Post # 1
So AD.com said i could exchange my ring.
i have two options i can
go smaller with my three stone 7.5mm wiht 4mm side stones
get this moissy ring i saw
itd be 7.5mm center stone, and its around $300 more
im filling out my return request in a bit and im not sure what i should do i love the three stone but i love the mixed gold color on the halo =/
Post # 3
i love asha but would maybe prefer the moissanite and see how it works out
Post # 5
Are you worried the moissanite wont give you enough finger coverage? As I know you had this problem with other rings, that is why you love the three stone so much. Could you switch to a moissanite three stone if you want to try out moissanite?
Post # 6
I personally like the second ring because it is more unique
Post # 7
i think both of these rings drown out the size of the main stone… if you do the first, maybe get smaller side stones? i don’t really like the 2nd one.
Post # 8
I voted 3 stone because I personally prefer that setting. However, if I was choosing moissy vs Asha I’d go moissy without question.
The two-tone would certainly be unique! Do you prefer that setting?
Post # 9
I voted for the 3 stone because you said a few days ago that your 3 stone was the last ring you’d get.
Post # 10
i DO love the three stone and ive never had problems with my asha, but since this was my LAST upgrade lol i want to have soemthign that will last, thats why im debating if i should go with moissy.
and a three stone in moissy is waay out of my budget
i think the moissy setting would look great with a yellow gold plain band, idk FI kind of scared me off the three stone with his “too big” comments.
Post # 11
@abirdword: I was thinking the same thing. I remember you posting that new ring and “Finally! The Ring”.
I am not a fan of moissy but I do love two tone. You could always get yellow gold bands for one or both sides of your current 3-stone. I normally don’t like 3-stone but it looked great on you in all your pictures.
Good luck with either decision
Post # 12
i know im SUPER INDECISIVE and i hate it *grumble grumble*
i like the fact that whatever band i get with the second ring WILL sit flush.
Well AD said they can make the ring with an asha center stone also, so im debating what to do.
i just hopei can have the ring by my wedding date eek.
Post # 13
Honey, that 3stone is just stunning. Stick with the 3stone and if you like the look of two tones of gold, I suggest you get a yellow or rose gold wedding band.
Post # 14
@Missus_LLC: If you want something that’ll last, why not upgrade to moissy in a year or two?
Post # 15
Love the 3 stone look. I am bias though because I have one.
The 3 stone is gorgeous on your hand and you can always add the other toned gold as bands.
The 2nd ring choice had a clover look to it. The 3 stone is classic and timeless.
I know you asked for our opinions but do you have a gut feeling on either one?
Post # 16
Is this your engagement ring or wedding band? If you are planning to add a wedding band to it you might want to consider the first one. But I do love the originality of the second one. I have a similar three stone setting and I see it more and more. It would be nice to have something a little bit more unique.