene or be inconvenienced will shoot yo in the foot every single time and make it worse the next time.

    THIS! Frankly I'm not going to over think it or buy any disapline books. Everything I've learned from dealing with children has been thru trial/error and ton of common sense. ie when you kid is throwing a trantum you don't give in to their demands. YOU are the parent. You stay firm and consistant, address the problem right away in age apporiate language. Kids immediately respond to rewards and consequences. We are not our childs "friend", their are not our equals, we don't care if they like us, but they will respect us as the leaders of our household. Its our responsblity to have a united front. And to @MissEdamame: point we also agree on about keeping them on a fairly consistant shedule as well.  Children respond best to firm boundries. Overall we hope to sitck to this plan and to be firm & fair 80% of the time. I'm sure we will fall short sometimes but thats okay.

     
    26.
    Member
    431 posts
    Helper bee
    red_seattle    April 17, 2010   Seattle

    @Miss Sapphire: I worry about buying into any particular parenting model as well, and your philosophies sound similar to mine. Instilling adaptability in kids seems to be under-rated. And, I mean, I want to try to always act lovingly towards my child... but not to coddle. IMO, that's why we're dealing with so many entitlement issues with kids now. And I'm afraid a lot of current philosophies result in kids who are too dependent on their parents. 

    My plan is to just keep my eyes on the prize: raising a child to be a responsible, independent, considerate adult who contributes positively to society. If my actions as a parent don't encourage that, then I'm doing something wrong, but otherwise, I'm not going to worry about one method of parenting vs. another.

     
    27.
    Member
    2,113 posts
    Buzzing bee
    misschickpea    October 26, 2013   Austin, TX

    @Beluga: Niiiiiiicceee!!

     
    28.
    Member
    1,454 posts
    Bumble bee
    Ronneykay    May 11, 2013   Phoenix/ Vow Renewal In Las Vegas 5/11/13

    @vmec:

    I agree!!! 100%.

     

    And the "I said "no" do you think if you keep bugging me I will change my mind?" method.

    Kids get it pretty quick.  I know someone who gives into her kids ALL the time because she would rather do that then hear them cry.  However, when I am around, they know better than to play me, and they are better behaved. 

    Children are master manipulators. 

     

     

     
    29.
    Member
    1,378 posts
    Bumble bee
    Take The Reins    August 11, 2012   Canada

    @bklynbridetobe: I agree with your statement 100%.

    I am a firm ruler in my house.  FI is softer, but he's learning, and I let him deal with the consequences when he makes a less than adult decision!

     

    Reply

    You must log in to post.





    Visit our sister sites eHarmony
    Online Dating
    eHarmony Advice
    Dating Advice
    Project Wedding
    Wedding Songs
    JustMommies
    Pregnancy Calendar
    Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
     

    Find your vendors on Weddingbee

    Real reviews from brides in your area!

    Favors by Weddingbee

    • Favors by season

    Shop Now ยป

    Find Registry Find Registry Find Registry

    More
    User Posts Today
    aussiebee 10
    MrsOliveBird 9
    janetsnakehole 8
    j_jaye 5
    Rivendeler 5
    simpleandchic 4
    Scottish_lassie 4
    Adalita 4
    MabelleBliss 3
    Sarahbear 3

    Parenting


    Sorry, there are no users yet.


    More