- Blog
- Bios
- Boards
- Classifieds
- DIY
- Gallery
- Vendor Reviews
- Shop Weddingbee
First off, let me prepare you. Some of you may be appalled by the proposal, it’s really bitter sweet.
My fiancé has been dangling a ring in front of my face (figuratively) since June of 2009. He’d talk about it almost every week, and I was just too excited to continue acting nonchalant. So, in September, I asked him if he was planning on doing it anytime soon. And, he said sometime between October of 09 and March of 2010. Of course, I expected it to be in October. So, I did my hair and makeup super nice every and made sure to wear a flattering outfit. When December rolled around and my ring finger was still bare, I was sick and tired of being a Barbie for three months so I asked him what the deal was.
He said his timeline wasn’t up and to “just give it time.” But, I’d been waiting since June and in my head, he’d exceeded his deadline (because I was expecting my ring in October). I couldn’t help but get emotional, so I started crying. I told him that it was cruel to give me such a lengthy timeline and that if he didn’t want to marry me, to just stop stalling and to be straightforward.
He flipped out on me, started yelling and all, and told me that he planned on asking me to marry him when the ball dropped on New Years. But, then I was disappointed because he took away THE ELEMENT OF SURPRISE TO THE WHOLE PROPOSAL! I just wanted a more accurate timeline (e.g. from now to February), not a play-by-play of how he was going to propose. I selfishly asked him to scrap his plans and try and surprise me, even if it meant I had to wait into January or longer.
He took me ring shopping a week or two later and told me that I wouldn’t get to “try on” my ring until he actually proposed. I didn’t want to taint the ring, so I wholeheartedly agreed with his decision.
The next morning rolls around, I wake up, start the coffee maker, head to the bathroom to pee, and I hear a knock on the door. I fling open the door, while I’m still SITTING ON THE TOILET PEEING, and there he is down on one knee and says, “Will you Marry Me?!” I said yes, of course. But, I won’t lie, I was a bit disappointed. I was expecting a trip to central park or a nice dinner or even while we were watching TV at home, but not while I was on the toilet.
Of course, I won’t ever tell him that it wasn’t my dream proposal. When we tell people about our proposal, I act as if it were my dream proposal. We love each other, he proposed and he did what I asked, he SURPRISED me. We’re both jokesters so it ties in well with our personalities. But, I have a great comeback; when I’m pregnant, I’ll wait till he’s on the sh*tter, knock on the door and say, “Honey, I’m pregnant!”
Picture of my engagement ring below. Please excuse my fat, stubby fingers.
pictures didn't upload, make sure its under 100kb :) kind of a cute story though!!
Thanks Tulip! It definitely is a story i get a kick out of sharing.
& I re-uploaded the pictures
I think it is a great story and something my FI would do LOL I love it!
i love it... it sounds so funny and you can be sure you got a unique proposal
Congrats! Your ring looks beautiful in those pics! :)
I think you'll find that many girls are not so thrilled with their proposals, but the point is that he did it because you've found the person for you, and he feels the same way. I was thinking last night about how amazing it really is that that happens! I think it's so great that you are ok with it and just happy to be engaged, or at least from what I can tell.... :) Have a wonderful engagement & wedding!!
I think this story is great! Everyone gets a nice dinner, or a carriage ride, or something like that, but you have this wonderful story that seems to fit your personalities and your relationship. I think that's the best kind of proposal. Many many congratulations! (BTW, it's the ways that I managed to screw up my proposal [impatience, nosy-ness, and my tendency to be freezing everywhere I go] that I think make it a great story--it wouldn't be nearly so good without that. It's just so....US.)
Congrats on the engagement. I'd love to hear what he has the day should you someday decide to pull that comeback on him.
Hahahaha your comeback is great! And I'm glad you can see past the fact that the proposal wasn't what you wanted, but that you're with the person with whom you want to spend the rest of your life. You have a great sense of humor!
I love it! Hahaha. I would die to be able to tell this story. :) Congrats! Your ring is stunning!
Thanks so much girls!! I'm glad that you like our engagement story.I love my ring, I'm starting to love the story, but most of all, I love that we're going to spend the rest of our lives together.
