10 sec. ECLIPSE teaser for the teaser released!
more by KLP2010
Urban Outfitters GOING BRIDAL!
Help! Trying to find an old post about painting
more in Home
Things that go "Woof" in my yard...
Holy Cow! How do guest lists seem to grow overnight?
more in Boards
Why are girls so BLIND!

Stupid 2/28 regulation is going to cost us our house

posted 2 years ago in Home
  • 1 Members Subscribed To Topic
  •  
    1.
    Member
    4,199 posts
    Honey bee
    KLP2010    October 30, 2010  

    So, if you've been following my threads, we finally after a ton of hoops, got our offer accepted. Finally got the inspection completed. Finally even picked out the appliances and floors we would put in.

    Yesterday I brought all our financial documents to the bank. When I left, the mortgage broker was like, "OK, I'll be putting all this in and let you know if I need anything else." A few hours later I get a call from our Realtor, NOT the broker. (pansy)

    "Hi, K. I've got some really bad and serious news. As of 2/28, a new regulation was passed that requires you both have 3 trade lines and you only have 2. You're no longer approved to get a conventional loan."

    Um.... WHAT. So, we had OVER 40-45% to put down. We were approved for the full price of the house, but only needed just about half of that on the mortgage. The reason we have money to put down, is that we're both REALLY big on only buying what we can afford. i.e. Our cars are paid off, no student loans, etc. FI got a line of credit (and already paid it off) to buy my ring and that was his 3rd. I only have 2. So, in order to get a conventional loan, I have to go open a new credit card and wait about 3-6 months for it to get a "history."

    WTF - I'm being punished for being smart with my money. This is apparently a Fannie and Freddie regulation, which means, just about every bank we attempt to go through would have this. Anyone know of a bank which DOESNT report to F&F?

    HOWEVER - We're approved for a FHA loan. Meaning, we're only required to put down a little bit, you've got PMI insurance, etc. i'm not entirely sure of what happens if you go with a FHA and you put down more than 20%. I thought the PMI would go away but we're not sure. Also, the interest rate is usually higher.

    I'm just beyond frustrated. Part of me is thinking maybe this is God's way of saying, "goodness how many hoops do you need to make yourself jump through before you see my plan." Part of me is wondering if it's just the way things are these days post bailout. Even my dad the day before closing wasn't sure he'd get his loan, and he's a Oil Co. Exec.

    I'm just beyond words right now. We have time to establish a new line of credit on me before the wedding.... but we'll loose this particular house and the $8,000 tax credit. As of last night I thought we were going to let it go, but FI this morning called and wants to exhaust a few possibilities first.... So, I'm off to call a few places and see what's what.

    Basically, we need your thoughts and prayers. I'm just glad I didn't turn in my 60 days notice yet :-(

     
    2.
    Hostess
    10,729 posts
    Sugar
    Beekeeper
    crebre80    November 20, 2010   Baton Rouge, LA

    ((HUGS)) I have  a strange question, can he add you to any of his lines of credit and that way you can pick up the history which would sort of fake the system or can your parents?

     
    3.
    Member
    915 posts
    Busy bee
    Miss Britt    June 25, 2010   Kalamazoo, MI

    Can the house just be in your FI's name?  Since he has the three lines? 

    I know that may not be for everyone...but when we bought our house it could only be in my FI's name because my job is technically on a contract, even though I am full time and everything.  That could be an option if you are in a hurry to buy it and don't want to wait the six months.

    It sucks that you are being punished for being responsible, but it's stuff like that always made me have a few credit cards just in case...even though they didn't have a balance.

     
    4.
    Member Icon
    Member
    1,158 posts
    Bumble bee
    mrsmdphd    April 17, 2009  

    I'm so SO sorry you're dealing with this. I don't have a lot of advice for you because we bought our place almost a year ago, and this regulation wasn't in place, so I don't know how to deal with it.  But I think you're right, since the financial collapse, banks are lending to almost no one--they've done a complete 180 from their lending 3 years ago, and they're punishing people who would be excellent homeowners and mortgage holders.  It took us FOREVER to get approved because my FI is earning his salary through an MD/PhD program, so he's paid a stipend by the NIH (National Institute of Health), not a standard "salary" by a company.  He makes the same as what he made when he was earning a salary, but because it's called a stipend we almost didn't get our mortgage.  They kept telling us it wasn't considered income (to which I said, "great! would you mind letting the IRS know, because it would be lovely if they didn't ask us to pay taxes on it!"  They didn't go for it.)  Eventually we worked it out, but I think it took YEARS off my life.  So I'm so so sorry that you're going through this right now, and I do feel your pain.  Is there a second opinion that you can get?  Just to make sure that you're getting the right information?  Because I found that sometimes the people we dealth with just didn't have any idea what they were talking about.  Good luck!

