(Closed) A Nightmare MOH!

posted 9 years ago in Bridesmaids
Post # 3
1565 posts
Bumble bee

I am going to be really honest with you. I read your last post earlier today, and it made me think “bridezilla” right away. I know the bees are generally very supportive and tend to give posters the benefit of the doubt. But when you continually talk about “firing” bridesmaids, and mention that you asked your Maid/Matron of Honor to step down just because you found another friend you decided should be Maid/Matron of Honor instead when the original girl did nothing wrong, that is a really self-centered way to think. “Bridesmaid” is not a job and you are not their boss. You can’t expect anything of them except buying the dresses and showing up.

Now I don’t know what your initial email said, but if the tone was such that you expect certain things of them or they have to step down, it sounds like it was out of line. You can’t go ordering these girls around just because it’s your wedding. You can’t expect them to support you through every change of plans. When I changed dates and venues just once, everyone was kidding around about it. If you keep changing your ideas, yes, they may get frustrated. Maybe don’t tell them until you have a final decision. About costs, it’s nice to be upfront if the costs are reasonable. But maybe it’s not so nice to say “pay up or drop out.” I would lower the costs for bridesmaids before kicking them out.

Even if your behavior is out of line, some girls are going to be more flexible and chill about it. Others will feel like you’re overbearing but not say anything. And some. like your Maid/Matron of Honor, will speak out. I don’t know you or them, but it sounds to me like your Maid/Matron of Honor has valid concerns. 

<input id=”gwProxy” type=”hidden” /><input id=”jsProxy” onclick=”jsCall();” type=”hidden” />

Post # 4
14183 posts
Honey Beekeeper
  • Wedding: June 2009

I dont’ think you handled this very well and frankly, I think it’s a good thing your Maid/Matron of Honor called you out on this. I’d be LIVID if somebody wrote me an email like that. I just dont’ think it’s a good way to go. I know as brides we want our friends to be supportive and give us ideas and help us out, but you also have to take the things they say with a grain of salt and you can’t be overly sensitive (which you may have been?) I mean, emailing your friends and telling them they’re not allowed to mock you anymore? As a friend, I wouldn’t have received that very well, either. You already asked one Maid/Matron of Honor to step down and the way your other post was phrased really rubs me the wrong way.

You dug your own grave with this one. There’s no nice way to say it. I think you have to call your friend up and have a chat with her. Even if your other friends are all “on board” now, i doubt they were thrilled with the email.

Post # 5
23 posts
  • Wedding: March 2014

I just read your original thread, and from what you posted there, I don’t think your concerns were unreasonable.  Your Maid/Matron of Honor sounds completely disinterested in the wedding you want, and, to be perfectly honest, she doesn’t seem like a very good friend. 

That said, I agree with GirlWithARing that I’m baffled as to why you “fired” your first Maid/Matron of Honor for this girl.  Your original MOH’s only flaw seems to be the distance, which does make me wonder if you are expecting too much from your BMs.  Without knowing everything that has gone down with your BMs or what you said in your e-mail to them, I am a bit concerned that you are involving these ladies a bit too much.  They don’t need to sign off on every single decision you make (i.e. your changing the venue), and unless something relates directly to your Bridesmaid or Best Man (their dresses, for example), you should just inform them after a decision has been made and that’s it. 

The same thing goes for the dresses–I doubt you really knew what your wedding was going to look like two years ago, and it is unreasonable to ask someone to buy a dress 1 1/2 years in advance.  Now that you’re getting closer and decisions must be made, you need to apologize to your ladies for your prior confusion and say that this is the dress and must be ordered by X date, and then don’t change your mind.

Remember, this is your wedding, not theirs.  Yes, they’re excited for you, but they aren’t excited about every single detail that you make.  They have lives, too, and you need to respect that and keep the things you ask them to do, the time you ask them to devote, and the money you ask them to spend, to a reasonable amount.

Post # 7
1580 posts
Bumble bee

Has your Maid/Matron of Honor ever been a bridesmaid before? Because I think you are right about the dress. If you are ordering a dress, you have to order it 3-6 months before the wedding.

My bridesmaids are my sisters and Future Sister-In-Law, so I am sort of a different situation than you, but my whole family was getting fed up with me when it seemed to them that I was being indecisive, but really, I was just throwing ideas out there and trying to get feedback on them. I think it was just overwhelming for them because they didn’t know when to believe something was really my final decision. Same goes with bridesmaids dresses. They weren’t really interested in emailing back and forth about different styles and designers. They seemed to be happier when I told them what I was going to pick, rather than involving them in the whole process. (The price issue for you is another bucket of worms, so I’d suggest asking each girl what dollar figure she is comfortable with. Or just go the LDB route, which always looks classy.)

