Vietnam, Thailand or Malaysia, cant decide.. any advice?
more by simpleandchic
Have the dress now for the shoes.......
help how to make pics of ering small to upload on wedding bee
more in Rings
How did you know the right engagement ring for you?
Looking for Maggie Sottero kennedy
more in Boards
LDRs are not my friend :(

Fiance who keeps going on about the price....

posted 2 years ago in Rings
  • 1 Members Subscribed To Topic
  •  
    1.
    Member
    1,846 posts
    Buzzing bee
    simpleandchic    November 27, 2010   Adelaide, South Australia

    My FH keeps complaing about how much we spent on the rings, engagement and wedding. My engagement ring cost $8000 and my wedding band will cost $2200. I know that it is a lot of money but I feel that as it took 8 years for him to propose I kind of diserved it. His band would have cost $800 but our jewler had a deal of buy one band and get the second half price. ever since we ordered the bands he keeps going on about how he doesn't know anyone else who had to spend 10K on rings. It is sort of tainting the whole experience.

    Also I have heard that the engagement ring should generally be 3 months wage which in his case would be 3 times that.

    Have I been to spoilt or is this reasonable?

     

     
    2.
    Member Icon
    Member
    11 posts
    Newbee
    Lola78      

    I agree that is a lot of money, but why didnt he talk about it before you guys bought the rings? What is the point of complaining now? After all I agree you deserved it. I think every bride does :) Also, they just sometimes like to find a reason to complain :) Dont be stressing too much!

     
    3.
    Bee
    4,375 posts
    Honey bee
    mrbee    March 5, 2005   New York City, New York

    Everyone is different, and so what works for one couple is different from what will work for another.

    I don't know anyone who spent over $10k in rings... but if you guys have a lot of money saved up, then you're in a different place than most people I know.  But it does sound like your FI isn't quite comfortable with spending that much on the rings!

    Hope you guys can talk it all out!!

     
    4.
    Member
    1,437 posts
    Bumble bee
    FlipFlopBride       Virginia

    My whole set cost $100...and my FI complains about it. So, we've all got our own budgets in our heads. FI just doesn't get why I need rings to get married.

    Did you guys talk about it before you bought the rings? Or is this a new thing?

    I haven't met anyone that's spent that much, but if he has the income to spend $10k, then why not?

    I don't think it's a matter of being spoiled or deserving. It just comes down to what you can afford and the budget agreed upon.

     
    5.
    Member Icon
    Member
    107 posts
    Blushing bee
    will_be_ckd    5/15/10   Michigan

    Something you need to talk about becuase planning a wedding will involve money on a much bigger scale.  Maybe there is another reason this amount worries him? 

     
    6.
    Hostess
    9,017 posts
    Bee Keeper
    daydreamwanderer       DC

    Hmmm... regardless of comparisons to others, it sounds like your rings are already purchased. If I were in your shoes, I'd be more bothered by the fact that he brought it up AFTER buying, rather than BEFORE. I mean, no matter how much he (you both) spent on your ring, no one wants to bring it back and exchange it for a cheaper ring after the fact! What a let down!

     
    7.
    Member
    1,542 posts
    Bumble bee
    rabbit    September 3, 2010   Milwaukee, WI

    i agree with everyone above- this is something that should have been brought up in the buying process. If you bought them together, he ought to have said something while you were in the store buying them. My FI and I talked it over for months before heading to the store and then we had whispered conversations while in the jewelery store buying our rings. If, however, HE BOUGHT the rings (especially the engagement ring!) on his own without you- dude should shut the [blank] up! Seriously.

     

    I must add, also, that if this is a recent thing, and hasn't been going on since the moment you got the rings, maybe his job has recently become unstable and he sees those rings as money that could be in the bank, taking care of both your houseing/food/etc needs if he loses his job. This economy is highly unstable and if he fears losing his job at all, his snarkiness may be his round about way of telling you.

     

    I hope things work out.

     
    8.
    14,581 posts
    Bee Keeper
    ejs4y8    June 20, 2009  

    I know plenty of friends who have $10,000 engagement rings (not including wedding bands). So, for me, it doesn't seem like a lot. BUT, since it is basically 9 months' pay for the dude, I can see how it stings a little bit. DH cringed a little when he bought my rings (i was with him) and he told me I owe him with a wink and a smile. I used to date a guy who'd do stuff for me (take me out to eat then complain about the cost. It's really hurtful and makes you feel super guilty! However, tell him he's making you feel like crap and that complaining about it post-proposal does not do either of you any good. What's done is done. I think he's having a bad attitude about it. Does he really expect you to up and exchange it? If so, is it b/c he's worried about his job? Did he spend ALL of his savings and now he feels like it was a dumb idea? You have to know how he feels about it. But i can see how spending 10K when he only makes 13K or so a year would frustrate him unless he really had a lot saved up.

