Post # 1
Hello all! Our engagement ring shopping ventuer has come down to the final two–the one on the left is a six prong solitare in 18k gold without the diamond. We already purchased a diamond that’s the same size as the one on the right. Thank you so much for your help! I love them both!
Post # 3
I voted for the solitaire, but I’m really partial to solitaires. They’re classic and elegant. I’m one of the few bees who really isn’t fond of halos. They’re too trendy and overdone IMO.
Post # 4
I really like the halo- but what you’re wearing is my dream ring 🙂
Post # 5
@Soon_To_Be_Mrs_T: +1 (I used to be a fan of halos but now I’m very much all for a great solitaire.)
@carltonjo: Which do you like best? I love the slightly wider wedding band with the solitaire.
Post # 6
@carltonjo: Both are just soooo lovely, but I have to vote solitaire. It looks lovely on your hand and I feel that they are timeless. Because of how simple and elegant they are, I don’t think they will go out of fashion or that you will ever get sick of the style or looking at it. 🙂
Post # 7
Solitaire. Classic and beautiful!
Post # 8
Petite halo for sure!! It’s beautiful!! I also prefer how the matching wedding band has stones across the full top of your finger. To me it’s a younger setting too.
Good luck choosing!
Post # 9
halo halo halo halo!!!! That ring is beautiful!
Post # 10
Thank you all SO much for your feedback 🙂 Im leaning toward the solitare because I could just see myself loving that one forever, you know? If I was the type of lady who was open to getting it reset later in life, I would probably go with the halo. Your opinions were all so helpful! By the way, I went to Rogers & Hollands jewelers and they were amazing–if you like either of those rings go there!
Post # 11
@Soon_To_Be_Mrs_T: +1 on the halos being over done. I’m sooooo glad mine isn’t one (no offense to anyone who has a halo ring!!)
Post # 12
I love the Halo, however I agree that it’s over done. They are beautiful but I do believe everyone has one. Solitaires are classic. I have a solitaire and had a bit of a hard time buying a wedding band but instead we bought a filler ring. It’s 2 rings in one. So I have the diamond band at the bottom and then 2 more diamonds surrounding my solitaire. I have a smaller diamond so we bought the filler band to amp it up.
You already have the whole set so you have no prob. I would go with the less overdone one.