(Closed) 1st Anniversary Gift Question

posted 12 months ago in Married Life
Post # 2
720 posts
Busy bee

oh boy – you two need to sit down and talk about this. His familial experience is all he has to lean on, and clearly you expect something different (which is totally okay!). 

My ex and I used to follow the “tradition” wedding presents (with 1 year being “paper.”) He wrote me a nice note. I got him a gift certificate to go sky diving. I spent WAY more and and totally different expectations. He never used the gift certificate, and I held onto that sweet note for our entire marriage (and then burned it in anger last month while cleansing my house of bad energy hahaha, but that’s another story). 

The second year, we were both so overwhelmed, I think we just went to dinner. 

After that, we had a talk about our expectations and experiences with gift giving/receiving. We set a dollar limit that was within our budget. We shared the things that were important to us (“creativity,” “sentimentality,” “unique” were things we agreed on). The $$ limit and the guiding principles really helped us with our future purchases. We did the same thing with holiday and birthday presents. It allowed us to not stress about our budget (some years we had more money than others), and it made us do gift giving in a more purposeful way. 

Also – I understand the engagement ring thing. He bought me a small little gemstone because he was a poor 20 year old when he proposed to me. But I FINALLY told him for our 10 year I wanted an upgrade. I set a budget based off what our income was, I picked the ring, and he made the payments. I was happy, he was happy I was happy, and he was able to afford it. Now I’m holding onto it for our daughters. 

The fact of the matter is that he will never know it’s an issue unless you tell him. If you want diamonds, you have to tell him that. If TJMAXX isn’t your style, you have to tell him that. Don’t let anyone make you feel guilty about having those wants and desires (they’ll change with time, too…). 

If I’ve learned anything, it’s that men are 1) creatures of habit (will defer to what their families taught them); 2) not good at picking up on hints; and 3) truly desperate for guidance on what will make us happy. Chances are he will feel relieved if you tell him exactly what you want. 

Post # 3
7806 posts
Bumble Beekeeper

So first of all, I’m not 100% familiar with the differences between tjmaxx and winners (canadian version), but my winners literally has chanel, balenciaga, chloe, hugo boss, etc. You can get some really nice stuff there, so I dont think you need to shit on the entire chain LOL. 

Hasn’t a man ever heard of an anniversary ring? Not all men have. Not all women have either. “Anniversary” rings like what youre asking for are not common where I live. THe only anniversary rings I know of are like 5/10/20 year rings and generally diamond eternities.  

You may need to accept the reality that you’ll need to give your husband a list for “acceptable” gifts for you. 

Post # 4
3647 posts
Sugar bee
  • Wedding: April 2017 - City, State

Just tell him what you want. It’s really not that hard. You are continuously setting him up for failure and yourself up for disappointment by making every gift giving event a mind reading challenge. Just tell him, “I’d like this gift for our anniversary.”

I know, I know. You want to be surprised. You want him to just KNOW exactly what you want. Well, he doesn’t. If you have specific wants you’ll need to specifically express them. He’ll be happy he knows you like the gift and you’ll be happy knowing you’ve got what you really wanted. These gift games just end up frustrating everyone and no one wins.

Post # 5
492 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: July 2014

My husband doesn’t have a great track record with buying jewellery for me independently, what we do now is he gives me a budget and I get to go shopping to find something or more than one something that I really want, normally making a day of it with my friends, he calls them ‘girl trips’.

For anniversary gifts, he surprised me for our first anniversary with a photo album of photos from our honeymoon- playing up to the paper tradition…honestly I can’t remember what I bought him, though I know he kept the card. Since then we’ve mainly done joint things, gone out to concerts or shows together, this year we bought furniture for the house.

I’ve never heard of anniversary rings… except for like 10 or 20 years….

Maybe if you don’t want him to go shopping with his Dad, offer to go shopping together? 

Post # 8
564 posts
Busy bee

View original reply
@springlilies28:  Why are his parents so involved in all of this? Like you said, just because his parents operate one way with gifts doesn’t mean you guys have to. I can also understand being disapointed with the whole TJ Maxx thing… I personally shop there when I’m looking for something cheap since it’s a discount store afterall. However, I don’t know you and your husbands financial situation. Can he only afford to purchase a gift here?

I agree with PP, you should just talk to your husband about this. Let him know you’d prefer his family not be so involved with your spending/picking out gifts, and also when a gift giving occasion comes up just let him know you’d really like XYZ. Assuming its within your guys budget, there shouldn’t be an issue. 

In my experience most guys I’ve dealt with need a little help picking out gifts, and I’d rather my husband spend money on something I love than something that will just sit on my dresser, that’s just a waste of money and would also hurt his feelings.

Talk to him!

Post # 10
3951 posts
Honey bee
  • Wedding: September 2012

I’m lucky that my husband is a great gifter, but he gets that from his parents. His gifts are good, though, because he listens when I say I want/like something and tucks that info back in his head until he’s ready to shop.

I thnk you need to clearly TELL him what your expectations are. How else will he learn what types of gifts you like/want? He learned from his parents and if you don’t give him guidance, how else will he know?

Something that helps my husband and I is setting a price limit. It keeps us within a reasonable budget and reduces the chance of one person spending way more or less than the other.

For anniversary gifts, we usually do the traditional “year” gifts and we go nice/keepsake style. (This year was 8, which is bronze. We actually ended up buying a joint gift because we couldn’t find bronze items the other person would like.)

I’m also with PP – I thought anniv rings were for milestones if people do them at all.

Post # 13
492 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: July 2014

View original reply
@springlilies28:  Its frustrating when they give you random crap, or even jewellery that just isn’t to your taste…even when it comes from a place of love.
Maybe say something like, I really appreciate that you listened when I said I fancied some more jewellery but next time could we go to __________store and pick something out together? 
Or if budget is the issue, say you could add the budget for Valentines, birthday and anniversary to get something really special?
Just because the salary that you have is large enough to have money to splurge, it doesn’t mean that he has a large enough budget in mind when shopping… 
You may have shown him the etsy shop in your mind but you may need to indicate actual stores, lots of people have insecurities about buying jewellery in particular off the internet

The topic ‘1st Anniversary Gift Question’ is closed to new replies.

Find Amazing Vendors