     
    9.
    Hostess
    1,975 posts
    Buzzing bee
    redherring    September 11, 2010   Pittsburgh, PA

    The 3-month salary "rule" is basically an arbitrary thing devised by the diamond industry to taunt people into spending more money than they necessarily should, and it's predominantly aimed at those making middle-class incomes. Once you get into higher incomes, it somewhat breaks down. Had my fiance used that "rule", my ring would cost 3x as much as it does, and that would have been *ridiculous*. Basically, what my fiance did was buy a ring that he could afford, but that made him a little uncomfortable to buy, with the logic of "He'd only have to do this once, so he might as well splurge." Personally, I think the cost of your ring is exorbitant. It's also near the cost of my ring, which I also find exorbitant. But if it's what we could afford, then awesome for us both :)

    As for your fiance's behavior - he's complaining at the wrong time. If he genuinely objected to spending that much money, he should have spoken up BEFORE the rings were purchased. Talking about it now does neither of you any favors. It's hurtful to you and spiteful of him, and it's going to end up driving a wedge between you if he doesn't let it go.

     
    10.
    Member
    2,152 posts
    Buzzing bee
    alishaneva    May 2011   Lancaster, PA

    The girls here all gave great advice - and I think the underlying thing you can take away from it is that it's time to actually talk to hime about this. Why is it that now he's worried? I've done this with other purchases - spent more than I should have and worried about it later. It happens. But the important thing is to talk about it now to figure out what you two can do to make him feel more comfortable. And definitely talk to him about the wedding - cause they're expensive, too!

     
    11.
    Member
    1,846 posts
    Buzzing bee
    simpleandchic    November 27, 2010   Adelaide, South Australia

    i must have been too confusing. It wasnt 9 months pay it was only a months pay.  as for talking about it before he was happy to spend that much on the engagement ring we had spent years talking about it (part of why it took so long for him to propose as he was saving) The problem arrose with the bands 'cause he didnt realise how much they cost (mine needed to go with the engagement ring so that made it dearer.) we agreed on spending $2000 on the rings but mine ended up costing $500 more this is where the problem started. He recently got a promotion and his job is very secure.

     

     
    12.
    14,581 posts
    Bee Keeper
    ejs4y8    June 20, 2009  

    Oh wow, big difference. One month's pay? It sounds to me like your FI has a very well paying job that is secure and he needs to chill! Maybe he's not used to spending money? The first time you write a big check like that sorta chokes you. it's all "save save save" then suddenly it's gone. Just ask him WHY it bothers him to spend the money on a ring--is it that he hasn't spend that kind of money before or is he uncomfortable about you wearing something so nice, etc? There's gotta be a reason he's complaining. If your ring was only one month's pay for him, he's likely doing well enough that he'll recover from it quickly. Offer to help him save a little to offset the cost--eat in a little more instead of eating out?

     
    13.
    Member
    3,763 posts
    Honey bee
    JamaicaBride    May 14, 2011   Charlotte, NC

    My fiance and I never had a particular cost in mind. As a matter of fact...we have been engaged for almost 3 years and I JUST found out how much he spent about 5 months ago. While my rings are beautiful and I LOVE the fact that he designed them himself...I do feel odd about walking around with what basically amounts to a compact car on my hand. I thinks is a bit much...but since I don't wear any other rings, my wedding band and e-ring will literally be the only rings I will ever wear. He didn't complain about the cost though....we do joke about it from time to time but he was able to "go all out" and so he went for it.

    Like the other posters stated...the rings are bought now. It's a little too late for complaints now. If budget was an issue, the the onus was on your fiance to buy what he could comfortable afford.

     

    Reply

    You must log in to post.





    Visit our sister sites eHarmony
    Online Dating
    eHarmony Advice
    Dating Advice
    Project Wedding
    Wedding Songs
    JustMommies
    Pregnancy Calendar

    Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
     

    Find your vendors on Weddingbee

    Real reviews from brides in your area!

    Favors by Weddingbee

    • Favors by season

    Shop Now ยป

    Find Registry Find Registry Find Registry

    More