Post # 1
I have a quick grammar question. Which of these sentences is correct?
Thank you for inviting FI and me to the Christmas party. (he had never met FI)
Thank you for inviting FI and I to the Christmas party.
I think the first one is correct b/c when you take out FI it should read thank you for inviting me. It just sounds funny. Thanks for your help!!
Post # 3
I agree. The correct form is “FI and me,” even though it sounds funny.
My grampa was an English teacher. This was hounded into me since I was a toddler.
Post # 4
“Thank you for inviting FI and I to the Christmas party” is the correct grammatical presentation when responding for more than one person.
Post # 5
I believe that the first sentence is correct. As a hint, if you take out one pronoun and it works as a sentence still, then that’s the correct form.
Post # 6
- Wedding: September 2010 - Heinz Chapel Ceremony, Museum Reception
It’s “Thank you for inviting FI and me,” for the reasons you said. You write it as you would if FI were not included in the sentence. You could use ‘I’ if you were going to say something like, “FI and I would love to come to the Christmas party,” but for the sentence you want, it’s me.
Post # 7
Definitely the first one.
You wouldn’t say, “Thank you for inviting I to the Christmas party.” Just take the other guy out of it whenever you need to check a sentence like that.
I taught three years of HS English, worked a few years in corporate communications, and am, in general, a big ol’ nerd.
Post # 8
FI and Me is correct! For the reason Carrie stated – you write the sentence like FI wasn’t included.
Thank you for inviting me – Thank you for inviting FI and me!
I went to the store – FI and I went to the store!
Hope this helps!
Post # 9
You can always say “us!”
Then follow it up with soemthing like “Hisname enjoyed meeting you.”
Post # 11
Thank you all for your help!
Post # 12
Actually the second one is correct. Its a rule when referring to more than one person you always put yourself last.
Guess this post is so late it wouldn’t matter anyway.
Post # 13
Its always been ‘Soandso and I’. Its just what we always say and its more proper to put whoever before I in a sentence.
Post # 14
plaugher85, picturemeurs, and CO919- If the pronoun is acting as the direct object in the sentence the pronoun is always me- not I, regardless of accompaniment. You wouldn’t say, “Thanks for inviting I to the party.”
Post # 15
You’re right. (It does sound silly, though, I agree.)
Post # 16
Like staying_ms_shaw said, the first is absolutely correct.
An easy way to check (in addition to the ways already proposed) is to simplify it: would you say us or we? “We” correlates to “I” and is a subject; “us” correlates to “me” and is a direct object.
So anywhere that you’d say “us” you always, always say “xx and me.” And if you’d say “we,” you should say “xx and I.”
So: “Thank you for inviting FI and me [or us] to your party,” but “FI and I [or we] were delighted to attend your party—thank you!”
(My mom was an English teacher so this stuff is instilled in me! 🙂