     
    5.
    Member
    4,199 posts
    Honey bee
    KLP2010    October 30, 2010  

    Unfortunately, he got hurt at work about 2.5 years ago and his income suffered a lot because of it. He doesn't have a strong enough work history from the past 2 years to qualify on his own, he needs my income, I need his credit :-(

    I'm about to talk to a financial advisor, I'll put the idea out there but I highly doubt adding me would "fool" anyone :-/

     
    6.
    Member
    9,971 posts
    Buzzing
    Beekeeper
    CorgiTales    February 1, 2011  

    Buy under FHA (no PMI when you put more than 22% down), open up a new line of credit, and refinance in 1 year for a conventional loan. Yes you'll probably have some fees... but not enough to eat up the 8k tax credit and lower interest rate. 

     

    Note: When you go fha they charge you a fee that is a % of the house. Ours was like 3,500. BUT if you refinance within 3 years you get most of that back. Talk to your realtor about this-- for real. 

     
    7.
    Member
    550 posts
    Busy bee
    asunw    June 10, 2011   Southern Illinois

    I'm with Miss Britt, my FI and I purchased our home in July 2008 so I can't really help you but because the FI is 5 years older than me and had plenty of credit our mortgage is only in his name.  It worked well for us this time and its something you may want to consider esspeicially with all that you have to put down.

    Also PMI insurance drops off automatically when you have 20% equity in your home so with such a large down payment you should never have to pay it.

     
    8.
    Member
    4,075 posts
    Honey bee
    Amaryllis    July 2, 2011  

    Oh, man, I can only imagine how shocked and disappointed you must be. I hope that it works out for you, or maybe this is a sign that there is something better waiting for you? Good luck!

     
    9.
    Member
    390 posts
    Helper bee
    owlbride    October 10, 2009   Houston

    No bueno :(  I'm so sorry. This is just crummy. My thoughts, prayers and hugs go out to you.

     
    10.
    Hostess
    3,884 posts
    Honey bee
    caszos    June 2010   Florida

    I think Corgi has a good point.  Just apply with the FHA loan and refinance when needed.  Talk to the realtor or mortgage lender to discuss the details of this.

    I dont think this is God telling you to walk away.  Buying a house is hard.  If everyone walked away when issues like this came up, I doubt anyone would be in a house! 

    It is very stupid you are being punished for not having enough history.  I have had 2 credit cards open for a while (over 2 years) and they still identified them as "new" accounts.

     
    11.
    Member
    5,184 posts
    Bee Keeper
    2PeasinaPod       Philadelphia

    Go with the FHA. We put 20% down on our house, but went with the FHA loan b/c in the long run, it saved us more money than a conventional loan. You don't have PMI with an FHA, it's insured by the government rather than a private mortgage company. There's absolutely nothing wrong with an FHA, and as soon as you own 20% of the appraised value of your home, the insurance falls off. Since you're putting down way more than that, you'll be set.

    Again...nothing wrong with an FHA, and in the long run, it could save you money over a conventional loan.

     
    12.
    Member
    3,763 posts
    Honey bee
    JamaicaBride    May 14, 2011   Charlotte, NC

    I am with Corgi on this one...For FHA loans, if you put 20% or more down, you don't have to pay PMI. Also, this will get you in the home you want and you can refinance at a later date.

     
    13.
    Hostess
    7,632 posts
    Bumble
    Beekeeper
    MightySapphire      

    I'm so sorry, I know how excited you've been!  I hope that you can find something that will work for you and your FI!

     
    14.
    Hostess
    16,857 posts
    Honey
    Beekeeper
    MissAsB    June 6, 2009   Married in CO, Living in AL

    I'm sorry about this.  I would go with the FHA loan.  You don't have to pay PMI if you own more than 20% of the home.

     
    15.
    5,478 posts
    Bee Keeper
    lilyfaith    June 23, 2012   Lakeview, Chicago

    That's ridiculous... I'm sorry. :( Sounds like Corgi has good advice, though. 

     
    16.
    Hostess
    4,102 posts
    Honey bee
    AnnieAAA    October 25, 2009   Dallas, TX

    Bummer! Hope everything works out for you!

