Struggling to find music "adventurous" for us
more by SweetRose2011
Bridesmaids but no MOH
Wedding dress - details
more in Dress
show off you organza dresses!
Bridesmaid Hair blowup
more in Boards
How much alcohol????

Which looks more flattering on me. Mom says dress #1 is matronly.

posted 1 year ago in Dress
  • 2 Members Subscribed To Topic
  • poll: Which dress looks most flattering for my figure
    the halter : (116 votes)
    50 %
    the strapless : (116 votes)
    50 %
  •  
    1.
    Member Icon
    Member
    3,017 posts
    Sugar bee
    SweetRose2011    March 9, 2010  

    went in to buy my dress today with my mom. I was very leary she would try to swade me to change it but wanted to involve her. And guess what, she tried to persuade me. I ended up trying on way more dresses than I wanted to, even though I've tried on so many already. Anyways, I still love the first dress I tried on and at a measly $340 it's a perfect price. The one I fell in love with today, however is $300 off so it would be reduced to $700. But that's twice what I first liked.

     I'm very worried about modesty and was liking the first one (the halter) because I could add a modesty panel that would be higher then a strapless dress. On the strapless dress we can add beautiful matching sleeves but I'm so frustrated because it's a gorgeous dress but the line only ends right above my chest and still adds the lovely "arm fat". My mom used such words for my first dress like "matronly" and that it made me chubby. (I'm pretty sure she's not ok with me being a size 10 even though I'm only 125 and 5'4"

    So here's the pictures:

     

    Which looks more flattering on me. Mom says dress #1 is matronly. :  wedding Wedding Fun With Friends 083Which looks more flattering on me. Mom says dress #1 is matronly. :  wedding Wedding Fun With Friends 084Which looks more flattering on me. Mom says dress #1 is matronly. :  wedding Wedding Fun With Friends 085Which looks more flattering on me. Mom says dress #1 is matronly. :  wedding Wedding Fun With Friends 101Which looks more flattering on me. Mom says dress #1 is matronly. :  wedding Wedding Fun With Friends 103

     
    2.
    2,566 posts
    Sugar bee
    Statutory Grape    March 2014  

    I love the first one on you. Makes your waist look super-tiny! You're not chubby--ignore your mom's negativity and go with the one you love.

     
    3.
    Member
    8,542 posts
    Bumble
    Beekeeper
    noritake22    March 31, 2011   Seattle

    I am probably around the same age as your mom. I don't think either one of them make you look matronly, but the second one does give off a younger feel and seems more princessy. The other one is more grown up.

     
    4.
    Member Icon
    Member
    3,017 posts
    Sugar bee
    SweetRose2011    March 9, 2010  

    Thank you so much! It's just been so hard to find a dress and then I go in today and she tries to change my mind. I like the fact the second one has such a big skirt but I'm worried that it's going to be too heavy after a while.

     
    5.
    Member
    1,312 posts
    Bumble bee
    baldor1    May 7, 2012   Southern California

    Honestly, the 2nd dress is not my style. I don't like the sleeves. I prefer dress # 1. I actually think, dress # 2 looks more "matronly."

    And by Size 10, do you mean regular clothes size or bridal dress size? Either way, you are in no way fat. I'd be hard-pressed to find the arm fat you are referring to.

     
    6.
    Member
    708 posts
    Busy bee
    Corykru    September 17, 2011   Pittsburgh, PA

    I love love LOVE dress two.....I want it lol.

     
    7.
    Member Icon
    Member
    3,017 posts
    Sugar bee
    SweetRose2011    March 9, 2010  

    @baldor1: Size ten in "some" of the dresses I was trying on today. Some jeans I can wear sixes in and some in eights. But my mom was all losing her cool about the number I think today.

     
    8.
    2,566 posts
    Sugar bee
    Statutory Grape    March 2014  

    @SweetRose2011: My mother's the same way. I had to buy the 12-14-16 in the pattern I'm using and she blew the frig up, lol.

     
    9.
    Member
    6,816 posts
    Busy
    Beekeeper
    moderndaisy    June 2010  

    Okay, first of all you are not chubby! And I love your style, you love you some sparkle just like me! :) Both dresses are so much fun, like you are a ballerina, but I like the first one better for your body, it really flatters you.

     
    10.
    Member
    1,312 posts
    Bumble bee
    baldor1    May 7, 2012   Southern California

    @SweetRose2011: If you are referring to Bridal sizes then your Mom needs to be informed that Bridal sizes run small by at least two sizes. A bridal size 10 is actually a street size 6.

     
    11.
    Member Icon
    Member
    3,017 posts
    Sugar bee
    SweetRose2011    March 9, 2010  

    @baldor1: She has been informed. She's just ignorant and thinks I'm fat when I don't think I am. I'm a teeny chubsters but I like my chub. It's cute. :)

     
    12.
    Member
    562 posts
    Busy bee
    bridesmomma    June 19, 2010   Northern California

    YOU..chubby???  No way!!  I think dress #1 looks absolutely gorgeous on you!  I wouldn't change the neckline at all either--I think it looks very 'bridal' as is!

