So I am sad to say that the New Zealand Mountain-Top Elopement is out.
more by FutureMrsHoneybee
Giving my fiance a *surprise* wedding on a MOUNTAINTOP in NZ! Am I crazy?!
Husband's friend insists on bringing wife to Boys' Weekend -- Opinions Please!
more in Newlyweds
I wish my facebook friends would stop following me on pinterest...
For all you harry potter fans
more in Boards
Things your FI does that make you go "mmm...now that's a man..."

Would you rather have had your dream wedding or your dream honeymoon?

posted 3 months ago in Newlyweds
  •  
    1.
    Member
    225 posts
    Helper bee
    FutureMrsHoneybee    August 2012   Costa Rican Rainforest Elopement

    Looking back with what you know now, would you choose to have your dream wedding or your dream honeymoon if you had to choose one?

    Here's my situation. My fiance can either have our dream wedding (we're eloping) or our dream honeymoon. We don't get to have both.

    Here's our options:

    Option 1) Get married in our dream location, on a mountaintop in New Zealand. We could stay there for four days (no, we can't make it longer). The flights would also be long (13 hours). It would be a whirlwind experience with some memories that we wouldn't be able to have again.

    Here is where I would want the ceremony to be in NZ: http://www.theweddingcompany.co.nz/aoraki-mt-cook-weddings-new-zealand.html

    Option 2) Have a honeymoon in Europe for one week (we'd probably elope in our local forest beforehand). We would make numerous memories together while we have that newlywed giddiness for each other.

    I think both adventures would give us unforgettable memories. I go back and forth on this because on one hand, you only get married once, so do it the way you want. But, at the same token, we will only have that just married feeling once, so I'd like to spend more time being alone in another country and having that feeling together.

    I am assuming that since you guys are married you have a better insight to what matters most. Can you let me in on your wisdom please? :) Which would you choose? (FI isn't sure what he wants to do either).

     
    2.
    Member
    1,862 posts
    Buzzing bee
    Ree723    July 9, 2011   Australia

    NZ is amazing and I can say with full certainty that it is far and away the most beautiful country I have ever been to (and that's saying A LOT)!   However, with that being said, there's really no point to going to NZ for only 4 days.  It's a very long journey and it is an unbelievable country - I think you will seriously regret not having more time there and it may taint your whole wedding experience.   If you can't afford to go for a longer time now, I would shelve New Zealand and save up for a time when you can do it properly.

    A week in Europe would probably be a better option - you get to spend more time together and will actually have a bit of time to appreciate your time together.   

    For me personally, before I'd even read your post, my initial reaction was HONEYMOON!  The wedding day goes by so quickly but to spend some quality time with your new husband, soaking in everything that's just happened is such a worthwhile endeavour.

    Like I said, New Zealand is amazing but to do that long of a trip for such a short time would be incredibly draining and I really think you would be quite sad about having to leave so soon and not being able to explore more of the country.  It's just not practical for a long weekend IMO.  

     
    3.
    Member
    198 posts
    Blushing bee
    Jinxstar      

    I agree with Ree723.  New Zealand for four days will leave you disappointed.  You'll spend too much of the time exhausted from travel and have too little time to really feel like you are there and experiencing how beautiful it is.  Pick one or two places in Europe if you are going for a week and you'll get a much better feeling of having "been there" and made memories.

     

     
    4.
    Member
    1,544 posts
    Bumble bee
    auggiefrog    August 25, 2012   Wauwatosa, WI

    I would do Europe! 

     
    5.
    Member
    225 posts
    Helper bee
    FutureMrsHoneybee    August 2012   Costa Rican Rainforest Elopement

    @Ree723: I diagree that spending four days in NZ would taint my wedding experience (my wedding is one day- why would spending four days in NZ have anything to do with it?). If we went to NZ it would be for the wedding experience, not seeing the country. If we went to NZ we'd go back on our one year anniversary to properly see the place.

    We'd spend the four days relaxing in NZ, it's not like we'd be trying to see the country AND have our wedding. We'd maybe go to a spa and go on a horseback ride, but we definitely wouldn't be trying to do both. That would be too exhausting.

