Table number holders?
more by lily1223
Caramel Apples
Cake Question in need of your opinion!
more in Food
Ribbon for wedding cake?
Green (eco friendly) Weddings Wanted
more in Boards
Affordable/Reasonable flowers in Chicagoland??

Fake the Cake?

posted 3 years ago in Food
  •  
    1.
    Member Icon
    Member
    68 posts
    Worker bee
    lily1223      

    Do you think fake cakes are tacky, or smart?  I'm thinking of doing one, but I'm reading a lot of negativity online- one person even called it 'dishonest.'  Are fake cakes dumb?  We're on a budget.

    Attachments

    1. Fake the Cake? :  wedding fake cake diy Img 3179AA1.jpg (8 KB, 78 downloads) 2 years old
    2. Fake the Cake? :  wedding fake cake diy Img 3179AA.jpg (5.6 KB, 53 downloads) 2 years old
     
    2.
    Member Icon
    Member
    742 posts
    Busy bee
    TallBride    January 24 2009   Westlake Village, Ca

    Do what your budget allows you too. I'm not sure how much money they save but if its signifacant I say do it, no one will notice they're eatting sheet cake.

     
    3.
    Member Icon
    Member
    26 posts
    Newbee
    KLHM      

    It can be considered green!  See the California Courting entry on Real Green Weddings - http://realgreenweddings.blogspot.com/

     
    4.
    Member
    2,168 posts
    Buzzing bee
    cannotwait    February 1, 2009   TX

    If you find a great deal, pls let me know!

     
    5.
    Member
    409 posts
    Helper bee
    HistoryBride    6/27/09   Plymouth, MI

    I think fake cakes are a little silly, it's just buying into what the wedding world tells you you have to have.  If you want sheet cakes, go for sheet cakes.  No one is going to care.  Cut a cupcake, heck, don't even serve cake, cut a pie or have individual little deserts.  You can be creative, and it will only make your wedding more unique.

     
    6.
    Member Icon
    Member
    29 posts
    Newbee
    cammie    5/30/09  

    My personal opinion is that it is a great way to save some money if you want to have a traditional cake for pics, etc.  Nobody will notice the difference when the cake is cut.  I certainly wouldn't think that it is 'dishonest', and I doubt that your guests would either.  I also think that there are plenty of other great dessert options if you are on a budget and aren't really attached to the cake.  Really, it's dessert...how can you go wrong!

     
    7.
    Member Icon
    Member
    64 posts
    Worker bee
    jcandy    May 16, 2009   Wheeling, IL

    Ok, "dishonest" is a little harsh when we're talking about cake. As a guest, all I would care about is that the cake looks good and tastes great. It doesn't matter if it was from a sheet cake or not. Besides, I've worked in the hotel banquets business, the cake turns into a gigantic mess when they cut it up in the back and a good chunk of it gets thrown out because they cut the pieces so small to make sure they have enough for everyone.

     
    8.
    Hostess
    2,252 posts
    Buzzing bee
    chelseamorning    November 1, 2008   Washington, DC/Atlanta

    We talked about doing a fake cake or a fake layer to the cake and the price we got from our baker was not much different from that of a real cake. The cost of the styrofoam and the icing ingredients and labor time added up to much more than we expected. We just went with a slightly smaller traditional wedding cake than we had planned instead.

     
    9.
    Member Icon
    Member
    157 posts
    Blushing bee
    Krista    June 6, 2009   Kingston, Ontario

    My parent's cake (in 1978) was kind of a fake cake. Apparently, the bottom layer was real cake, and the top 2 layers were fake (styrofoam? or whatever it is they use). Or maybe it was the top layer that was real, and the bottom layers were fake. I'd have to ask my mom again, but either way: 2 layers were fake. They like the look of layers, but it wasn't a large enough wedding to need layers. They would have had a lot of leftover cake if they had had real layers of cake.

    So, I say it's GREEN to have fake layers if you like the look of layers, but don't need the layers!

