- Blog
- Bios
- Boards
- Classifieds
- DIY
- Gallery
- Vendor Reviews
- Shop Weddingbee
I don't even know where to start. I am just baffled by this and need to vent.
My brother's FI is a bit of a penny-pincher. No, She is actually a HUGE tight wad! They have not set a wedding date because she can't find anyone allow them to have a wedding and reception for free. (as in NOTHING comes out of her pocket! not one single cent)
Anyway-- back to my vent. My brother called me last night and we had the following coversation:
HIM: "FI wants to know if you and your FI want to come over for a picnic on Monday."
ME: "Sure, we can end our trip early and come home from the beach in the AM hours instead of waiting to leave."
HIM: "Great. "Could you please bring Hamburgers, hot dogs, chicken and shrimp to cook on the grill?"
ME: "You mean enough for us to eat?"
HIM: "No, could you bring all of the meat? We can pick up the bread. She also needs someone to either make or bring potato salad, coleslaw, pasta salads and dessert. What else would you bring? Oh, and she said bring Beer too."
ME: " let me see if I have this right. You and FI are hosting a picnic on July 5th because fireworks can be seen from your house and we don't have to go to the park. Her ENTIRE family will be there, FI and I, and you and her?"
HIM: "YES"
ME: "So you want FI and I to bring hot dogs, hamburgers, chicken, shrimp, potoato salad, coleslaw, pasta salad and dessert for 40+ people. Plus you want us to end our weekend early to attend"
HIM: "Yes, and don't forget the beer. and could you pick up a bushel of crabs too"
ME: " have you lost your ever loving mind? I will attend, I will bring food for us, but I am not supplying you with everything YOU need to feed HER family for a picnic SHE wants to host. It will cost me well over $300.00 for all of that."
HIM:" But you just said you would come and she has been calling her family telling them to be here. What are we suppose to do now?'
At this point I asked to speak to his FI. I repeated everything that he has said she wanted me to supply. She agreed to what I had said and when I asked her what she and her family were going to supply she said, "OH, the paper goods, the chips and the bread," I told her that we would be staying at the beach and catching dinner on the way home and not be able to attend. She started yelling about how I was going to ruin her family picnic by backing out now and what was she suppose to feed them all. I told her to start calling those 40 family members and advise them it would be a pot luck and they needed to bring a dish. She got so mad at me for that and said, "That's inappropriate. I can't ask my guest to bring a dish. That's tacky."
UM... WHAT????? but asking me to supply all of the food for HER picnic is OK? PLEASE.... Sorry just needed to vent a little.
omg... i'm sorry but i just had to laugh. that is insane. totally batshit crazy.
LOL! Sorry, I know it must be incredibly frustrating to deal with, but what a ridiculous person! I can't believe both she and your brother apparently think that's in any way appropriate. You're a better person than I for not laughing in her face!
Whaaaat? Is she for real?
I would NEVER go to that picnic!! I would have laughed in her face for what she said...especially the end about it being tacky. Um hello!!
Good luck with that one...
Ummm that is not ok. IF they had planned this earlier they could have split all of the food up for everyone....dumbdumb FI. I'm glad you stuck by your guns!
Wow. Seriously? Feed your own guest you if want to have a BBQ or have a potluck if you want to save money. Wow, you handled that better than I would have. Some people, eh?
whoa.... that is mucho nutty. im a very "cautious spender" also, but that is just indecent. and she got mad at you? your brother doesnt see the nuttiness in this situation?
That is SHOCKINGLY tacky and rude! Does your brother even hear himself as he is saying those words on her behalf?
somebody is cookoo bananas! That is insane, I am glad you stood up for yourself. As I was reading I was like PLEASE tell me she didn't agree and wants to back out, FSIL would straight murder her then haha.
She sounds completely out of her mind. If she brings it up again you should remind her that making guests bring things is tacky (her words) and you were invited as a guest!
I bet you can't wait until she gets going with the wedding planning. Bet she will call and ask you if you can pay for the venue, photographer, limo, caterer, flowers, dress, cake and invites. Don't worry, her parents are paying for the programs and her shoes. lol!
Um, that's insane! I would of flipped my lid. Who asks for all of that? Omg, I'm glad you didn't do it! Jeez, I'm annoyed for you!!
Haha...wow, so I guess she didn't consider you a guest at her house? Maybe the food supplier? Sheesh! I would've asked for money upfront to bring all of that! Haha...
All.. By the time I hung up, I was literally on the floor from laughing at the strange turn in the conversation. I have no idea if Bro finds it odd or not. Seriously, I think he just has his head in the sand and lets her do what she wants. THAT is not my problem.
@jaylii9 -- don't laugh. My FI and I got engaged 5 weeks after Bro and FI. MY FI and I were ready to jump on the planning wagon and get things rolling, so I called BRo and said, "have ya'll set a date? I don't want to step on toes but we want to plan and get married." Bro said no. So, FI and I started planning. When I realized how big our wedding and reception was going to be I called Bro and FI and actually asked if they wanted to share in the reception since they had been talking destinational wedding. BRo and FI said, "Sure... As long as it doesn't cost us." HAHAHAHA. UM... She wants to invite her family and friends... its gonna cost ya!