     
    6.
    Member
    5,969 posts
    Bee Keeper
    AmeliaBedelia    March 3, 2012   Georgia

    If I'm just answering the basic question: I'd rather have the honeymoon!

    Also, I agree with PPs about NZ. That's more than a 4-day trip, IMO. I'd rather do Europe and get to see more.

     
    7.
    Member
    51 posts
    Worker bee
    Iluvmydog    June 30, 2017  

    Basing this only on how you responded to other people's opinions, i think you've already made your decision on what you think will have the most meaning. 

     
    8.
    Member
    225 posts
    Helper bee
    FutureMrsHoneybee    August 2012   Costa Rican Rainforest Elopement

    @Jinxstar, auggiefrog, AmeliaBedelia: Thank you for letting me know what you would choose!

    @Iluvmydog: I haven't made my decision yet, I just wanted people to know that if we went to NZ we wouldn't be trying to experience the country there and have a wedding in four days because I think that would be too much. We'd just relax and take in the scenery (and maybe do an activity or two).

     
    9.
    Member
    3,623 posts
    Sugar bee
    rachgirl82    December 15, 2011   FL

    Honeymoon!

     
    10.
    Member
    1,862 posts
    Buzzing bee
    Ree723    July 9, 2011   Australia

    @FutureMrsHoneybee:    I only meant that you lose two days getting there (you leave on a Wednesday, arrive on Friday etc).  Then you're jet lagged.  You run off and get married, spend a day or two relaxing and then jump back on a plane for 14 hours and have massive jet lag to overcome.  It would be completely and utterly exhausting.  It sounds like you have a romanticized notion of a NZ wedding right now and I would hate for your dreams to be dashed because you didn't have a realistic expectation of what it was like.  

    If you just want to go for the wedding and to relax at a spa for a couple of nights, there are a LOT of other places where you could do that much easier and for a cheaper price.... especially as you said you're considering going back to NZ for your anniversary.

    I've been to Mt Cook where you want to get married and it is truly gorgeous, but it's not easy to get to from Christchurch (assuming that's where you'd fly in as that's the nearest international airport), so factor in additional travel times and costs to get to Mt Cook.  It is a beautiful mountain village - but you could get a very similar experience in the Rockies, or British Columbia, Canada.  You don't need to fly halfway across the world for a couple of days to get married on a mountain that looks very similar to lots of other beautiful mountain towns (no offense to the Kiwis out there!), especially as you only want to spend a couple of nights in a spa and going on some horseback rides whilst there.  You could have that experience anywhere.... it just doesn't make sense to me to fly all that way and not take the time to see the country, especially when it's a country with as many amazing sites as NZ.  

    [deleted]

    ETA: I deleted the last part of my post as I don't want to put a negative spin on whatever you decide to do.   Good luck whichever you decide!

     
    11.
    Member Icon
    Member
    1 posts
    Wannabee
    sadiefrost    May 2015  

    Honeymoon! Both for my own personal answer and as an answer to your question. If you're from the States, you are going to be so so jet-lagged and exhausted to fully experience your wedding day. It does look beautiful though...maybe a 5 or 10 year renewal ceremony? :) 

     
    12.
    Member
    2,576 posts
    Sugar bee
    Wonderstruck    September 18, 2011   Detroit, MI

    I'm surprised so many people said your honeymoon...I'm the completely opposite! You will have other vacations, but this is your one and only wedding! I'd rather put the money into that and make your next vacation a super nice one =)

     
    12.
    Member
    225 posts
    Helper bee
    FutureMrsHoneybee    August 2012   Costa Rican Rainforest Elopement

    @Ree723: That gave me some things to think about. Thank you.

     
    13.
    Member
    225 posts
    Helper bee
    FutureMrsHoneybee    August 2012   Costa Rican Rainforest Elopement

    @sadiefrost: Thanks! I don't think a vow renewal would be the same (feeling-wise). It would still be nice and romantic though!