     

     
    17.
    Bee
    345 posts
    Helper bee
    birdofparadise      

    on the plus side, we found that an fha loan equaled a lower rate over conventional. therefore, your monthly payments could be lower!

     
    18.
    Member
    4,199 posts
    Honey bee
    KLP2010    October 30, 2010  

    We're being told that no matter how much we put down on a FHA we HAVE to pay PMI for 5 years. Even if we put down 45%

     

     
    19.
    Member
    3,763 posts
    Honey bee
    JamaicaBride    May 14, 2011   Charlotte, NC

    Here is a link that provides some additional info. I don't think you are being provided with accurate information unless the rules have recently changed.

    http://www.ehow.com/facts_5272265_do-pay-pmi-fha-loan.html

    I will also paste it in...hope it fits

    Do You Have to Pay PMI on an FHA Loan?


    Contributor

    By Shauna Zamarripa
    eHow Contributing Writer
    Article Rating: (0 Ratings)

    PMI stands for Private Mortgage Insurance. This is an additional fee added on to a home buyer's monthly payment that is paid into an escrow account to protect the lender from loss in the event of default. The amount of PMI that is paid is typically 0.5 percent of the total loan amount and is added into the monthly payment for all loans. Knowing the rules for PMI and how they translate in FHA loans is important in determining your overall affordability of a monthly payment.

    //

      PMI vs. MIP

    1. PMI is typically only charged with conventional loans. FHA loans have something similar to PMI, which is referred to as MIP or a mortgage insurance premium. Nevertheless, the amount of 0.5 percent is the same when charged to buyers on a home regardless of the term used to describe it.
    2. Upfront Cost

    3. The upfront cost for MIP to buyers at closing is 1.75 percent of the total loan amount. This can be waived if a buyer puts over 20 percent on a property.
    4. Down Payment

    5. FHA loans require a minimum investment of 3.5 percent. With that the MIP will range from 0.5 percent to 0.55 percent. Putting a minimum of 5 percent down on a property will keep the MIP stable at 0.5 percent.
    6. Time Frame

    7. MIP is only charged until the loan principal has been paid down by 22 percent. This would typically take about six years with a 6 percent interest rate, and must be verified by an independent appraisal.
    8. Considerations

    9. When factoring in MIP, and paying the home down by 22 percent this is not just made up of monthly principal payments, but is also determined by the home's year over year appreciation. In states where appreciation is higher for real estate values, MIP premiums can be eliminated in as little as three years.
    10. Expert Insight

    11. If considering making a 20 percent down investment in a property, it might be more financially responsible to consider a conventional loan as opposed to an FHA loan where you might qualify for a lesser interest rate due to down payment. FHA loan interest rates are based completely on market value and can only be lowered if an additional fee is paid to buy the rate down.

    //

     
    20.
    Member
    4,199 posts
    Honey bee
    KLP2010    October 30, 2010  

    Ya, i've yet to see anything anywhere saying that I would still be paying PMI or MIP or something....  I mean, I don't get what the H is going on....

    I've been on the phone all day with mortgage brokers and what not, I feel like I'm going to explode. 

     
    21.
    Hostess
    3,884 posts
    Honey bee
    caszos    June 2010   Florida

    Jamaica is correct, it is not technically called PMI if you do an FHA loan.

    http://www.fhaloan.com/fha_article.cfm?id=19

    IF THE FHA INSURES MY LOAN, WHY DO I HAVE TO PAY A MORTGAGE INSURANCE PREMIUM?

    Mortgage insurance is a standard part of buying a home. It’s a requirement on both conventional loans and FHA guaranteed loans. The mortgage insurance on conventional loans includes what’s known as Private Mortgage Insurance. To get an FHA loan, you pay what’s called an Up Front Mortgage Insurance Premium or UFMIP for short, plus a monthly Mortgage Insurance Premium or MIP.

    HOW MUCH DO I PAY UP FRONT?

    The cost of Up Front Mortgage Insurance Payments is calculated at 1.75% of the base loan amount. You have the option to include this amount in your FHA mortgage. Ask your lender how this works.

    HOW MUCH DO I PAY EVERY MONTH?

    Your monthly mortgage insurance includes a premium of .55% of the loan amount. You pay this every month for at least five years. There is no set amount of mortgage insurance or fixed rate which applies to all borrowers since UFMIP and MIP rates are determined based on the amount of your particular FHA mortgage or FHA home loan.

    WHEN DO I STOP PAYING?

