No newer images
more by ladyliath
Wedding Dress Too Fancy?
17 day diet
more in Wellness
Switching BC pills (if it ain't broke, don't fix it?)
Best Place in L.A. for Cathedral Veil?
more in Boards
Playing the waiting game...

Weight Watchers vs. Atkins vs. South Beach Diet vs. MyPlate (Livestrong.com)

posted 1 year ago in Wellness
  • 2 Members Subscribed To Topic
  • poll: Need to lose 10-15 lbs within next four months. Which diet should I follow?
    South Beach Diet : (3 votes)
    15 %
    Atkins Diet : (0 votes)
    Weight Watchers : (14 votes)
    70 %
    MyPlate (Livestrong.com) : (3 votes)
    15 %
  •  
    1.
    Member
    37 posts
    Newbee
    ladyliath    July 16, 2011   Oakland, CA

    Hi Bees!! Need your help!

    I have exactly four months until my wedding day (July 16th, 2011) and I want to lose 10-15 lbs. I have been working out 4-5 days a week but haven't changed my eating habits as well as I should have...what do you think is the best diet for me?

    I went on Atkins about eight years ago and lost a lot of weight but I have heard that is usually typical for the FIRST time you try Atkins. I know South Beach is similar to Atkins but I have never tried it myself.

    A lot of people have reccomended Weight Watchers to me but I really don't want to spend the money for it if I don't have to (already over budget on our wedding and trying to save $$$ like crazy!). My SIL switched from Weight Watchers to the MyPlate calorie counter through Livestrong.com and she had great success on that program (she was also running 3 miles every other day though).

    I am so confused on which diet I should do! I know, in the long term - Weight Watchers and MyPlate are better. BUT I *REALLY* just want to lose that extra 10-15 lbs before the wedding!!!

    Any advice you can provide would be so helpful. Thank you ladies :-)

    (Not sure if you need to know this but I am 5'3 and 162 lbs)

     
    2.
    Member
    867 posts
    Busy bee
    bunnyfoofoo    May 14, 2011   Wilmington, NC

    It's not on your list, but I've been on the hCG diet and have lost 12.5 lbs in the last 13 days. I'm getting married in exactly 2 months, so I needed something FAST!

     
    3.
    Bee Icon
    Bee
    1,136 posts
    Bumble bee
    lox    May 2011   Baltimore

    Honestly? I'm just flat out counting calories using loseit.com. So far I've lost 17.6 pounds since the beginning of the year so I think it's great! And, you know, it's also free. ;)

     
    4.
    Member
    2,350 posts
    Buzzing bee
    heather25       New York

    WW if you want to spend the money.  Nothing has stuck w/ me and granted I've been on this for only 2 weeks but the meetings make me accountable and I have lost 7.2 pounds with tiny tiny effort (and I didn't get to workout much those weeks).

     
    5.
    Member
    2,350 posts
    Buzzing bee
    heather25       New York

    Also, what are your workouts like?  Are you really going hard.  If you are, you should see some difference.  If not, what goes into your mouth is of the utmost importance.  Try really clean, unprocessed eating for a few days to jumpstart.

     
    6.
    Member
    1,225 posts
    Bumble bee
    baletrina    May 27, 2012   Chicago, Illinois

    My friend is on Weight Watchers since January and has lost 17 pounds.  Her wedding is in June.

    I personally love South Beach.  I felt that layer of fat around my ribs just melt away after the first two weeks.  I don't weigh myself, I go by clothing fit.  Plus I feel like South Beach teaches you how to eat responsibly unlike Atkins where when it was popular I would eat a dill pickle slathered with cream cheese and wrapped in bacon as a meal.  It really messed up my metabolism for sure!