    @courtney1188: That's how I feel about it sometimes too. I mean, you only get to get married to him ONCE. You will hopefully get to take more vacations as a married couple. That's what's bothering me.. I don't want to have an exhausting wedding experience, but at the same time, if I don't do it, then we will never get to have the memories of getting married on a mountaintop together. I'm feeling so confused. :(

     
    14.
    Member
    2,576 posts
    Sugar bee
    Wonderstruck    September 18, 2011   Detroit, MI

    @FutureMrsHoneybee:   What about having a mountaintop wedding in Erupe followed by your honeymoon, since you'd already be there? Is that an option?

     
    15.
    Member
    2,242 posts
    Buzzing bee
    Brielle    May 22, 2009  

    @Wonderstruck:  I agree. 

    OP, You only get married once, whereas you will have many opportunities for a vacation anywhere in the world. I would make your marriage experience what you really want it to be.  There will be opportunities for you to go to Europe in the future, but, if the wedding of your dreams is in NZ, then I think you should have what you really want.

    I'll say something to you that I always say to brides who are torn between two wedding gowns:  Clearly, you like both of these options very much, so you could live WITH either one of these choices. What REALLY matters is, however, is which choice will you be truly upset to have to live WITHOUT?  Which experience, if you do NOT choose it, will drive you crazy and "haunt" you that you didn't go for it? Once you answer that question, you'll have your answer as to what you should do! :)

     
    16.
    Member
    225 posts
    Helper bee
    FutureMrsHoneybee    August 2012   Costa Rican Rainforest Elopement

    @courtney1188: I still haven't found any mountain-top wedding options that I like in Europe. :( That would be an option if only I could find a company in Europe that performs weddings on mountain-tops. I've seen a couple weddings in Europe that are in the mountains, but none of them are actually on TOP of them the way that I want it to be.

     
    17.
    Member
    1,184 posts
    Bumble bee
    MissTX    May 17, 2013   Texas

    without a doubt in my opinion, the wedding is more important than the honey moon. I would rather have my dream wedding. I feel like ANY destination you travel to with your hunny would be amazzziiinnnng and you could take an amazing honeymoon vacay every year ya know?? You cant have a big dream wedding more than once ;) Realistically. Lol i dont know. My personal thoughts :)

     
    18.
    Member
    225 posts
    Helper bee
    FutureMrsHoneybee    August 2012   Costa Rican Rainforest Elopement

    @Brielle: :) Thank you so much for that. I will make sure to ask myself that in upcoming decisions, lol!

    The wedding does take priority over the honeymoon for me. BUT, if everyone is sitting here telling me that the experience won't be worth it because we'll be too jet lagged to fully enjoy it, I can't argue with that because I've never been on a long flight (neither has FI) so we don't know how we will feel. It's very confusing and disheartening because we've been on four day trips before and we LOVED it, but we didn't have to deal with jet lag so I just don't know what to do. :(

     
    19.
    Member Icon
    Member
    35 posts
    Newbee
    SeaRhapsody      

    Wow I haven't done either yet.  I have however done plenty of long haul flights.  The advice you are getting is correct-- it can be a huge adjustment.  If you've never done it before you won't know how it will affect you. And if it were me and my time period were so limited I wouldn't risk it for my wedding day. 

    Just a few personal examples, I went to Australia and was fine during the trip, but on the return to the east coast, it took me a week to get fully adjusted to be awake during normal hours and if I had to head immediately back to work I wouldn't have made it. My bf and I took a trip to hawaii and  couldn't stay awake past 6 the first half of the trip. (imagine the damper that put on the romance).  That's not to say that you couldn't try to minimize the effects. on my last 24 hour flight to Africa, I took pains while traveling to try to adjust to the times I was headed towards by only sleeping during their night hours, but that meant some times when i was awfully tired and not at my sweetest for my honey. I guess if it were me, I would just want to feel my best on my wedding day and knowing that travel on a tight timeframe might screw that up I wouldn't risk it. 

