Anyone NOT do engagement photos?
more by bora
where to register for the <nice> stuff?
To register or not register...
more in Gifts and Registries
Honeymoon Registry?
The Simpsons grooms cake
more in Boards
switching Bridesmaid order, MOH not first?

Is my registry too over the Top???

posted 4 years ago in Gifts and Registries
  •  
    1.
    Member Icon
    Member
    68 posts
    Worker bee
    bora      

    So we started our registry process on Sunday. And I def. want the fine china, silver, crystal stuff. So we headed to bloomies and see what they had. Instead of getting the 5-piece place settings, we decided to mix and match from different settings. The FH and I LOVED these Faberge plates and a couple of other pieces and made a really nice place setting. Now if you add up all the pieces, the plates come to $212 and the teacup setting comes to $135 per setting. That is a total of $347 per setting! We didn't quite know how much it was going to be when we decided on these plates+cups. Now I'm starting to feel bad.... is this too expensive? Will it come off bad? Our wedding (we're hoping) will be nice. Our total budget (excl. honeymoon) is around $400 per person so I feel like we're trying to make ia nice experience for ppl. (not that you need to spend that much for ppl to have fun, but you know what I mean : )  Anyways, is this too much? We will def. have lots of stuff under $100 and so I'm hoping the expensive stuff won't seem so ostentatious. But I did have my heart set on nice china (even the FH did!) since I've always dreamed of a big family around the thanksgiving table having a nice dinner- I know, how fromagey  
    And now that I think about, ppl put knives, pots+pans sets, and mixers which are $400+ so maybe my plates aren't that bad (?)  whatyathink??  : )

     
    2.
    Bee Icon
    Bee
    413 posts
    Helper bee
    dahlia      

    My only thought would be that you need to make sure that you have plenty of items that are less than 50, 50-100, 100-150, and 150+.  The vast majority of your items should be less than 100. 

    I just wouldn't be surprised if you didn't get the china, since people may not want to spend $135 on a teacup.  They may want to spend, say, $150, but want to get you something "more" than "just" a cup.  

     
    3.
    Member Icon
    Member
    203 posts
    Helper bee
    BA    7/12/08  

    I think it depends on lots of stuff.  Will many of your guests be travelling very far for the wedding (and thus incurring expenses aside from your wedding present)?  Will you be inviting lots of older guests who might have more cash than recent college grad/grad school type students who may not have lots of expendable cash?  I don't think you should factor in how much YOU are spending per person, since most guests don't consider that when buying a present.  You're right that people generally have a few big ticket items on their regstries (the kitchenaid mixer comes to mind!), but $300+/place setting DOES seem really expensive.  I guess the real question becomes: how would you feel if you didn't get many of those because they were out of many people's price ranges? If you'd feel "gipped" because your registry wasn't filled, or if you only got one of two place settings, maybe you should pick something that's closer to most people's price point ($100-150ish).  That's just my two cents. Hope it helps!

     
    4.
    Member Icon
    Member
    1,315 posts
    Bumble bee
    rebecca    September 13, 2008  

    i'm dealing with this same question now. the fact that we're registered for a $400 pot is a little weird to me. but dahlia's right -- as long as you have enough of a choice, you're fine. my mom pointed out that some people want to give you a $400 gift and won't want to get you lots of little things to have to do that.

    the only thing i would say is that if you don't get the full number of place settings that you register for (say you register for 12 but only get 7), are you okay with either a) shelling out the cash to complete your set (and at $300/place that can be a lot!), or b) having an odd number of place settings?

     
    5.
    Member Icon
    Member
    259 posts
    Helper bee
    Amy       New York City

    another thing you should think about is... some ppl may choose to buy you the $300+ china setting but it may not get bought out.  So you're left with either buying it out yourself or having an incomplete china set.  This happened to a few of my friends and it was a pain b/c you either return everything or spend $$$$ to buy out the rest of the peices.

     

     
    6.
    Member Icon
    Member
    259 posts
    Helper bee
    Amy       New York City

    oops - didn't read rebecca's post... guess we had the same thoughts.  good luck with whatever you decide!

     
    7.
    Member Icon
    Member
    403 posts
    Helper bee
    Yach    10/23/07   CT

    You should have those items on your registry.  That's what they are for....for you to pick out things you really want.  Just make sure you do have items below $100 and in the $100-$200 range.  I would totally be one of those people who would get the plates if that's what you want.

    Attachments

    1. Is my registry too over the Top??? :  wedding registry china Pdf Wedding_101_Ad-web.pdf (94.7 KB, 105 downloads) 3 years old
     
    8.
    Member Icon
    Member
    68 posts
    Worker bee
    bora      

    Thanks for your all your comments!