@flutterby: That's hilarious! She obviously doesn't have a clue! I am hoping for you and your FI's sake that your wedding has nothing to do with theirs anymore!
Stay away from this person. She is completely nuts and it will only get worse! I really feel for your brother because this kind of behavior gets worse over time. If you don't watch it, you may end up sending their children to college!
I'm so glad you have a sense of humor about her. Best wishes.
Oh, lordy... If I don't laugh about her insane notions I would be beating my head against a wall daily.
She just called me to tell me that she would not be attending my and my FI wedding because she has to work. Forgive me, but is today not July 1st? OUr wedding is Sept. 25th... Why can she not get someone to cover for her? DUH! Oh well.
omg! what a crazy!!!! that's just plain nuts is she going to ask you to pay for their wedding too?
LMAO - seriously i feel like i need oxygen. *Gasping in between laughter*
is she SERIOUS!? you really did handle it better than i would have.... i would have just hung up.
classic. Some people's children *smh*
This is hilarious. Is she vindictive about any of it? If not, then it stays funny. :)
Wow, that's amazing. I'm so happy that you actually stood up for yourself and told her that you wouldn't be supplying her party directly to her, that's awesome!
I'm with spaganya, I wouldn't have handled that as well as you had. That is just INSANE. Seriously! I am having a hard time trying to understand why in the world she would think you were going to bring food to feed 40+ people at a cook out SHE was hosting. I just can't understand it!
Ok, I don't know what's more hilarious, the fact that she tried to get you to pay for your BBQ or the fact that she's now trying to tell you that she can't make it to your wedding b/c she has to work. LOL...I'm dying over here!
holy canoli...what a nutcase. This is the type of thing that just makes you wonder how in the world people actually think they can behave like this. Wow...
I don't find it funny...I find it sad. I'm sad because your brother actually asked you for all that!! Fine, she's nuts...that's ok, but why would your brother go along with this and ask you and NOT get that it's rude, inappropriate, disrespectful and just crazy to ask somebody to bring all supplies to the picnic! Doesn't your brother get it? I feel bad. He's going to marry a strange, strange woman! And she called you to say she isn't coming to your wedding now?? What did you say? This is nuts!
I am just so glad that you can laugh about it, because I am cracking up. What a wacko!! I had no idea people like this even existed!! WHO DOES THAT?!?!
please don't think I am handling it well. I have ranted and raved about it after I stopped laughing at her.(this the reason for this post-- I had to get it out there) I seriously could not believe that she asked me (told me?) to bring all the food.
I am not totally sure why my brother didn't see the oddness of this request. I don't know if he has suddenly forgotten how to think for himself or what, but it is strange and sad. I did call my mom and tell her what was going on. She just sighed and said,"Oh, I hope he realizes that this is as good as it get and it doesn't suddenly improve when the other ring goes on."
I am not thrilled that she will not be at our wedding. I think it is extremely rude (and tacky to use her words!) to not plan NOW for her future inlaws. FI and I set our wedding date in JULY 2009!!! it's not like this date just popped up.
She is not normally a vindictive person. I think she was just rasied by wolves ( and I do NOT mean the Jacob Black kind). She is just very self absorbed (? not even sure that is the right wording). She is a penny pincher and is always looking for ways to save a buck. However, save a buck normally doesn't come at the expense of others. I think this time is just a really bad brain lapse for her. At least that is what I am hoping for anyway.
@Flutterby I'm so sorry...hope she and your brother come around! This just isn't right. Does your bro seem happy with her and happy to marry her? Try not to let it get you down!! :)
Stay at the beach! Don't go, it's definitely not worth your time, especially since I would imagine her family is probably just as bad.
I would almost want to go to their cookout and not bring anything but a small dish i picked up from a grocery store deli. just to see how it plays out. at that point it's not just penny pinching... it's stupidity.
I ask my brother to bring beer, or pick up cheese. We always AT LEAST have the meat under control. duh.
Um. My chest is tight from reading that post. That is TACKY & rude. What a selfish, cheap ass.
I'd bring a pack of hot dogs, a 6 pack of beer & a small container of store bought potato salad. Dig in y'all. Cut the hot dogs into fouths, 1/8c of beer each for the adults, and 2 chunks of potato each. Sounds fair to me. It's better than just bread.
Too funny! I am so sorry she irritated you but her requests are so unreasonable, that no one in their right mind would honor such outlandish requests. To "invite" you and then expect you to supply all the food is just plain crazy!
As for not attending the wedding, I think you lucked out there! Plus since she is too busy to attend the wedding, no need to talk anymore about sharing a reception.
You must log in to post.
| Visit our sister sites | eHarmony Online Dating |
eHarmony Advice Dating Advice |
Project Wedding Wedding Songs |
JustMommies Pregnancy Calendar |

| User | Posts Today |
|---|---|
| fivemonthsnotice | 17 |
| Lyndzo | 15 |
| ticatica | 14 |
| LammChop | 14 |
| Mrs. Chai | 12 |
| MissPumpkinPie | 12 |
| BellaDee | 12 |
| MrsOliveBird | 11 |
| aussiebee | 11 |
| pinkandsparkly | 10 |
| User | Posts Today |
|---|---|
| LammChop | 1 |