    I think the Europe trip is certainly more manageable and there are plenty of amazing spots to get married there. If you want to keep the mountain theme, have you considered switzerland? I haven't been there personally but I hear the Black Forest in Germany is amazing. That said, its your wedding so you should do whatever makes the two of you happy. People make short trips around the world all the time. Go for it if that's what will make your wedding day.

     
    20.
    Member
    225 posts
    Helper bee
    FutureMrsHoneybee    August 2012   Costa Rican Rainforest Elopement

    @SeaRhapsody: Your comment was the straw that broke the camel's back if you will, lol. Thank you for helping me.

    We ultimately decided that while we do want to go to Europe, it's not exactly what we want for our honeymoon. (FI still wants it to be a surprise but he mentioned things he would like.) We did a find a place. :)

    If you want to know what we decided, you can read about my decision here: http://boards.weddingbee.com/topic/so-i-am-sad-to-say-that-the-new-zealand-mountain-top-elopement-is-out?replies=3#post-3213912

    Thank you all. Really.

     
    21.
    Member
    2,169 posts
    Buzzing bee
    regberadaisy    August 14, 2010  

    HONEYMOON!!!

    Because ours was freaking awesome. We backpacked for 3 weeks through Europe. It was a dream of ours and we made it happened. Would not have traded it for the world.

    And I say honeymoon vs dream wedding because yes you only get married ONCE. But at the end of the day the result is the same. You are married to your husband. It doesn't matter if you have $300 centerpieces at every table or centerpieces from the dollar tree. It does not matter if you are wearing a cocktail dress from a department store or a Vera Wang. It doesn't matter if your photographer is a student or a 5K photographer. What matters is that you are married.

    But the proper $$$ for an awesome honeymoon can change the experience.

    For us we were lucky enough to have both our "dream" wedding and honeymoon!

     
    22.
    Member
    3,003 posts
    Sugar bee
    vmec    May 12, 2012   Vancouver

    We're doing both but not without sacrifice. We're having a dream wedding (relatively) and we're delaying our dream honeymoon by a few years.

     
    23.
    Member
    3,003 posts
    Sugar bee
    vmec    May 12, 2012   Vancouver

    OK I read more. I have forumalated my opinion I would choose the wedding. You only get one of those, but you can have many trips to wherever should you choose to. The "newlywed" feeling is just that. If you want the lustly love feeling take yourself there mentally. So to me expericeing a trip as "newlyweds" just to feel like newlyweds isn't a reason to me. I'd rather have the best wedding EVER, and make the best trip ever (europe)- later.

     
    24.
    Member
    2,239 posts
    Buzzing bee
    yellowshoe    December 2011   Laguna Beach, CA

    I would do honeymoon!!

    First of all, all the drama that came with our wedding planning was something I could DEFINITELY have done without. A small intimate wedding with just the two of us (and our dog) and maybe our parents (if they're good. ha!) was actually my dream!!  In the end you two will still be married regardless of how much you spend and how many guests you had.

    In my experience, the big wedding production was for the parents' and the honeymoon was what was for us. Which is why I would go with a dream honeymoon all the way! We went on our dream honeymoon and if I had to choose wedding or honeymoon, I wouldn't have given up the honeymoon for anything. 

     

    Reply

    You must log in to post.





    Visit our sister sites eHarmony
    Online Dating
    eHarmony Advice
    Dating Advice
    Project Wedding
    Wedding Songs
    JustMommies
    Pregnancy Calendar
    Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
     

    Find your vendors on Weddingbee

    Real reviews from brides in your area!

    Favors by Weddingbee

    • Favors by season

    Shop Now ยป

    Find Registry Find Registry Find Registry

    More
    User Posts Today
    rachgirl82 39
    pengoala 33
    MissBoPeep 28
    Future Army Wife 20
    Beckster329 19
    couawilou 18
    Sunfire 18
    KatNYC2011 15
    vorpalette 15
    beargoose 14

    Newlyweds

    User Posts Today
    rachgirl82 4
    loveroflove 3
    slicey19 2
    KatNYC2011 2
    hergreenapples 1
    carriejuly 1
    knittylady 1
    SutSip 1
    BoiledPNut 1
    relaxedabout it 1
    More