Post # 1
Hi Bees! First time poster here. I’m ordering a new e-ring and wedding band from an online jeweler and they’ve sent me a picture of my ring plus two different styles of wedding band, but I can’t tell which one looks better.
The first is a thinner band which I originally thought I wanted, but I’m not sure if it’s too small next to the 2 carat e-ring? Plus the stones go all of the way around the band and I’m not sure how that will affect general wear and tear.
The second band is a lot bigger and the stones only go half way around the ring, but it’s thicker than the band on the e-ring and I’m not sure if it looks better or worse than the thinner band. Opinions please?
This topic was modified 2 years, 10 months ago by CarlyPalmer.
Post # 2
The second one looks way better. It matches your ering more than the first one. I vote the second band!
Post # 3
I love both! However, I’m not a fan of stones going all the way around the band, or of thin bands so I would personally go with the thicker band. But whatever you love (:
Post # 4
Beautiful e-ring! I think the first band is too thin, but perhaps there is there something in between the two? I think the 2nd band overpowers your e-ring a little ..
Post # 5
CarlyPalmer: I really like the first band! But, I’m also partial to wearing thin bands. I would be worried about having the diamonds all the way around too. Can you get the thinner band with diamonds on half? That would be a winner for me. I think it compliments the e-ring well without competing with it. Beautiful! 🙂
Post # 6
I think the thicker 12 stone band competes with your ering a bit. I love dainty, feminine bands so I vote for the first one. I would also see if they could perhaps do that ring in a half-eternity style because I don’t think I would personally want the stones to go all the way around the ring. Both rings are beautiful, but band #1 definitely gets my vote.
Post # 7
I was really hoping that one ring would be favoured over the other then I would know which I wanted more if I was happy or disappointed, but nope, I love them both. I think I’m going to ask if they have anything inbetween the two, or if the thin band can be made in a half-eternity style. I would rather have a smaller band and be able to add others to create a stack in the future than be constantly worrying that my band is too thick and overpowering, thanks everyone! 🙂
Post # 8
- Wedding: June 2017 - Country Cottage and Gardens
I personally would go to a jeweler and get one that is the same width as the e-ring. I like the thinner band out of the two that you posted but I think it looks the best when they match.
Post # 9
CarlyPalmer: I prefer the thicker band, and I also think that a half eternity is much more practical than a full eternity (wear and also re-sizing). But I second what PPs said about seeing if they have something in-between as I do think that the second band runs the risk of overshadowing your e-ring; something a little thinner would be better IMPO.
Post # 10
Between the two I prefer the Second. But is there no band that’s a happy medium between the two sizes?
Post # 12
i like the second. i think i’m partial as mine looks very similar
Post # 13
Love the second! I really like the look of the thicker band.
Post # 14
I’m not sure how to tag people in comments yet, but I was hoping to get both bands from the same seller and there’s no band that is the same size as the band on the e-ring.
lilsweetie, your ring looks fab 🙂 What size is your ring? I guess I’m worried about the thick band being too overpowering because I have short fingers.
Post # 15
Just an update, I found a plain band they have that matches my e-ring perfectly so I think I’m going to buy it as my official wedding band, then maybe get the thin eternity band and wear them together to start a stack.