     
    13.
    Member Icon
    847 posts
    Busy bee
    Prettyinpink89    January 1991   N/A

    Number 1 for me. I don't think you look chubby at all (far from it actually). Do what makes YOU happy :). Congrats!!!

     
    14.
    Member
    4,577 posts
    Honey bee
    Treasure43    September 18, 2010  

    I LOVE the first one and don't think you look chubby OR matronly! I think you look fabulous!

     
    15.
    Member Icon
    Member
    315 posts
    Helper bee
    jenny8283    May 1, 2011  

    I think the 2nd one is just stunning!

     
    16.
    Member Icon
    Member
    864 posts
    Busy bee
    Angela83    June 2011  

    They're both beautiful, go with the one you love!  

    I feel your pain on the mom thing.  I had a terrible experience with my mom. I'm 5'5" and 120. My mom has implied I am heavy, and always talks about how everyone else in the family has such a "small frame."  Almost every dress I tried on she said was not flattering b/c it looks like I have no waist.  I think my mom is sincerely disappointed that I don't look like the dress models.  It really hurt my feelings.

    Anyway, sorry for the threadjack, but my point is, stick with what YOU like, and don't let her get to you!

     
    17.
    Member
    666 posts
    Busy bee
    artwyopie    October 20, 2012   Northern MN

    i think that they both look lovely. i don't see matron at all. i voted for the 1st one because i really liked the neckline and your waist was super tiny! :)

     
    18.
    Member
    8,947 posts
    Buzzing
    Beekeeper
    bells    June 26, 2011  

    i prefer the second one. and what arm fat are you talking about? you look like you are average/below average weight for your height. so its a shame you think your chubby. put your weight and height in a BMI calculator and see what it tells you about your weight

     
    19.
    Member Icon
    Member
    3,017 posts
    Sugar bee
    SweetRose2011    March 9, 2010  

    @Angela83: No I know what you mean. My mom has always been overly critical like that.

     
    20.
    1,241 posts
    Bumble bee
    CaraMia10    October 10, 2010   Loma Linda, CA

    I think the first is gorgeous on you. You don't look very comfortable in the 2nd (hands in front of your stomach in both pics).

     
    21.
    Member Icon
    Member
    3,017 posts
    Sugar bee
    SweetRose2011    March 9, 2010  

    @bells: Well I definately don't think I look "fat" and I don't feel like I really need to lose any weight for the wedding. I used to be thinner then thin so I've definately come to terms with gaining a few pounds. my FI would probably hate it if I lost them. :)

     
    22.
    Member
    6,034 posts
    Bee Keeper
    jo.lee    September 10, 2011   Indianapolis

    Oh my God, you look so gorgeous in the first one! I can't believe she said that looked matronly! I wonder what that word even means to her?! Go with the dream dress!!!

     
    23.
    Member Icon
    Member
    3,017 posts
    Sugar bee
    SweetRose2011    March 9, 2010  

    @CaraMia10: Yeah sorry about that, I think that it is a common pose for me to put my hands in front of my waist.

     
    24.
    1,484 posts
    Bumble bee
    arenyth    May 14, 2011   planning in CA, wedding in NJ

    I chose the second one, you look super cute with your short hair and the tiara with that princess dress! I love how tiny the first dress makes you look, but I don't dig the halter- it starts to look like a tank top, like a wifebeater.

     
    25.
    Member Icon
    2,541 posts
    Sugar bee
    piglet_625    January 1, 1991  

    I think you look fabulous in both, but I would definitely go for #1, since that's the dress that YOU seem to love most.  It's very, very flattering on you.  I don't think you look chubby in the least!  Your waist is tiny, and it flatters your figure very well without showing too much.  I think if anything #2 is more "matronly".... although, I've never seen a "matronly" woman wear a ball gown haha... :)

    And don't worry about being a 10 at ALL.... in fact, if I am recognizing the David's Bridal background, their dresses run small.  Most, if not all, special occassion dresses do.  Size is irrelevant in the wedding world. :)

     
    26.
    1,241 posts
    Bumble bee
    CaraMia10    October 10, 2010   Loma Linda, CA

    @SweetRose2011: lol, understandable. But you still look much happier in the 1st one :) It's so flattering!

     
    27.
    Member
    1,054 posts
    Bumble bee
    missbiscuit    March 12, 2011   Sonoma County, CA

    Neither are my personal cup of tea, but of the two I prefer #1 on you.  I don't think you'd need a modesty panel though.. it looks beautiful on you as-is!  And no way are you chubby!