I don’t think you’re being bridezilla, but I also don’t think your Maid/Matron of Honor is being insensitive. I think there is a lack of communication about what is expected (I know you were trying to accomplish this with your email). So I’d say reply to her email and tell her you are sorry that it came across contractual, but you wanted everyone to know what you are thinking, and it is up for discussion.

Good luck!

Post # 8
350 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: July 2009

I think you’ve gotten some great advice here, and I’d like to add one more piece: don’t take the websites at face value when you read what bridesmaids and MOHs are supposed to do!  I’ve never met a single bridesmaid or Maid/Matron of Honor who does all of the stuff some websites or books claim are their “duties.”  It might help to dial back your expectations a bit, especially where “listening to wedding ideas/details” is concerned.  Wedding talk can get *really* boring if you’re not the one getting married — yes, even if you’re a bridesmaid!

Also, I think your Maid/Matron of Honor may be upset because you sent out a mass e-mail instead of talking to her personally about her behavior.  She may think that this was your way of embarassing her in front of the other bridesmaids, and not realize you were having some problems with several bridesmaids.

And re: the 6-month dress order.  This applies if you’re getting a dress from a bridal shop, because that’s how long it takes an order to get filled, but not if you’re just asking your bridesmaids to pick out any little black dress from the store, since they can take the LBD home right away.  I wasn’t sure which route you’re going so I thought I should mention that the 6-month timeline isn’t necessary unless you’re going the bridal salon route.

Post # 9
804 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: November 2010

I’d suggest choosing one or two people you feel comfortable bouncing wedding ideas off – but make sure these people are open to it – and they won’t be ALL the time! For me these are my best friend and one of my sisters. I have 4 bridesmaids and I’ve told them all that they can choose their own dress (I have given them a colour) and thankfully they’re all cool with that. I understand how tricky it must be feeling like you’re not being supported by your bridesmaids (especially if you’re really psyched about the wedding and they may not be) but you’ve got to be really choosy about who you talk to about the wedding. I’m really psyched about my wedding and I still get “Urgh MORE wedding talk!” comments from some members of my family – even if I’ve just made one comment! It’s hard cos you feel like you’re not allowed to be excited but I’ve found that if I pick who I talk to about it and pick when carefully then you can have a really great chat and get feedback without anyone getting bored or thinking you’re wedding obsessed! And they won’t be up for these chats ALL the time – you have to gauge how they’re feeling that day.

Also, I thought that your friends response to your email was a bit on the nasty side and I’d be upet about it but I kinda understand where she’s coming from. It’s a tricky situation and I really hope you and your bridesmaids can sort it out and have a brilliant day!

Post # 10
22 posts
  • Wedding: June 2011

I am not sure what your email said or exactly what has transpired between you and your Maid/Matron of Honor, but I think her email is horrible. It just seems really mean spirited and it makes me think she was more than just disinterested in your wedding ideas. If she really felt this way, I would think she could respond nicely that she’s sorry she won’t be able to handle so much and graciously step down. I would say the claws are way out in her email response.

Also, for the Maid/Matron of Honor that you ‘fired’ – that may not have been the best decision, but to your defense of the word ‘fired’ I think that’s kind of thrown around a lot in the wedding blog world. That’s not the first time I’ve heard someone use that.

I do agree with some of the previous girls tho – you can’t talk to everyone all the time about wedding stuff. I know it makes me sad that I can’t talk to my Maid/Matron of Honor about things sometimes and she’s not as excited about it like I would like for her to be, but I realize at the same time that she’s not the one getting married. I think there are other circumstances like some poster mentioned before about people going through relationship problems, divorces, etc. that make it extra hard for them to hear anything about a wedding. Also, I know I get tired with my own indecisiveness over what I want, so I’m sure that can be overkill for anyone else (esp if I’m already over it). Sometimes I just wish the choices for certain things weren’t so hard (factor in costs, locations, guests accesibility, style, etc.). Some decisions, especially with out of town guests, can be really hard to pin down. I just wouldn’t share that with many people.

Best of luck to you in sorting this all out!

Post # 11
6661 posts
Bee Keeper
  • Wedding: May 2010

Her email to you was mean and uncalled for, but you shouldn’t have sent that email out in the first place. AND you shouldn’t be involving them in all the decisions like it sounds as though you are. If you are emailing them and asking for opinions, even though they should only reply with ‘Sounds wonderful, anything you choose!” you are guaranteed to actually get some real opinions and they might not all be supportive.

It also sounds really awful that you already asked a Maid/Matron of Honor to step down. like another poster said, BM’s aren’t employees and shoudn’t ever get fired or demoted unless they are trying to sleep with your Fiance or something awful like that.

I think you should write back to her and say I know you’re kidding, but I am sorry that i’ve been too needy with wedding details. I’ve realized the hard way it’s too much to ask BM’s and I feel bad. But everyone does actually have to order the dress 6 months in advance for them to come in on time. See you at the bach party, lata!

The topic ‘A Nightmare MOH!’ is closed to new replies.

Find Amazing Vendors