Sign up   Login  
No newer images
more by Canadiangardenpartybride
Best Place for Bridal Shoes in Toronto?
Invite timeline for semi-destination wedding
more in Etiquette
When an RSVP card states "_____ guests attending"
SO has been looking at the facebooks of other women
more in Boards
Custom ring help needed!

No Gifts Shower: Ok to invite people to the bridal shower but not the wedding?

posted 3 months ago in Etiquette
  • 1 Members Subscribed To Topic
  •  
    1.
    Member Icon
    Member
    15 posts
    Newbee
    Canadiangardenpartybride    June 29, 2013  

    Hey bees,

    My fiance's mother is hosting a old-fashioned, no gift shower for me, is it ok to invite people who are not invited to the wedding? I have several friends whom I love and would have at the wedding if we didn't have such space constraints, but I don't want to offend anyone. 

    I know it is typically very bad form to ask people to bring a gift to a shower if they're not invited to the wedding, but is that still the case if no one is bringing gifts? 

    I'd like to include them in the wedding in some way, even though we don't have the space to invite them. Also, not sure if this matters, but we're all university aged, and I think a little less stringent on the traditional rules. 

    Any advice would be great! thanks! 

     
    2.
    Member
    4,204 posts
    Honey bee
    beachbride1216    November 2, 2013   St. Augustine

    It's considered rude where I live regardless of whether gifts are expected. Shower invite equals wedding invite.

     
    3.
    Member Icon
    Member
    97 posts
    Worker bee
    julesjules83    August 3, 2012  

    @Canadiangardenpartybride:  I wouldn't have any problem with that, especially since you specify "no gifts" so it's obviously not a gift-grabbing event. But be prepared: some people might consider it rude and take it personally.

     
    4.
    Member
    402 posts
    Helper bee
    JFay    April 1, 2014   GA

    If you aren't getting gifts, then it's not a shower, right? I thought the point of a shower was to shower you with gifts? In fact, up until I joined the Bee, I thought a shower was where you were supposed to bring your one and only wedding gift...

    I would think this would just be a party, so no gifts would be expected...

     
    5.
    Member Icon
    Member
    340 posts
    Helper bee
    classyashley    October 5, 2013  

    No. Anyone invited to wedding events should be invited to the wedding.

     
    6.
    Member Icon
    Member
    1,600 posts
    Bumble bee
    prisigtr    May 17, 2013   Virginia Beach, VA (Disney World)

    Nope, anyone invited to a shower should be invited to the wedding...

     
    7.
    Member
    6,575 posts
    Bee Keeper
    Brielle    May 22, 2009  

    The solution to this is for your FMIL host a tea in your honor, not a shower. 

     
    8.
    Member
    161 posts
    Blushing bee
    llgraham    August 4, 2013   Vancouver, British Columbia (Wedding in Nova Scotia)

    My mother had a surprise shower for me when I went home for Thanksgiving (we live on different coasts) even though I had expressed I had no interest in bridal showers and would prefer not to have one. I didn't think there would be time (my wedding is august 4th, so besides this past thanksgiving, the only time I would be home is a week before the wedding this summer, and I thought it was rude to have a shower a week before the wedding then the wedding where people would also prb bring gifts). Also, we don't need gifts - we live in a small condo and I am 30 years old with a career, I have bought most of what we need already and we are not encouraging people to bring gifts to the wedding either - when they ask we tell them just bring your "presence!" Besides all that, it would be hard to lug a bunch of presents from the east coast back to the west coast.

     It was awkward because she invited about 30 women (mostly her friends and some old family friends) that I unfortunately will not be inviting to the wedding (some were her work collegues who I had never even met before this night). I still have no intentions (or room! or money!) to invite most of them, and I feel badly:(

    I sucked it up and had fun cause I know my mom was excited and only did it out of love for me. I sent thank you cards to everyone right away. I hope no one judges me too hard that I am not inviting them even though they gave me gifts at my surprise shower, and there is no hard feelings:(

     
    9.
    Member
    395 posts
    Helper bee
    FutureMrsRoos    August 16, 2014   Canada

    No

     
    10.
    Member Icon
    Member
    840 posts
    Busy bee
    BridieBea    December 3, 2015   Glasgow

    @Canadiangardenpartybride:  I think it would be nice of you could have some kind of party where you host the people who didn't get invited to your wedding to show your appreciation of them, but you shouldn't use your shower for this. It's rude to ask people to an event celebrating another event that they weren't invited to, regardless of whether you're asking them to bring a present. 

    The friends who weren't invited probably understand why you couldn't invite them, but asking them to your shower is just going to make them hurt and confused. 

     
    11.
    Member
    1,130 posts
    Bumble bee
    WestCoast    August 9, 2013  

    @Brielle:  such a good solution! If it's not called a shower, that's way better! I +1 this!