    Yes, we should and will def. have lots of stuff under $100... I'm hoping it will make the expensive stuff not be so obvious.

    I won't feel gipped about not getting all of the nice china, but more than that I'd feel kinda embarassed that I was so off the mark. We're having a lot of out of country guests (my FI is from England) so we're hoping and thinking that ppl will make it a long holiday (vegas bachrlor party for the boys the w/e before the wedding). but I feel that its balanced by the exchange rate which is in their favor. The sterling is dbl the dollar right now.  

    Good points about having to possibly buy the china ourselves if we don't get enough settings. I think we'd definitely do that... in fact I may even put some things I don't want on the registry but are cheaper so that I can return them and get the china, (if I dont get all the china).

     Thanks for all your input !!!

    Attachments

    1. Is my registry too over the Top??? :  wedding registry china Img marisa_769.jpg (89.2 KB, 93 downloads) 3 years old
    2. Is my registry too over the Top??? :  wedding registry china Img face_block_dress_front.JPG (25 KB, 85 downloads) 3 years old
    3. Is my registry too over the Top??? :  wedding registry china Img back_of_dress2.JPG (109.4 KB, 66 downloads) 3 years old
     
    9.
    Member Icon
    Member
    203 posts
    Helper bee
    BA    7/12/08  

    Just a follow up bora- I'm also in the UK with my FI, but our wedding is in CA, and we have lots of guests travelling from the UK. I don't know where in the states your wedding is, or what time of year, but flights are REALLY expensive (like 700 GBP LHR-California).  Just something to keep in mind. 

     
    10.
    Member
    151 posts
    Blushing bee
    southernbella    07/18/2009   Charlotte, NC

    I think you're fine-I'd rather someone register for china and crystal (and recieve several pieces and later build on it themselves) than ask for a flat screen tv-now THAT is tacky!

     
    11.
    Member Icon
    Member
    1,315 posts
    Bumble bee
    rebecca    September 13, 2008  

    southernbella, why is a tv tacky?

    Attachments

    1. Is my registry too over the Top??? :  wedding registry china Img 101_1568.JPG (76.3 KB, 86 downloads) 3 years old
     
    12.
    Member Icon
    Member
    101 posts
    Blushing bee
    OnlySupernova    June 2008   Lexington, Kentucky

    I don't have fine china on my registry...but I do have a moderate television...because we need one. Isn't that what a registry is for? Nice stuff, but also a chance for friends and family to give you stuff you need?

    I'd also suggest checking your registry more frequently as your wedding date approaches to make sure one price range or another isn't running out of items too quickly. You don't want to make people feel obligated to get you one of your splurge items just because it's all that's left. 

     
    13.
    Member Icon
    Member
    190 posts
    Blushing bee
    haselwand    12/20/08   Indiana/Las Vegas

    I wouldn't worry too much as long as you have many price ranges ($30–$150+), because two different guests who might not spend as much (ie, two couples or two aunts, etc.) might go in on a gift so they can double their money and get a bigger ticket item such as a place setting or KitchenAid Stand Mixer (can you tell I'm registering for one?!).

     
    14.
    Member Icon
    Member
    53 posts
    Worker bee
    champagnebride    aug 2008   Canada

    I don't want to hijack the post but I was interested when southernbella said to register for a tv is tacky and rebecca asked her why she though that. what do you think? I think it is tacky but I can't articulate why I think so, what the 'dividing line' is......but I  know a girl who registered for a hair straightener and I remember feeling that that was pretty silly.

     
    15.
    Member Icon
    Member
    94 posts
    Worker bee
    peaches    August, 2008   CA

    Definitely have a good price range of gifts you register for.  Most places recommend having a larger number of gifts in the $50-100 and $100-125 price range.  I think it also depends on your guests and what they can afford...you know them best.  Just don't be disappointed if you aren't able to get all the place settings you registered for...there's always the risk that some people may be very generous and get you some of the teacups and place settings...and others may not be able to afford it.  Worst thing that can happen is that you may get an odd number (ie 1, 2 or 3) of plates/cups and have to buy the rest yourselves...just be prepared for that!  If you already know, you can't afford to complete the settings yourself, it may be best to just take them off of the registry and go with something else.