    If your FHA loan lasts 15 years or more, your MIP will be cancelled when the loan-to-value (LTV) reaches 78%. This is calculated based on the original value of your FHA home loan and only if the borrower has paid the annual MIP amounts for at least five years. For FHA mortgages with terms of less than 15 years, monthly insurance payments or MIP stop when the LTV reaches 78%.

    The kind of insurance the FHA offers your loan and the kind of mortgage insurance payments you make as a borrower are quite different. It may interest you to know that people taking out conventional home loans are also required to carry mortgage insurance. Terms may be different between private mortgage insurers and the kind of insurance required by the FHA, but the basic coverages are similar. If you are unsure of terms, specific length of time you must carry mortgage insurance, ask your lender to explain the UFMIP and MIP programs in detail.

     
    22.
    Member
    1,365 posts
    Bumble bee
    Vitsippa    October 10, 2010  

    Oh man ... I'm so sorry to hear you're going through this! I hope the people you're talking to don't have the info correct regarding the PMI. Also, when did you start the process (when did you submit your bid)? Because it may be possible to get around the requirement if it was before 2/28. If you talk to the right person, they might be able to make it happen with that much down payment.

    Take deep breaths and take a break and do something non-house related tonight. It'll rejuvenate you. Wish you the best! *HUGS*

     
    23.
    Member
    3,353 posts
    Sugar bee
    MsMamaBear       Atlanta

    I agree,Vitsippa.I thought you started the threads on your house before 2/28? Maybe you could get around it anyway.

    I really hope so. I've been rooting for y'all and this house. I SO agree with getting what you can afford, not what you THINK you will afford in the future or something silly like that.

    I don't think God is saying this isn't the house. It's just how things are right now and it does make you frustrated when you have to pay for other people being irresponsible. Yell

    I'm praying for yall!!

     

     
    24.
    Member
    4,199 posts
    Honey bee
    KLP2010    October 30, 2010  

    Nope. Even though we were ratified before 2/28 it's because we weren't "Closed" before 2/28

    UPDATE:

    I don't have the energy to explain too deep, but after about 20 phone calls, and literally spending the entire day on the phone, we have a pending CONVENTIONAL mortgage with USAA for just about the same interest rate as Bank of America (who was giving us all the shiz. And for the record, USAA thinks it's ridiculous too they want me to have more debt to give me debt). They are fed-ex'ing a packet to us to sign and return. We're now looking at a closing date of April 5 (hopefully the sellers are OK with that). I can't imagine a way this could fall through.... so fingers crossed as i'm sure there is always a possibility.... 

    For now i'll leave it at that. I have so much I could say but I'm waiting until papers are signed for the chain of events that made this possible.  I'm beyond mentally and physically exhausted. Ugh.... But again, So thankful for USAA. I don't know how they can keep topping their self... but they manage to continually do so.

     

     
    25.
    Member
    2,440 posts
    Buzzing bee
    MissHelen    November 20, 2010   California

    Thank goodness!

     
    26.
    Member
    2,074 posts
    Buzzing bee
    Ms.Teddy    April 2011   South Carolina

    USAA is the best. Just have to put that out there. When Teddy and I get married we will be transferring ALL of our banking needs over to them. You definately made a GREAT choice with going with them. So this may have happened as a blessing in disguise...for you to switch over to them instead of Bank of America.

     
    27.
    Member Icon
    Member
    294 posts
    Helper bee
    oakster    June 26, 2010   SF East Bay

    Agreed. You'll be happy in the long run not to have Bank of America own your mortgage---we had them briefly (they bought out the bank that held our loan) and were not excited about that at all. We refi'ed with a local credit union that sells to Fannie Mae, so now the feds own us instead, but they're much more pleasant to work with. :)

     
    28.
    Member
    191 posts
    Blushing bee
    jamie80218    7/10/10   Denver, CO

    All I have to say is Bank of America Sucks!!! You are very lucky you are with USAA instead of BOA! 

     
    29.
    9,010 posts
    Buzzing
    Beekeeper
    MrsSl82be    October 24, 2009  

    Mortgage insurance and PMI are totally different things. PMI is what you pay when you finance less than 20%, once you have 20 equity in the house you no longer pay PMI

     
    30.
    Member
    4,199 posts
    Honey bee
    KLP2010    October 30, 2010  

    Ms.Teddy - They truly are the BEST! I already have my car insurance, renters (and pending homeowners) insurance, credit card, and life insurance with them. Now we'll have the mortgage with them and I'm so happy. We were given the old brokers name and it wasn't until we were pre-approved I knew it was with Bank of America. I've NEVER liked that bank (I've had other bad experiences) and I have heard nightmares about buying and selling using them... I am indeed glad USAA stepped in to save the day.