     
    7.
    Admin
    3,530 posts
    Sugar bee
    penguin    June 7, 2008   Berkeley, Ca

    I'm with Lox --- working out 4x a week and I use loseit.com (free free free) to track my calories and stick to a specific # for calories a week as well. Down 10 pounds in 6 weeks! DIETING IS ESSENTIAL to losing weight but I hate calling it "dieting" -- I'd call it mindful eating. I eat ANYTHING I want, but I can't indulge anymore and as long as I stick to my numbers, I lose weight. That means if I know I'm having pizza for dinner I eat very mindfully the rest of the day---apples, oatmeal, that kind of stuff. Don't deprive yourself or tell yourself you "can't" have certain things...that's definitely how I fall off the diet wagon quickly!!!

     
    8.
    Member Icon
    Member
    415 posts
    Helper bee
    edb    10/2010   Baltimore, MD

    I really really like the MyFitnessPal app, if you have a smartphone or an iPod touch - but their website is pretty good too.  The app is free, and you don't have to be online to input stuff (I have a touch so it's great for me).  You can lose 10-15lbs in your timeline with diligant calorie counting.  

    I would also hit the local library for diet books - I've tried the Abs Diet and Best Life diet and had decent success with them.  

     
    9.
    2,299 posts
    Buzzing bee
    bluespurrs    August 7, 2009   South-central PA, USA, Earth

    I lost 35 lbs. in less than 6 months with Sparkpeople.com Keep in mind that those 6 months included all the winter holidays!

    No special diet of any kind - just a calorie range and nutritional guidelines.

    I cut my portion size, skip "filler" foods and focus on what I really want to eat. And I exercise every day.  I found out I need real food, special diets are not for me!

     
    10.
    Member
    37 posts
    Newbee
    ladyliath    July 16, 2011   Oakland, CA

    Thank you ladies for all your advice! The more that I read about these programs, the more I feel that a calorie counter like Weight Watchers or Livestrong or Sparkpeople is the best solution in the short term AND long term. Even using the calorie counter for the past two days has really put my diet into perspective. I've heard that losing weight is 80% diet and 20% exercise and I am really starting to believe it!

     
    11.
    Member Icon
    Member
    1,483 posts
    Bumble bee
    EleanorRigby    June 2011  

    I always suggest South Beach.  My FH had great success with it (lost approx 70 pounds and has kept it off for almost 2 years).  Personally, I would hate calories counting... I feel like it would make me think about food even more, and then I'd get even hungrier... but that's just me.

     
    12.
    Member
    37 posts
    Newbee
    ladyliath    July 16, 2011   Oakland, CA

    Just as a follow up - I started using Livestrong.com shortly after this post and I've lost 4 pounds so far!

     
    13.
    Member
    50 posts
    Worker bee
    sarahtisme    May 14, 2011   GTA

    I am currently on WW and have lost 20lbs but I have had huge success with Livestrong in the past. When I first joined way back in 2005 it was called the daily plate but it was basically the same idea just a different format.

    It was my first experience with calorie counting and if you follow it and stick to with it, it does work. I lost 60lbs in a little over a year. Go on the forums, the people there are so wonderful and supportive.

     

    Reply

    You must log in to post.





    Visit our sister sites eHarmony
    Online Dating
    eHarmony Advice
    Dating Advice
    Project Wedding
    Wedding Songs
    JustMommies
    Pregnancy Calendar
    Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
     

    Find your vendors on Weddingbee

    Real reviews from brides in your area!

    Favors by Weddingbee

    • Favors by season

    Shop Now ยป

    Find Registry Find Registry Find Registry

    More
    User Posts Today
    MissBoPeep 93
    beargoose 55
    hisgoosiegirl 51
    ndreighton 51
    Mrs.KMM 46
    BetterSherm 42
    akp0702 41
    Beckster329 37
    stardustintheeyes 36
    MrsPom 36

    Wellness

    User Posts Today
    phillygirl629 3
    andielovesj 2
    NellieBly 2
    Sunfire 2
    anonymousbee62 2
    Janna19 1
    MsBrooklynA 1
    Mrs.KMM 1
    kybride 1
    mckernae 1
    More