- Blog
- Bios
- Boards
- Classifieds
- DIY
- Gallery
- Vendor Reviews
- Shop Weddingbee
as long as you and your FH know what's up then I wouldn't worry too much about it. She's driving herself crazy and there isn't anything you can do beyond what you've already done to assure her. She's doing it to herself by jumping to conclusions and not trusting you guys.
Ugh she sounds difficult. I would stop giving her any details about church services. When she brings it up, say "Sandy, nothing has changed since our last conversation. Johnny is not converting to Catholicism." - then change the topic! While I understand that she is looking for reassurance, she can't keep harping on a subject when you've made it clear her input is not needed/wanted.
From my experience its all about the grandkids--- assure you about that- and she will mellow out
I actually think FI needs to give her a talking-to. If these issues are coming up now when you are engaged, imagine once you are married and have kids.
FI needs to make it clear to her that she needs to respect your decisions as a couple and mark some boundaries.
I hope you guys can find a resolution to this situation soon. I imagine it would become a very tiresome, stressful, and aggravating thing to deal with nonsense accusations for the rest of your life! Agree that FH should sit her aside and lay everything out on the table before it really gets out of hand.
Also, I should note that regardless of what your FH is doing, it is his decision. Even if he was converting, FMIL has no right to act out in such a way. It's his life and they are his decisions and she needs to respect them, whatever they may be.
I hope that you two have decided on what faith your children will be, if you choose to have them. If you chose to not to raise them in her religion I would have the conversation now.
It sounds almost like she is hoping you'll convert to Judaism... what with not being offended that you go to her schule and everything... not long after I met my FH did I get the "my grandkids had better be Jewish" talk...
I realize that it's annoying, but I would cut the woman some slack. How doyou think you family would react if the situation were reversed?
Agree with PPs that she's probably worried about grandchildren. If you guys haven't addressed that issue now I would strongly advise that you do so and then communicate your feelings to her as a couple.
Most recently she has decided that I hate her, which I don't and have never given her an indicaition of, That I think she is a second class citizen because I am not involving her in every wedding decision and when we do ask her to help or something she blows us off or complains. She also has accused me of lying to her when I havent, some summer plans changed and she was confused on some details taht both her son and I spent hours clarifying but as of 3 days ago I am now a liar, she has accused me of trying to "one up-her" on several occasions when I thought we were having a normal conversation, including me remembering my mother and grandmother raising some heirloom flowers she mentioned a relitve had a huge yard full of them and I said that I thought that was wonderful and must have been beautiful.
FH has now gotten to the point that he has told her she needs to back off and stop blaming me for everything and that she needs to see a counselor.
For some reason it cut off part of my post, my family wouldn't care as they are mostly non-religious. She doesn't even practice her faith (doesn't keep kosher, doesn't keep the sabbith etc.)
Sorry girl, sounds like things are getting worse. Just keep your chin up and try your damndest to be sweet. Weddings bring out all sorts of family drama, eventually the dust will settle.
We have already decided on how we are raising the kids, she isn't happy about that either.
OP--I realize that I am kind of late to the game here, but have you made an effort to learn about Judaism? Are you dedicated to ensuring that your children are knowledgeable about their Jewish heritage? My FI is Jewish and I am not, however I have gone out of my way to ensure that his family realizes that I am interested in their heritage and am not going to ignore it. Making a few latkes and knowing a little Yiddish can go a long way!
While your FMIL does sound a little crazy, to which I have no comment, please remember where she is coming from. Women of her age personally know Holocaust survivors and those who didn't survive. She has likely dealt with predjudice in her life due to being Jewish. I imagine that she is concerned about the family's Jewish heritage living on, especially if you aren't going to raise your children Jewish.
Difficult though she may be, she is your FI's mother and will be in your life for a long, long time. You can't do anything about it. What you can do is do everything in your power to have a good relationship with her.
Actually I have made the effort to learn about the Jewish faith, any children will know about the Jewish faith/heritage etc. My family a couple generations back was Jewish except someone converted or stopped practicing, married a Catholic and here I am. Most of my family was non religous of any kind so as an adult I converted to Catholicsm(it was a toss up between that and Judiasm). Had I known about the family history I would have converted jewish. My Grandfather was in WW2 and part of the troops that liberated camps, my great grandmother sold the diamond out of her ring and sent the money back to family in Europe to get Jews out. Even all of this has been shared with her, and I understand where she comes from on this, but she has gone off the deap end more than on the issue of Judiasm with me.
She interferes in our relationship, telling my FH not to talk to me about what she says about me, To not buy me jewlery, flowers, cards or any gifts whatso ever because I don't deserve them. That I am not allowed to have family antiques that are traditionally handed down when the eldest daughter gets married because I "have too much stuff".
She has tried isolating me from my family by saying we can't spend holidays with them. She has demanded we spend Christmas and Easter with her (her 2nd husband is non-practicing catholic) at the same time belitteling Christianity the whole time but does not want to celebrate Passover or Chaunnaka. The closer we get to the wedding the crazier she is getting.
You must log in to post.
| Visit our sister sites | eHarmony Online Dating |
eHarmony Advice Dating Advice |
Project Wedding Wedding Songs |
JustMommies Pregnancy Calendar |

| User | Posts Today |
|---|---|
| LammChop | 17 |
| fivemonthsnotice | 17 |
| Lyndzo | 15 |
| Mrs. Chai | 14 |
| ticatica | 14 |
| beargoose | 12 |
| MissPumpkinPie | 12 |
| BellaDee | 12 |
| Ms. Salamander | 12 |
| MrsOliveBird | 11 |
Sorry, there are no users yet.
Ok, a little background, my FH is Jewish, I am Catholic. FH has been really good and supportive of all the Catholic hoops we have to jump through to get married and I mean EVERYTHING from NFP to Marriage Prep and the paperwork which if you are getting married with Catholic approval or in the church you know is a bunch of paperwork... and he occasionally goes to mass with me to play nice with my pastor.
My FMIL has been losing her mind for the past several months that I am trying to get him to convert, this is AFTER we had a conversation with her specifically about this, that NO I am not trying to get him to convert, I don't want him to convert, and I would probably quiz him to death if he told me he was converting... ie he would have a heck of a time convincing me, not to mention he has no intention of converting.
The most recent event to make this woman go off the deep end bat sh*t crazy is FH went to Mass with me at Easter. As many Catholics know we have the renewal of baptismal promises at masses during Easter, I made sure FH didn't even stand for this part, he sat, during the sprinkling rite my priest went out of his way to make sure he did not sprinkle FH with holy water (my priests are really good dealing with the interfaith thing). The woman lost her mind thinking I had had him baptized at Mass and nothing he or I could say or do would make her realized that it wasn't a baptism.
Grrr.
He only came with me because we were doing dinner at my family's for easter and we live an hour away. BTW I go to High Holy Days with him, not that he is the most observant Jew in the world, she has no problem with me going with him to synagoge but all h*ll brakes lose if he goes to Mass with me.
GRR