     
    28.
    Member Icon
    Member
    3,017 posts
    Sugar bee
    SweetRose2011    March 9, 2010  

    @CaraMia10: Thank you so much! I look happier in it too! :)

     
    29.
    Member Icon
    Member
    446 posts
    Helper bee
    fontgoddess    August 8, 2009   British Columbia, Canada

    I think #1 looks a hundred times better on you, frankly. Your waist looks so tiny! Not "matronly" by any stretch of the imagination. Plus you look happier in it. :-)

     
    30.
    Member Icon
    Member
    157 posts
    Blushing bee
    cherryshake    September 17, 2010   London

    I think your face in the pics says it all. Go with the one you love. You are NOT fat, by the way, and look amazing in either one. You could always 'fluff' up the skirt of the first one with a bigger crinoline...

     
    31.
    Member
    51 posts
    Worker bee
    sweetredthing    October 10, 2010   Oregon

    I'm exactly your size: 5'4" and 125 lbs and I was a size 8 or 10 in all the wedding gowns I tried on. Bridal sizing is rather odd; I wouldn't think anything of it. *shrug*

    And for what it's worth, while I think both dresses are very pretty, you should go with what you are most comfortable in...ie, what you can happily boogey in all night long. :)

     
    32.
    Member
    2,267 posts
    Buzzing bee
    veganglam    January 5, 2013   Philadelphia; Wedding in NYC

    Chubby!  Your mama is nuts, no offense.  Your waist looks soooo tiny in the first dress.  I really don't care for those sleeves on the second dress--they look really prissy to me.  I think the first one is much more flattering and interesting overall, and definitely not matronly!  I didn't realize a halter top was particularly matronly!

     
    33.
    Member
    5,381 posts
    Bee Keeper
    pinkshoes    July 2011   MA

    They both look nice but I actually like the second one more, but its a little hard to tell since you have your arm across you in the picture.  It makes it seem like you were a bit more self conscious in it. 

    That odd, I'm about the same height and weight, but all the 10s I tried on at running of the bridge were huge.

     
    34.
    Member
    33 posts
    Newbee
    06anchored08    August 11, 2011   Chicago, IL

    If your chubby then I am afraid to know what I am! Don't worry about sizing in gowns- its not the "industry" standard sizing. Go with what you feel a million bucks in! What you feel radiates outward! 

     
    35.
    Member Icon
    Member
    3,017 posts
    Sugar bee
    SweetRose2011    March 9, 2010  

    @pinkshoes: some of the dresses were bigger in the tens and some were smaller. It depended. It was so werid.

     
    36.
    Member
    4,075 posts
    Honey bee
    Amaryllis    July 2, 2011  

    I refuse to believe that you are a size 10! That's what I wear at DB, and my waist is NOT that tiny. :P

    Both look great on you, and I don't think the first one is matronly at all! Go with what you love.

     
    37.
    Member Icon
    Member
    3,017 posts
    Sugar bee
    SweetRose2011    March 9, 2010  

    @Amaryllis: Super serious! The first picture of the halter is actually an 8 until I told her I couldn't breath and then I tried the 10 on which is the second halter.

    Weird huh?

     
    38.
    2,299 posts
    Buzzing bee
    bluespurrs    August 7, 2009   South-central PA, USA, Earth

    Go with the one you love! Both dresses look good on you and no, the halter dress does NOT make you look matronly or chubby! I like the halter dress on you the best and it's less money so that would be the one I would pick!

     
    39.
    Member Icon
    Member
    286 posts
    Helper bee
    Ei    September 10, 2011  

    they are both pretty, but the 1st is more figure flattering and you seem more comfortable...go with whatever one YOU like best and feel bridal in!

     
    40.
    Member
    318 posts
    Helper bee
    Ms. MoxieMonkey       Los Angeles

    First of all, you are NOT CHUBBY.  Not even a little!

    I personally like dress #2 better, but it's clear that you like #1 more, just from the pictures.  And you look great in both!

    GO with #1!!!

     

     

    Reply »

    You must log in to post.





    Visit our sister sites eHarmony
    Online Dating
    eHarmony Advice
    Dating Advice
    Project Wedding
    Wedding Songs
    JustMommies
    Pregnancy Calendar
    Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
     

    Find your vendors on Weddingbee

    Real reviews from brides in your area!

    Favors by Weddingbee

    • Favors by season

    Shop Now ยป

    Find Registry Find Registry Find Registry

    More
    User Posts Today
    rachgirl82 39
    pengoala 33
    MissBoPeep 23
    Future Army Wife 17
    Beckster329 17
    couawilou 15
    Sunfire 15
    KatNYC2011 13
    beargoose 13
    kate02121 12

    Dress

    User Posts Today
    pengoala 12
    Indecisivebride2012 10
    louiseW 8
    rachgirl82 7
    Lyndzo 6
    Petite_Fraise 5
    ozpeony 4
    dressamore 4
    peachacid 4
    Beckster329 3
    More