I was worried that I'd get a couple of "how tacky" or "What a Redneck" responses. I do love telling the story, and I definitely did get a memorable engagement. You should have seen my grandmother's face (87 years old) when I told her. She almost peed; I guess it runs in the family. =D
Hey, if it's not going to be a romantic story, at least it's a hilarious one! Congrats on your engagement and your GORGEOUS ring!!
And don't feel bad about ruining his original idea, we've all been there (I got so upset that I actually made him propose way way earlier than he was planning to!)
the proposal was representative of your personalities and relationship = perfect :)
@Trailmix and @Ms.Min Pin: I'm glad it's hilarious, at least we have a funny story to tell our kids one day that actually sounds like us.
I love your attitude about this!! When I hear women complain about how they were proposed it makes me sick! Its selfish and greedy and takes away from what their man is doing. Its just like if you tried so hard to cook a nice dinner for him but never cooked before and he ate it and complained about it and made you cook another dinner for him to make it up, that would suck! Same concept here. Good for you and him! My fI proposed to me in our livingroom and I thought it was the cutest thing just looking at how nervous he was and bashful, I would never ever take that away from him
thank you thank you thank you for your wonderful attitude to your proposal. im sick to the teeth of overwrought precious brides who wail and convulse at the thought that their proposals wasnt fireworks, romance, row boats and and rose petals - thank you!
and congrats - your ring is fabulous
honestly, our proposal didn't play out how EITHER of us had planned, either, but after awhile it stops mattering
hahaha what a funny story...you could always add that your FI wanted to make sure you were safe in case in the excitement of the proposal caused you to pee yourself lol!
I love that you accept your proposal as is and have the gusto to not care what others think!
Hahahaha, I love the story! I'm all for an original proposal and that's as unique as it gets!
haha! i love it! awesome proposal story! I like those cute, random, funny ones! :) beautiful ring too!
Your ring is beautiful! And OH MY GOSH I would have killed Mr. KM if he did that. But, we don't keep the bathroom door open (some things are just supposed to be private in my world) so he probably wouldn't.
I think it was funny what your FI did but I have to agree with others your comeback is going to be good. I love your ring and your finger looks fine in the picture.
@Vegan: Thanks girl! It will be an AMAZING comeback. When that does happen, I think I should video tape it. Oh how sweet the revenge will feel!
hahhahaha i love this!! it seriously made me laugh out loud :)
Congrats! That is a story to remember for sure... My friend got engaged while she was taking a bath, her bf kneeled on the bathmat to propose. As long as it happens it doesn't matter where right?!
It'll be a great story to tell your children, no? Your ring is beautiful and it makes my insides flutter. ^-^ I've always had a special place for three-stone rings!
I love it. He did surprise you and now you're getting married with a beautiful ring! Congratulations!
This is hilarious and definitley original! My fiance kept saying he was going to do this 
I think that yours is one of the most amazing proposal stories I have ever heard!
It is so unique, and please tell him you pregnant (whenever that happens) while he is taking a dump! AMAZING!
Your ring is beautiful!
Thanks for the amazing words everyone! I spilled the beans that I'm on a wedding forum yesterday and told him that everyone loved the story. He said, "see, I told ya." Haha, men.
Maybe you shouldn't have let him in till you were finished. Oh, well, you got a proposal and each proposal is romantic no matter where you are.
You must log in to post.
| Visit our sister sites | eHarmony Online Dating |
eHarmony Advice Dating Advice |
Project Wedding Wedding Songs |
JustMommies Pregnancy Calendar |

| User | Posts Today |
|---|---|
| Lyndzo | 52 |
| This Time Round | 46 |
| Brielle | 43 |
| Future Mrs K | 39 |
| ndreighton | 36 |
| mypinkshoes | 34 |
| his chippymunk | 34 |
| Cady | 32 |
| fivemonthsnotice | 32 |
| TheLionQueen | 31 |
| User | Posts Today |
|---|---|
| sienna76 | 2 |
| tibbets | 2 |
| Miss Sweet Pea | 2 |
| ms. headphone | 1 |
| Jenlon | 1 |
| caseyleigh10 | 1 |
| MissPumpkinPie | 1 |
| MilksMom | 1 |
| MsJ2theZ | 1 |
| ladyartichoke | 1 |