Musicians for Ceremony?
more by trilby
No older images
Brightly Colored Bridesmaid Shoes
more in Shoes
SHOE HELP!!
First Dress Fitting?
more in Boards
Europe or Italy Honeymoon?

Real Manolos vs. Knock offs?

posted 3 years ago in Shoes
  • poll: Should I do a major splurge and buy the real Manolo shoes or be sensible and get the knockoffs?
    Real Manolo Blahnik shoes : (24 votes)
    28 %
    Knockoff version : (63 votes)
    72 %
  •  
    1.
    Member
    38 posts
    Newbee
    trilby    March 20, 2009  

    In my search for wedding shoes, I saw a pair of Manolo Blahnik's and fell in love!  They're the jeweled satin d'orsay Sedaraby's (http://www.neimanmarcus.com/store/catalog/prod.jhtml?itemId=prod75800022&parentId=cat000209&masterId=cat000199&index=11&cmCat=cat000000cat000141cat000149cat000199cat000209) in teal, which they didn't have in my size and can't find anywhere else.  The woman at the Manolo store suggested that I buy the white satin and dye them, which makes me a bit nervous.  Then I saw the knockoff dyeable version (http://www.bridalshoes.com/item/dyeable-3-inch/Onyx.asp) for 1/7th of the cost and am now trying to decide between going for the BIG splurge and having a pair of designer shoes that I know will be high quality, comfortable and will always feel special when I wear them (and they're not just wedding shoes; they can get plenty of use after the wedding) or being reasonable and going for the lower end version that will probably not be nearly as comfortable or hold up as well.  Keep in mind - I'm not normally a shoe girl!  I live in flip-flops and sneakers but there is something about the Manolo's that are just calling to me.  Opinions and suggestions needed!

     
    2.
    Member Icon
    Member
    614 posts
    Busy bee
    emileee       San Jose, CA

    i wouldn't assume that the real manolos are going to be comfortable just because they are expensive.  i've seen plenty of brides take off their expensive designer shoes halfway through the reception because their feet hurt! 

    Attachments

    1. Real Manolos vs. Knock offs? :  wedding shoes manolo blahnik dorsay sedaraby splurge Img bling2.jpg (21.2 KB, 97 downloads) 2 years old
    2. Real Manolos vs. Knock offs? :  wedding shoes manolo blahnik dorsay sedaraby splurge Img bling1.jpg (30.3 KB, 43 downloads) 2 years old
     
    3.
    Hostess
    7,632 posts
    Bumble
    Beekeeper
    MightySapphire      

    No no, Manolos are always comfortable.  One reason for the price tag?  Because they are designed to be comfortable and actually support your arch.  Lower cost designers may not necessarily be so, but Manolos are...oh...so...comfortable!  I would go with the splurge!  You only get one wedding day, why not treat yourself?  I have been looking for a pair of Jimmy Choos or Manolos for my wedding, I just can't find THE SHOEs.  I've kind of given up, and started looking at other shoes, but there's still the part of me that wishes Manolo made a pair that would be as perfect as you're describing.  Go for it!

    Attachments

    1. Real Manolos vs. Knock offs? :  wedding shoes manolo blahnik dorsay sedaraby splurge Img 9B-869x1045.png (62.3 KB, 51 downloads) 2 years old
    2. Real Manolos vs. Knock offs? :  wedding shoes manolo blahnik dorsay sedaraby splurge Img P1000164.jpg (6.1 KB, 46 downloads) 2 years old
     
    4.
    Hostess
    2,252 posts
    Buzzing bee
    chelseamorning    November 1, 2008   Washington, DC/Atlanta

    If you're normally a flip-flops and sneakers girl, then where other than your wedding would you realistically wear the Manolos? If you weren't getting married, would you buy these shoes?

    Is these any way you can try on both styles and see if there is an appreciable difference in comfort? I read some reviews of those particular Manolos and many people said that they fit strangely.

    $700 is a lot of money to spend on shoes when shoes are not something you are particularly into. If I was going to splurge on myself, I would do it on something that meant a lot to me personally.

     
    5.
    Member
    869 posts
    Busy bee
    monalisa670    August 2009   Boston

    Those are hot and you seem to be leaning toward them but feeling guilty. I say go for it! I splurged and got a pair of Manolo's for my wedding too. I plan on wearing them after the big day, as they are very unique and not your typical wedding shoe! You can see a pic similar to them here : http://www.footcandyshoes.com/istar.asp?a=6&id=CATALINA!BLA&csurl=%2Fistar.asp%3Fa%3D3%26dept%3DF%26manufacturer%3DBLA%26  -But they are entirely ivory and were $600. I am in love with them. I know it is a lot for a shoe but I have heard about the comfort factor with Manolo's, they are perfect for my vintage look, and I could not resist. The first thing I noticed about them (seeing as how they are my first and likely only pair of Manolo's!) is how well-made they are- they have hidden heel straps to keep your foot in place. We'll see how they go with the long night of Greek dancing, but I'm hoping for the best! Go for it!

