Post # 1
Hi there! I am torn between two rings and keep going back and forth on the matter. I really love both. My boyfriend favors one over the other. I dont want to make the wrong descision and regret it after I get the ring. I have until may to decide. Help me choose please! Any opinions or comments on the rings concerns, etc may help sway my choice! One I like because its more simple and elegant, the other I like because its unique and antique looking. Thanks SO much!
Post # 3
I voted for the second one- there’s something about the first one that I don’t like, but it’s hard to put my finger on it… the second one is just so beautiful and deliciate looking, I love it…
Post # 3
They’re both so different, but I’d have to say that I love the look of the 2nd one, it’s really very beautiful.
Post # 4
I DEFINITELY like the second one better! I love it!
Not really a fan of the bezel setting, and also not a huge fan on oval diamonds. BUT, the first one is still unique and I love unique! I think it’s about what looks best on your finger. But my personal opinion is that I am obsessed with the second one 🙂
Post # 5
- Wedding: June 2014 - Ontario, Canada ♥ EDD- April 2016
I like the second one best because it’s more detailed and delicate (:
Post # 6
2 looks more like an engagement ring to me
Post # 7
The second is so gorgeous.
Post # 8
I wish the bezel on the first one went all the way around the diamond. I’m voting the 2nd because I think it will be easier to wear a band with.
Post # 9
I love the detail on the 2nd one
Post # 9
I love the second one, its just so dang gorgeous! & Like a PP mentioned, the second will be easier to find a band to go with it. The first looks like you may have to have one made to go with it.
Post # 10
Neither of these is really my style, but out of the two I prefer the second. I feel like the first one looks a little like costume jewelry with the center stone laid into the ring and it being oval. The second is more traditional, and the filigree is pretty and dainty. However, that being said, it’s about what YOU prefer! Have you tried either of these rings on? That makes a huge difference.
Post # 11
iIthink the first one takes away from the diamond. There’s a lot of gold that makes the gold more of the focus than the diamond. The second one is amazing.
Post # 12
Thanks so much everyone! Didn’t expect so many replies so fast! I very much so appriciate it! It looks like its unanimous so far. The oval one does have the bezel going all the way around the diamond, the picture just has a reflection. I love the antique one a bit more and its the one I found first and it makes my heart beat fast, but the oval (first) one grew on me and its the one Nick likes better. It looks more traditional to him. I havent tried them on and wont be able to seeing as we are buying them online. I have been to tons of shops and am just so picky that I couldnt find anything in person that I liked enough. These were the two I liked best.
I think you guys helped push me in the right direction, the one my heart was leaning towards! <3
Post # 13
I’ll be the difficult one. I prefer the first ring.
Post # 14
The first one is very similar to my set which was custom made so that is where I voted. Mine has a pronged center stone but the diamonds are all half bezel.