    Attachments

    1. Is my registry too over the Top??? :  wedding registry china Img plain_wedding_bubbles.jpg (2.1 KB, 8 downloads) 3 years old
    2. Is my registry too over the Top??? :  wedding registry china Img paper_parasol_to_upload.JPG (58.9 KB, 27 downloads) 3 years old
    3. Is my registry too over the Top??? :  wedding registry china Img table_number_holders_-_blank.JPG (3.2 KB, 30 downloads) 3 years old
    4. Is my registry too over the Top??? :  wedding registry china Img table_number_holder_-_painted.JPG (85.8 KB, 27 downloads) 3 years old
    5. Is my registry too over the Top??? :  wedding registry china Img table_number_holder_-_close_up.JPG (96 KB, 25 downloads) 3 years old
     
    16.
    Hostess
    2,683 posts
    Sugar bee
    suzanno    7/12/08   Richland, WA

    I'm with you - the tv strides me as a little weird and wrong - maybe because of the price?? So I was wondering if it would be better to register for things like a dvd player and surround sound, which would be less per item?  Its certainly non-traditional.  But so is registering for cross-country skis at REI, and I think its kind of cool when people do that.

    Sort of getting back to the china - I went to a wedding last year where the people had registered at Home Depot for a lot of really, really expensive power tools. (Okay sort of like china, sort of not.)  The point is, there were not very many less expensive items on their registry, and I was sort of left wondering "Who do they think they are, that everybody is going to spend in excess of $500 on them?"  I suppose they expected mostly gift cards.  It was particularly odd because they were a very young couple just starting out, so you know that they didn't have pots and pans or nice sheets and towels.  We got them nice towels from BB&B.  As long as you have a reasonable range of prices on your registry, and as long as you think you have some guests who will actually buy china that expensive, I don't think people will be generally put off.

     
    17.
    Member Icon
    Member
    1,315 posts
    Bumble bee
    rebecca    September 13, 2008  

    i just know alot of people who would/did register for a tv, so i was just wondering what makes it "tacky." is it the dollar amount, or is it the fact that it's a tv? would it be different if someone registered for an expensive piece of furniture?

    and yes, totally sorry to hijack the thread!!!

     
    18.
    Member Icon
    Member
    485 posts
    Helper bee
    dreambml    4/12/08   Boston

    I don't think a tv is tacky.  you register for what you need, if its your first place, that might be what you need.  people register for everything these days anyway.....who cares?  they even have "mortgage registries", which I think is slightly tacky.....but then again, it gives guests the option of not giving you cash - it all makes it more personal....isn't that more the point?  Anywho - my shower was yesterday.  I will say that mostly people tried to buy a lot of items at lower prices so it gave the appearance that they are giving you a lot.  If people don't know the cost of something - and really I believe this - they think, oh, they only bought them a toaster?  as opposed to 10 smaller items....so people may not want to show up to your shower with just a plate - and by looking at the price, that is probably about average (of one plate or cup) of each persons gift....so either count on gift cards or count on getting most of the cheaper items.  Trust me, everything we registered for that was on the pricier side is still on our registry, so we are trying to decide whether to keep it and buy the rest, or return it and get other things.

     
    19.
    Member Icon
    Member
    92 posts
    Worker bee
    lina624    08.16.08  

    A registry is a wish list.  It really depends upon each individual couple.  My fiance and I are not a the type of couple to register for fine china, but a tv is definitely something we are considering.  I even know of couples who put DVDs and Star Wars collectibles on their registry, which I thought was fun, cause that's who they are.

    The things on your registry should be items that reflect who you are. 

     

     
    20.
    Member
    287 posts
    Helper bee
    pancy    06/13/09   orange county/los angeles

    I agree with lina624 and in response to the original question - I think my Fi are going to definitely put additional, more pricey items on our registry without really expecting people to buy it because we want to take advantage of the discount we get after the wedding and are completely willing to purchase those things for ourselves! (especially when you think about the cash gifts you will be getting - you can use it towards your fine china). Liek others have said, I think as long as you have a variety of price ranges you are fine. I have never though low of a couple for having expensive items. I just figure they have some well-off family or friends or they want to purchase them on a discounted price after their wedding. ;)

     

    Reply

    You must log in to post.

    Tags:





    Visit our sister sites eHarmony
    Online Dating
    eHarmony Advice
    Dating Advice
    Project Wedding
    Wedding Songs
    JustMommies
    Pregnancy Calendar
    Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
     

    Find your vendors on Weddingbee

    Real reviews from brides in your area!

    Favors by Weddingbee

    • Favors by season

    Shop Now ยป

    Find Registry Find Registry Find Registry

    More
    User Posts Today
    Lyndzo 46
    Brielle 37
    AshleyR83 30
    mypinkshoes 28
    rebwana 26
    funkymunky85 26
    fivemonthsnotice 26
    Cady 25
    beargoose 24
    his chippymunk 24

    Gifts and Registries

    User Posts Today
    Jenlon 2
    eagle 2
    MissPumpkinPie 2
    AshleyR83 2
    mrsotg 2
    tcanne 1
    julies1949 1
    CorgiTales 1
    melisslp 1
    Ryansgirl 1
    More