     
    6.
    Bee Icon
    Bee
    834 posts
    Busy bee
    crabcake      

    I am a shoe girl, but I just can't justify $700 dollars for shoes.  People, that is more than my gown cost!  I suppose if I had a bigger budget, I probably would have demanded designer shoes, but eh...  Anyway, I bought Liz Rene's Melissa, it's a silk d'orsay and I love it so much.  It's really comfortable, dyeable, and the heel isn't too high.  I'm coloring them pink for the wedding, and then I'm not sure what, perhaps black (I just don't see much use in pink shoes). 

    Attachments

    1. Real Manolos vs. Knock offs? :  wedding shoes manolo blahnik dorsay sedaraby splurge Img 758.jpg (10.7 KB, 179 downloads) 3 years old
     
    7.
    Member
    38 posts
    Newbee
    trilby    March 20, 2009  

    The problem is, I completely agree with what all of you guys are saying!  It is a major splurge and perhaps a bit impractical since I will probably only wear them again on really special occasions.  But, I'll also only wear my wedding dress once and that certainly cost more than a pair of Manolos!  My fiance thinks I should buy the real thing and that I deserve to spoil myself, especially on my wedding day but I am seriously torn.  My hidden glamour girl side is at war with my sensible, thifty side...now I've got to figure out which is gonna win!

     
    8.
    Hostess
    2,252 posts
    Buzzing bee
    chelseamorning    November 1, 2008   Washington, DC/Atlanta

    You said, "But, I'll also only wear my wedding dress once and that certainly cost more than a pair of Manolos!"

    I say, ah, but everyone will be looking at your dress, whereas no one will be looking at your feet!

    Unless you've got a short dress, your shoes will only peep out from beneath your gown. A gown has a huge impact on how you look on your wedding day. Shoes...they'll be hidden away and no one is going to notice but you. So splurge on yourself if you want, but splurge in a way that makes sense for the kind of girl you are.

     
    9.
    Hostess
    2,683 posts
    Sugar bee
    suzanno    7/12/08   Richland, WA

    True - nobody will look at your feet unless you have an obsessive need to pull up your dress and show them off.  However, everybody will notice if you stop mingling and dancing halfway through the reception because your feet hurt, and as least a few people will notice if you have to take your shoes off altogether and then drag your dress across the floor until the bottom few inches are black as a dust mop.

    If you somehow must wear $700 shoes, and you have nothing else to spend the money on, I guess you should go for it.  If you're going to be scrimping elsewhere (or paying off the credit card bill for six months after the wedding) it hardly seems worth it.  Either way, you should go for comfort - so if the knock-offs are going to be unwearable after an hour, I would skip them and go for a nice pair of something wearable.  I got a gorgeous pair of ruby-red Soffts, which were not only lots of fun but great for dancing all night!  Cost:  $120.

     
    10.
    Bee
    1,250 posts
    Bumble bee
    deviledegg    May 24, 2009  

    I think the Knock-offs are the way to go, but then again shoes are not an area where I splurge.  And Dying a $700 pair of shoes seems super risky to me. 

    I don't think people will spend too much time looking at your feet, anyway.  The knock-offs will look great and so will the extra cash in your bank account.

     
    11.
    Member Icon
    Member
    120 posts
    Blushing bee
    MissTeaberry    August 1, 2008   Philadelphia

    Go for the knock-offs!!!!  You will regret spending the extra money more than you will regret not having the Manolos!  If you do regret not getting them one day, get a different pair of Manolos that you will get more wear out of!  Try to order the knock-offs from a website like shoebuy, where they have free shipping and free returns, and if they are THAT uncomfortable, you can ship them back.  If your dress was a huge splurge, it was probably because you couldn't get it anywhere else by any other designer - you easily can get the shoes for less money by another designer!  The extra money you save on the expensive ones will come in handy on your honeymoon!  :)

     
    12.
    Member
    102 posts
    Blushing bee
    cindylouwho    October10, 2010   Jersey Shore, New Jersey

    If it isn't really in your budget, go for the knock-offs.  You really need to dig designer shoes to rationalize the high cost to yourself.  If you find you do have it in your budget and it is a priority, then go for it! 

    I am a shoe-priority person.  I've taken on several little jobs in order to save up the extra money a pair of Christian Louboutin's will cost.  I have heard from others how utterly ridiculous it is to spend so much, but I feel as long as nothing else suffers, and its going to make me feel even better that day, why not?  

     
    13.
    Member Icon
    Member
    1 posts
    Wannabee
    megblan    april 4, 2009   los angeles

    Go for the real thing.  I went through the same battle and ended up splurging on a pair of fabulous aqua manolos for my wedding in a couple of months.  And you know what?  I feel sexy just thinking about them.  Your fiance is right--go for it.

    Also, they are fantastic for dancing.  Don't spoil the look by switching into a pair of flip-flops half way through the night. 

