Post # 1
Hi bees! Getting opinions on here has been so helpful, and here’s yet another poll! We’ve been sitting on a 7.5 mm Amora moissanite and it is about time I decided already!!
#1: Double prong, cathedral
but not cushion:
lots more pics: http://betterthandiamond.com/discussion/ubbthreads.php/topics/725115/all/I_wanted_to_share_D
#2: Classic solitaire
i love the videos of this ring, much better than that CAD image: http://www.bluenile.com/diamond-engagement-ring-setting-platinum_19010
#3: Monique Lhuillier solitaire (would get this remade since it’s Blue Nile)
I love them all, they all let the stone stand out, timeless, and not too ornate which wouldn’t really match my style. I’m a natural/earthy kinda girl, and the 3rd one would speak well to a naturey band. The 2nd looks like straight candy to me though haha and the 1st is so elegant and well designed. I can’t go wrong with any of them and I also can’t choose!! help me bees! thanks!!
Post # 3
@chillinchillin: Honestly they’re so similar, you can’t go wrong. I voted #2.
Post # 4
They are very similar, but I like #1 and #3 the best. What’s your gut telling you?
Post # 5
@ceebree: yeah, from face on they’ll look almost identical haha cept the subtle detail of double prongs on one. thanks for your opinion!!
Post # 6
Love #1– cathedral settings are so pretty! I feel like they let more light in = more sparkle!
Post # 7
@Ms.GoodEarth: my guts telling me ‘weeeee!!!’ LOL!!!! I’m so ready to get this thing on and ordered already! My SO has the ‘they’re all pretty!’ input, so I need some fresh opinions!! thanks!
Post # 8
All very similar, yet with different features. I voted #1 but I don’t like double claws. I do love the openings on the side as the shank rises to meet the basket.
Post # 9
I voted the classic solitare. However, if you are getting a large stone, the first one would be my pick.
Post # 10
@Rubbs: thanks ladies! it’s a 7.5mm (1.5 carat)
omg getting so excited that deciding is going to be over so soon! (and ironically with someone so simple!!:))
Post # 11
I like number one or three… I voted one, I think it’s my favourite! I really don’t think you could go wrong with any of these choices 🙂
Post # 12
@chillinchillin: I vote for 3, i like the head, it’s beautiful. I don’t like double prongs.
Post # 13
Love the double prong #1!
Post # 14
I’m torn between one and three, but number one wins out. I love the prongs, it looks so elegant.
Post # 15
Post # 16
I know this is an older thread but i voted 3 since thats the ring i’m planning on getting for my hopefully fiance-to-be.
Chillinchillin: i’m just wondering why you mentioned that you’s get the ring remade since it’s from bluenile? Is there a problem with the quality of the ring itself ir the rings from bluenule?