    As for the cost, if you have a sheet cake, chelseamorning makes a good point. I know some people who have had fake layers plus a styrofoam cake because it was cheaper, so it must depend on the baker and the design.

    I say price it out, and do what makes sense, do not worry about what's dishonest. I say honesty is two people getting married who love each other in front of their family & friends. The rest is just details! :) (But oh how I love the details ... :)  

    Attachments

    1. Fake the Cake? :  wedding fake cake diy Img Intro-header.jpg (81.1 KB, 43 downloads) 2 years old
     
    10.
    Member Icon
    Member
    122 posts
    Blushing bee
    tater    10/11/08   CT

    I'm having a fake cake and it will actually benefit the guests....  I found an amazing cake "artist" who creates beautiful fondant cakes, but they taste like crap.  So I am using her to design a gorgeous looking fake (the top tier will be real for cutting) and will be having an awesome bakery make sheet cakes of the most delicious cake I have ever tasted- best of both worlds! Fake the Cake? :  wedding fake cake diy Icon Biggrin Plus for some crazy reason the fancy cake designer is only charging me 1/4 of her real cake price- I guess she really loves making sugar flowers....  both cakes for 140 guest will be costing me a total of $300 - my original budget had been $500. 

    I wouldn't worry about people who think the idea is "silly or dishonest", I bet they don't even realize that they have probably been to plenty of "fake cake" weddings!

     
    11.
    Member Icon
    Member
    195 posts
    Blushing bee
    MrsFroggy    November 08   Asheville

    My opinion is: instead of payinf for a fake cake, just get a smaller cake or just a sheat cake that is beautifully decorated.

    A cake does not need to be 4 stories high to be pretty.

    We are not going to have a traditionnal wedding cake. I'd rather go for a variety of tastes, our plan is to have seasonal cakes. I know I want a pumpkin cheescake and will probably get that one decorated so we get the fun of cutting it. My hubby wants a red velvet cake and after talking with our baker she also suggested an apple cake and a hummingbird cake.

    You should look online for picture of one layer cake and how they were decorated, you can find something really pretty. Or just have the family bake things with family recipes, it can make it even more meaninful that way.

     
    12.
    Member Icon
    Member
    78 posts
    Worker bee
    cassiereanne    10/11/2008   Leavenworth, KS

    We are doing a little 2 tier cake and then we are having sheet cakes.  This will save us money....but we will still have a cute "traditional" cake to cute into. :)

     
    13.
    Member Icon
    Member
    197 posts
    Blushing bee
    marianneinvan       Vancouver, BC

    Fake cakes seem wasteful to me, since they'll just end up in the trash at the end of the night. :(  What about a small cutting cake, and then serving your guests from a sheet cake?

     
    14.
    Hostess
    2,704 posts
    Sugar bee
    KateMW    8.30.03   Birmingham

    I don't think it's tacky, but it's a waste and it probably won't save you any money. The price is mainly made up of decorating and labor costs, not the actual cake.

     
    15.
    Member Icon
    Member
    5 posts
    Newbee
    maren    July '08   Texas

    Only the top layer of our cake was real, the other two were fake. We took this route for several reasons:

    Our venue was outside in the summer and we were worried about the icing melting.

    The sheet cake tastes way better! (Buttercream icing instead of fondant)

    Plus, it was a little bit cheaper to get the fake cake + sheet cake than the tiered cake. We actually ended up getting more pieces for less money that way.

     I'm not sure the guests would even notice, since you often take the cake away to cut it then out come pieces of cake on plates.

     
    16.
    Hostess
    843 posts
    Busy bee
    LLauRRa    10/10/09   Dallas, TX

    Unless they are pitching in money to pay for a real cake, I wouldn't worry about what they think. Do what makes you happy. :)

     

    -Laura 

     
    17.
    Member
    197 posts
    Blushing bee
    LeiAnn    May 2009   Florida

    Wow, I had no idea some people were so against fake cakes. We'll be having a fake cake at our wedding (well, 1 real layer for cutting) and I love the idea. I totally agree with Maren that it's great for summer weddings and the buttercream tastes way better than fondant. Also, you don't have to worry as much about them dropping a heavy 3 or 4 tiered cake because you have sheet cakes which transport well and the fake is light.

