Post # 1
Member
5985 posts
Bee Keeper
Its our year anniversary next week and I am so excited! BUT…I just realized that the top of our cake is at my moms house which is 6 hours away (we lived only 40 minutes away when we got married and did not have room in our freezer). So no eating the top of our cake on our first wedding anniversary 🙁 Oh well, I hear it tastes like crap anyway LOL
So I am just curious, did anyone eat leftover wedding cake on their anniversary?
Post # 3
Member
5985 posts
Bee Keeper
I just read this…guess it does not make sense for us to eat it anyway
“Saving a part of your wedding cake to eat on your 1 year anniversary is an age old tradition. The tradition originated from the belief that by the time of a couples first wedding anniversary there would be a baby and the couple could serve their wedding cake at the babies christening. This came from an era where the sole purpose of marriage was the procreation of children.
Post # 4
Member
1940 posts
Buzzing bee
We don’t have a baby, thus no christening…. but, we are planning on trying a bite of our cake on our anniversary 🙂
Post # 5
Hostess
18644 posts
Honey Beekeeper
We didn’t eat our cake because we were moving away and it wasn’t worth it to transport it. My husband doesn’t like cake much anyway.
Post # 6
Member
2476 posts
Buzzing bee
We have ours in our freezer and plan to defrost it this weekend! I’ll let you know how it tastes. 
Post # 7
Member
5985 posts
Bee Keeper
@ddubzz: we are ALMOST date twins 🙂 let me know how it goes…
Post # 8
Member
4824 posts
Honey bee
I think my mom might have, but she is across the country. We will eat it probably before our first so is not gross. Nex time we are there.
Post # 9
Member
5655 posts
Bee Keeper
We ended up not keeping ours.. BUT since all we had was a small 1 tier we’re just going to get an exact replica.. it was a whopping 20 bucks so I think we should be able to swing that. lol =)
Post # 10
Member
4038 posts
Honey bee
We didn’t save ours. I’m planning on making cupcakes in one of the flavors we had at the wedding. I’ve always heard that it takes like crap, though, because most people don’t properly prepare it for freezing (and since we didn’t save it, I didn’t read up on what to do to properly store it to avoid tasting like freezer-burned crap). I can’t imagine serving that to guests at a christening, though. That just seems mean, lol.
ETA: Happy Anniversary!
Post # 11
Member
403 posts
Helper bee
We had such a small wedding and wedding cake that the whole thing was consumed at the reception. I’m thinking I might go in to the bakery that made the cake and have a small replica made of the cake topper for our anniversary on Sunday :o)
Post # 12
Member
333 posts
Helper bee
I was under the impression that you could only keep the cake (at least here in the UK) if you had a traditional fruit cake, as the fruit cake keeps its flavour and moisture for much longer than ordinary cake. I cant imagine that a sponge cake would be very nice at all after a year, as it goes stale..
I could very well be wrong though, i’d love to hear if it was tasty!
Post # 13
Member
3526 posts
Sugar bee
We actually had no intention of saving our cake for our one year anniversary but my caterers were sweet enough to set it aside. I was so excited to have it for breakfast the next morning….until I realize I left it in the trunk overnight. In summer.
No leftover cake for me!
Post # 14
Member
2889 posts
Sugar bee
Just like Gerber, our caterers put it aside for us and we had if for breakfast the next day. It made it into our hotel fridge but not in one piece. Someone clearly picked up the box without realizing it was cake and by the time I tracked it down it looked terrible but tasted delicious. I wish we lived near the baker so we could have a recreated cake on our anniversary. I will try to get a local baker to make a similar cake and hope it’s as good.
Post # 15
Member
6572 posts
Bee Keeper
We ate ours. Well we had a bite, and it was so gross we didn’t go any further. But I’m glad we did it, it was good memories!
Is there any place you can get the same kind of cake to eat?
Post # 16
Member
5110 posts
Bee Keeper
I get its tradition and all but were not. Our cake people do a top layer again for free if you call a few days before your anniversary. 🙂