    I'm honestly just completely emotionally and mentally exhausted still. It's SO ridiculous. I just want it all to be done with.

     
    31.
    Hostess
    16,857 posts
    Honey
    Beekeeper
    MissAsB    June 6, 2009   Married in CO, Living in AL

    I'm so glad you got it worked out!  USAA is the greatest!  We will have to consider them for our next mortgage.  Our current one is with Bank of America (but we got it with Countrywide who was bought by Bank of America).  Haven't seen any issues with them really but we haven't had interaction with them since the loan changed.

     
    32.
    Member
    1,365 posts
    Bumble bee
    Vitsippa    October 10, 2010  

    What a ride! I'm so glad it worked out! I remember your old posts about how the house has everything you wanted with just a little work. I can't wait to see your renovations! Will you still be set to move-in in early April? Time will fly by and next thing you know, you'll be relaxing in your beautiful new home!

    Congratulations again!

     
    33.
    Member
    4,510 posts
    Honey bee
    OttawaBride2011    May 21, 2011   Ottawa, Ontario

    I am so glad it worked out!!! Yay! Congrats :) Hopefully you'll get the closing date you want!

     
    34.
    Hostess
    2,787 posts
    Sugar bee
    missjyc    September 18, 2010   macomb, michigan

    if your house is FHA approved, i say go with a FHA loan... you won't have to pay PMI insurance if you put more than 20% down!

    but with the down payment... either do the minimum 3% down or the 20% to avoid the additional insurance.

    anything in between that is worthless! you should keep the cash in your pocket instead of into your house when it makes LITTLE difference in your actual monthly payment!

     

    (we got our house with an FHA loan)

     
    35.
    Member
    4,199 posts
    Honey bee
    KLP2010    October 30, 2010  

    For us, FHA is not better. We've analyzed them both and we're getting a much better deal on the conventional... which we have now.

    Can't wait for April 5th.... 

     
    36.
    Member
    4,510 posts
    Honey bee
    OttawaBride2011    May 21, 2011   Ottawa, Ontario

    Are you planning on fixing it up before you move in? If so, what's your move-in date? There is no point to this question, I'm just curious :)

     
    37.
    Member
    5,184 posts
    Bee Keeper
    2PeasinaPod       Philadelphia

    Oh good...Keep us updated and hope everything goes through ok! It's absolutely ridiculous that they wouldn't give you the conventional loan with BOA b/c you don't have enough debt. Good luck and congrats!!!

     
    38.
    Hostess
    3,884 posts
    Honey bee
    caszos    June 2010   Florida

    KLP - That is wonderful news to hear.  I know you are so exhausted but it really will make the house so much more worth while!  Maybe start thinking about the awesome housewarming party you can have!

     
    39.
    Member
    4,199 posts
    Honey bee
    KLP2010    October 30, 2010  

    If this does all indeed happen, my mom's going to come visit for a bit! That's pretty exciting, because then I can take her to the store and she can finally see the dress I got in person! She wasn't a huge fan of it, so hopefully that will help... but we're already phone confencing colors and such. She's a great interior designer, and I still think she should get paid for it. Unfortunately, a lot has to be done before she gets here :-( 

    But, yay for mom trips to visit!

     
    40.
    Member Icon
    Member
    372 posts
    Helper bee
    historienne       SF/Mendocino

    Awesome!  I love USAA also - using them just makes me constantly disgusted by all other banks, though, including BoA where we also have an account.

     

    Reply »

    You must log in to post.





    Visit our sister sites eHarmony
    Online Dating
    eHarmony Advice
    Dating Advice
    Project Wedding
    Wedding Songs
    JustMommies
    Pregnancy Calendar
    Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
     

    Find your vendors on Weddingbee

    Real reviews from brides in your area!

    Favors by Weddingbee

    • Favors by season

    Shop Now ยป

    Find Registry Find Registry Find Registry

    More
    User Posts Today
    MissBoPeep 94
    ndreighton 64
    hisgoosiegirl 56
    beargoose 55
    Mrs.KMM 46
    akp0702 42
    BetterSherm 42
    MrsBlueSeptember 38
    MrsPom 37
    Beckster329 37

    Home

    User Posts Today
    TheJeanses2012 4
    ladyartichoke 2
    MissBoPeep 1
    becauseilovehim 1
    burris4 1
    Mrs. Chai 1
    AB Bride 1
    bluewolverine 1
    Mrs. Mustang 1
    MrsPom 1
    More