     
    18.
    Member Icon
    Member
    14 posts
    Newbee
    sfgal      

    My friend actually had a fake cake at her wedding. It wasn't planned. Very last minute that her venue pulled together because her cake never showed up.

    Bakery was closed. There was no way to contact bakery, thus reception site went out and found a store display cake and bought a ton of sheet cake.

    All in all no one knew.

    I really like this site for fake cakes. The cakes have a compartment to hide a real slice of cake.

    http://www.cakerental.com/about_us.html

     

    But all in all, everything is up to you.

     
    19.
    Bee Icon
    Bee
    545 posts
    Busy bee
    sunbeam      

    I think a fake cake is completely tacky. 

    Why make your guests think they are getting a piece of the "cake" on display then pull a fast one and feed them the sheet cake in the back?  I think you can make a lovely small cake if you need to save on money, guests will realize they are not necessarily getting a peice of it, and have sheet cake or whatever in the back.  I don't see the point in having a huge fake cake sitting around.  That's just me.

     
    20.
    Member Icon
    Member
    45 posts
    Newbee
    Senonasun       Boston

    I think faux cakes are a great way to save money and to use your creativity!

     

    I just did a faux wedding cake that cost me $15.00!  I get my dessert buffet but won't have to spend hundreds of dollars.

     You can check out the steps to make one at my blog:

    http://peachesbyplums.wordpress.com/2009/03/02/wedding-cake-diy-style/

     

    Good Luck! 

     
    21.
    Member Icon
    Member
    69 posts
    Worker bee
    e.louise    10/24/09   Austin

    I think faux cakes are a great way to save money.  Another option you might want to consider is having one or two layers of real cake (so you can cut it) and the other ones faux.  Or you could do a smaller cake and supplement with sheet cake (this is what we will be doing because feeding 250 people cake at $3.50+ a slice is rediculous).  Do what you are comfortable with- either way, your guests probably won't notice Fake the Cake? :  wedding fake cake diy Icon Biggrin

     
    22.
    Member Icon
    Member
    1,428 posts
    Bumble bee
    ErinMarguerite    July 2009   DC Area

    I'm going the fake cake route.  I know several people here have mentioned that it's not necessarily cheaper, but it depends on your baker.  Our baker is charging us the price she charges for sheet cakes for things like birthday parties, rather than the wedding mark up.  We're getting a fake cake and two sheet cakes to serve 150 guests for $300.  In DC.  The second cheapest bid I got was going to be $900. 

    It's the only option for us for another reason: we have an outdoor ceremony in summer.  Our baker was quite concerned that the cake would melt and the tiers would all slide apart. 

    @Aerika, I don't think it's it's an issue of being deceitful.  And I don't think it matters.  People think they are getting a slice of cake and they are getting a slice of cake.  One that hasn't been frozen and baked in enough time for it to be perfectly decorated.

     

    Reply

    You must log in to post.

    Tags:





    Visit our sister sites eHarmony
    Online Dating
    eHarmony Advice
    Dating Advice
    Project Wedding
    Wedding Songs
    JustMommies
    Pregnancy Calendar
    Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
     

    Find your vendors on Weddingbee

    Real reviews from brides in your area!

    Favors by Weddingbee

    • Favors by season

    Shop Now ยป

    Find Registry Find Registry Find Registry

    More
    User Posts Today
    fivemonthsnotice 17
    ticatica 14
    MrsOliveBird 11
    aussiebee 11
    pinkandsparkly 10
    Lyndzo 10
    countrygirl62312 8
    s.renea9 8
    Rivendeler 8
    janetsnakehole 8

    Food

    User Posts Today
    csperry2 1
    bythebook 1
    More