     

     

     
    14.
    Member
    201 posts
    Helper bee
    Miss Bliss    January 2, 2010   Iowa

    If you normally are a flip flop an tenny girl, I would honestly go for the knock-offs.  They look like the Manolos and the fact that when would you wear them again, if you like flip flops and tennis shoes. 

    Plus, trying to throw on a pair of 3.5 inch heels for your wedding day if you don't normally wear heals and walk gracefullying in a wedding dress, might not be the easiest!  I wear heals and I absolutely LOVE Manolo's, but I can't bring myself to splurg on them for my wedding day because I would have to get them shorteneted because my FH and I would look eye to eye with eachother.

     GO with what you want!

     
    15.
    Member Icon
    Member
    7 posts
    Newbee
    Ms Yoga    May 30, 2009   New York, NY

    My two cents is this:  it's all about your budget!  If you an afford them, then go for it!  If you can't, then go with the knock-offs! 

     If the real things are a must but you're cutting it close with the budget, then look for another place you can make a $200 - $400 cut (like maybe only do one flower arrangement for the ceremony instead os two??)

     
    16.
    Member Icon
    Member
    1 posts
    Wannabee
    jennanne    September 5  

     
    As a girl who loves her shoes, but also watches her budget, I'd say knock off--at least that's what I'm doing.  
     
    I love my Manolos and Choos, but  only buy styles that are long-lasting and that I know I'll wear again and again---otherwise I can't justify the expense in my mind.  I love the Manolo Sederaby's for a wedding dress, but wasn't sure I'd wear them a ton (as opposed to my trusty black Manolos I can rock anyplace) so I opted for a really fantastic knock off by Pelle Moda.  They were around $200, look just like the real thing and are comfy.
     
    I love them, nobody can tell the difference, and I have been able to splurge on shoes that I know I'll rock daily.
     
     

     
    17.
    Member
    246 posts
    Helper bee
    hisMrs    October 11, 2009   San Diego

    Knockoffs = <3

     

    Go the cheaper route all the way!!! :) No one will ever know! Except for us! ;)

     
    18.
    Member
    435 posts
    Helper bee
    tenmylove    August 22, 2009   Wisconsin

    OMG... I have been coveting those Manolo's... get them! When will you ever get a chance to wear them again? I had been searching the internet for Manolo's and Jimmy Choo's for the wedding but just can't find anything that is on the "cheaper" end and that I like. I settled for Martinez Valero.

     
    19.
    Hostess
    7,536 posts
    Bumble
    Beekeeper
    bellenga    July 31, 2010   Georgia

    Manolo's are great shoes, as are Louboutins, but also check out Marciano's line.  (not Guess but their couture line, Marciano).  They are a little bit less than Manolos (about 250-300 range) and very comfy...very gorgeous too!  Mine is Tessa, by Marciano.

     
    20.
    Member Icon
    Member
    252 posts
    Helper bee
    Surgie      

    I know you asked about Manolos, but I have to put in a plug for Hey Lady shoes: http://www.shopheylady.com/
    Super stylish AND comfortable. All of their styles can be ordered with either a 3" or 4" heel. They have a Poron insole - the kind used in running shoes. Most are in the $250-$350 range. I was able to get an advance order on the champagne goggles and Emily was great to work with.

     
    21.
    Member
    786 posts
    Busy bee
    amandopolis      

    I have to chime in in support of Manolos.  I have a pair and they are hands down the most comfortable shoes I've ever worn.  I can wear them for a full day walking around and not have so much as a blister when I get home. 

     
    22.
    Member
    151 posts
    Blushing bee
    southernbella    07/18/2009   Charlotte, NC

    ethically, I'd say go for real, always but I had a bridesmaid buy a pair of manolo sedaraby's from an ioffer seller in silver and I cannot tell the difference between her replicas and my real ones. I was floored.

     
    23.
    Member
    1,245 posts
    Bumble bee
    realeastcoaster    July 11, 2009   Canada

    For that price, I agree with the previous posters who suggested going for the knockoffs and spending the money on something you really KNOW you want to splurge on, not something you think you might like to have but aren't sure.

     

    Reply

    You must log in to post.





    Visit our sister sites eHarmony
    Online Dating
    eHarmony Advice
    Dating Advice
    Project Wedding
    Wedding Songs
    JustMommies
    Pregnancy Calendar
    Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
     

    Find your vendors on Weddingbee

    Real reviews from brides in your area!

    Favors by Weddingbee

    • Favors by season

    Shop Now ยป

    Find Registry Find Registry Find Registry

    More
    User Posts Today
    MissBoPeep 89
    beargoose 54
    hisgoosiegirl 51
    Mrs.KMM 46
    ndreighton 46
    BetterSherm 42
    akp0702 41
    stardustintheeyes 36
    Beckster329 36
    MrsPom 35

    Shoes

    User Posts Today
    sopranokris 3
    RockStar33 2
    WillyNilly 2
    Rehanakn 2
    MsMindle 2
    Mrs. Chai 1
    dcdt212 1
    metalbride 1
    wmontano77 1
    GroovyHippieChick 1
    More