Centerpiece Help!!!
more by joymarie83
Help, I have to get my order in soon!!!
What is your favorite party food? Will you share a recipe?
more in Food
Help, I have to get my order in soon!!!
Ceremony dispute with In-laws..HELP!!!!!
more in Boards
*10/22/11 Recap-Bridal Party Pics...all of us*

Which matches better?!?!

posted 3 months ago in Food
  • poll:
    Cake 1 (Original) : (15 votes)
    48 %
    Cake 2 (New) : (16 votes)
    52 %
  •  
    1.
    Member
    583 posts
    Busy bee
    joymarie83    June 2, 2012   Milwaukee,WI

    I have yet to decide on a cake, and I plan on going in for cake tasting within a few weeks. The main reason I have yet to go in is because I can't decide on what cake looks best with my theme. My colors are black, white and hot pink with a touch a madison damask.

     

    Should I stick to the original or new one????

     

     

    I recently found this cake and I am in love with it! The cake would be white, damask in black and bling in silver. The only thing that is leading me away from this cake is if I keep the diamond pattern the full cake has to be fondant (so there isnt a difference) but I hear fondant isn't the best tasting. Do you think it will look to plain on top if I left it plain but added hotpink ribbon to bottoms instead of the frosting?

    Which matches better?!?! :  wedding cake damask Cake 1 Help, I have to get my order in soon!!! :  wedding Cake 1

     

    This was my origianl cake, which matches but is so plain looking to me.

    Which matches better?!?! :  wedding cake damask Cake 2 Help, I have to get my order in soon!!! :  wedding Cake 2

     

    Here are a few of the items I have to give you ladies a better picture of my theme

     

    Which matches better?!?! :  wedding cake damask Favors

    Which matches better?!?! :  wedding cake damask Matching3

     
    2.
    Member
    2,876 posts
    Sugar bee
    atalante    May 19, 2012  

    I think the issue with the taste of fondant has a lot to do with the type of fondant used... but usually there's buttercream beneath, so people can always peel back the fondant and still get cake and icing.

    That having been said... it is more expensive, usually.

    What about doing a swiss dot pattern instead of the diamonds? Like this --> http://www.whippedbakeshop.com/sites/default/files/imagecache/product_zoom/swiss-dot-wedding-cake-main.jpg

    I like the idea of putting in the hot pink ribbon.

     
    3.
    Member Icon
    Member
    1,747 posts
    Bumble bee
    les105    May 6, 2012  

    I think it will look nice. I agree with the PP; there should be buttercream underneath of the fondant, so people can (and will) just peel it off.

     
    4.
    Member
    80 posts
    Worker bee
    cellokitty    August 2, 2013   florida

    Ditto everything atalante said. I love the cake!

     
    5.
    Member Icon
    Member
    134 posts
    Blushing bee
    beccybaby    March 5, 2013   NSW

    Don't worry about the taste of the fondant.

    Yes it is gross, but older rellies usually love it because it is "traditional", and younger people will just peel it off and eat the cake inside of it. Fondant is a kind of solid icing, so it will peel off people's pieces if they don't want to eat it.

     

     
    6.
    Member
    1,184 posts
    Bumble bee
    MissTX    May 17, 2013   Texas

    I really like your cake but the first cake, I like it a lot better aesthetically. I say you cant go wrong with either cake :)

     
    7.
    Member
    2,392 posts
    Buzzing bee
    sugarpea    June 14, 2014   Ontario, Canada

    I think the first cake is really pretty (: and I know a lot of people who don't like fondant but the fondant I've had was actually pretty good so I think it depends on who is making it. Plus it's really easy to peel off as others have said (:

     
    8.
    Member
    2,268 posts
    Buzzing bee
    brenda.m.fields    March 3, 2012   Fort Lauderdale (wedding) & Gainesville (home)

    Your poll is really confusing because I think it is in the opposite order of the photos in your post.

    Go for the fondant as long as it is in your budget and get buttercream underneath.

     
    9.
    Member
    94 posts
    Worker bee
    curse10kaia    June 22, 2013   Wisconsin

    Just fyi I think I voted for the wrong cake because you posted "cake 1" & 'cake 2" but in the opposite order of the pictures, then I saw the cakes.  Careful when looking at your poll results 'cause I don't think I'm the only one!  lol  I was going to vote for the cake in the first picture until I read it was fondant.  That stuff is AWFUL and as a guest it would be more important to me that a cake tastes good than that it looks pretty.  Both cakes are gorgeous too, so I would vote for whichever one you could get without fondant.  Hope that makes sense?  Good luck!!!

     
    10.
    Member
    156 posts
    Blushing bee
    Bernadette_love    September 15, 2012  

    The first one gets my vote, I love it! But I'm afraid I also voted the wrong cake. Sigh...

     
    11.
    Member Icon
    Member
    401 posts
    Helper bee
    Bride7844    June 23, 2012   Perth Australia

    The first cake for sure! I too didn't want fondant as I wanted buttercream, but even though we are getting married in winter we were told buttercream very rarely lasts. They can also do much less with buttercream decoration wise.

    So I very reluctantly tried the fondent and I liked it. I just asked them to put it on as thin as they can instead of 4 or so cm thick!

     

    Reply

    You must log in to post.

    Tags:





    Visit our sister sites eHarmony
    Online Dating
    eHarmony Advice
    Dating Advice
    Project Wedding
    Wedding Songs
    JustMommies
    Pregnancy Calendar
    Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
     

    Find your vendors on Weddingbee

    Real reviews from brides in your area!

    Favors by Weddingbee

    • Favors by season

    Shop Now ยป

    Find Registry Find Registry Find Registry

    More
    User Posts Today
    rachgirl82 39
    pengoala 33
    MissBoPeep 23
    Future Army Wife 17
    Beckster329 17
    couawilou 15
    Sunfire 15
    KatNYC2011 13
    beargoose 13
    kate02121 12

    Food

    User Posts Today
    KatNYC2011 1
    Storm0075 1
    Jamcnair 1
    karleyrap12 1
    DEBeachGirl 1
    More