     
    12.
    Member
    1,037 posts
    Bumble bee
    aspasia475    December 31, 2017  

    Every so often, I like to go off on a rant* about the "wedding etiquette" advice that you find on wedding boards, being handed out to brides by other brides who got the advice off other wedding boards -- and who often have no knowledge of actual day-to-day etiquette. In fact, there is no such thing as "wedding etiquette". The etiquette you use for your wedding should just be the very highest standard of everyday good manners and cultured behaviour that you use in your day-to-day life. The oft-cited rule that "anyone invited to wedding events should be invited to the wedding" is an example of internet-sourced "wedding etiquette".

    Standard etiquette throws weddings in with other ceremonial rites of passage like christenings, citizenship ceremonies, graduations and so were there is a ceremonial portion that is under the control of some administering authority (the law, the church, a university or so on) followed by a social gathering to celebrate -- a single two-part event. Multi-month-long pageantry of multiple events is reserved for things like royal enthronements ant the Olympics. Standard etiquette does not permit people to orchestrate royal pageantry in celebration of themselves. Yes, there are such things as "showers" and "bachelorettes" that are clearly wedding-related -- but they are properly small and informal, nearly impromptu fun-times arranged by close friends, not large formal parties.

    On the other hand, what formal etiquette not only permits, but even insists upon, is that socially mature adults offer one another hospitality from time to time, in a network of gracious parties and dinners and return invitations, sometimes introducing guests of honour, sometimes just enjoying each others' company. A hostess may at any time invite people to a party -- which is generous of her! As hostess, she will go out of her way to make sure the guests have a good time, and as guests they will contribute to the pleasant occasion and be grateful to their hostess for providing it. This is NOT an imposition on the poor guests! But if they think it is an imposition, they are welcome to decline the invitation -- and no, they do not have to bring a gift, ever, and usually SHOULD not.

    So, your future mother-0in-law may, at any time, invite any people she wishes to invite over for tea (or brunch, or lunch , or dinner, or ...) and she may if she wishes invite you to come as her guest of honour at that time so that she can introduce you to her friends. If she is very generous, she may invite some of your friends at your request in order to giver herself the pleasure of meeting them, and to introduce them to her friends. This is perfectly acceptable, and she may do so at any time.

    What it is not, however, is a "pre-wedding event". As you learned in kindergarten, you would never talk about a party in front of people who won't be invited to it, so your wedding should not be a topic of conversation. If people ask about your wedding, you need simply turn the conversation gracefully onto something else. Talk about your hopes and expectations for married life, ask for housekeeping advice, talk about the transitions that are coming or about the customs of your husbands family that you are still learning -- anything but centrepieces and chair covers and first dances. If you can do that, then you may socialize with whomever you want whenever you want and, whatever "wedding etiquette" may say about it, etiquette will have your back.

    *http://boards.weddingbee.com/topic/big-engagement-party-or-post-wedding-celebration#axzz2LDVtpEm3

     
    13.
    Member Icon
    245 posts
    Helper bee
    maya2008    May 20, 2013  

    @Canadiangardenpartybride:  Call it a bridal brunch instead and say its an opportunity to share in the excitement!

     
    14.
    Member
    5,098 posts
    Bee Keeper
    Rubbs    July 2012  

    This is not right. Would you really attend a shower if you weren't invited to the wedding?!?! 

     
    15.
    Member
    1,256 posts
    Bumble bee
    mrs.stormylove    December 2011   The City

    I guess it depends. At my work it is very common to have showers for other coworkers that we all attend knowing we aren't all invited to the wedding. We work with a lot of people so it just isn't possible to invite everyone. Also churches work that way as well sometimes. But in every day life if a friend invited me to a shower but not the wedding I would think that is strange and not go. Unless she eloped or had a family only wedding. But if other friend were invited and not myself I wouldn't want to be included in pre-wedding events.  you can change the name of it to whatever you like but people are going to look at it like a shower. Only you really know if your friend would be more offended being invited or not invited so go with your gut.

     
    16.
    Member
    815 posts
    Busy bee
    mrs_brownie    August 24, 2013   MI

    anybody you invite to wedding events should be invited to the wedding. i would never go to a shower for someone that didn't invite me to their wedding.

     
    17.
    Member Icon
    Member
    42 posts
    Newbee
    xjamit    August 29, 2014  

    i would never go to a shower for someone that didn't invite me to their wedding.

     
    18.
    Member
    4,658 posts
    Honey bee
    AlwaysSunny    February 2013  

    I would ask FMIL to host a lunch instead. Just say it's a chance to meet everyone but it is not a wedding event. 

     

    Reply

    You must log in to post.





    Copyright 2004-2013, Weddingbee.com
     

    Find your vendors on Weddingbee


    More
    User Posts Today
    MrsPanda99 43
    AlwaysSunny 32
    jesssamesssa 29
    vorpalette 25
    Gemstone 24
    This Time Round 23
    Caroheart 21
    Cyri 19
    MrsBeck 19
    ajillity81 19
    User Posts Today
    renierose 19
    atlbride2013 9
    This Time Round 9
    MrsPanda99 8
    MrsBeck 7
    FauxPas2012 6
    sablemuse 5
    mgol25 5
    DaisyBelle 5
    Woodstock 4

    Favors by Weddingbee

    Shop Now ยป


    Etiquette

    More