(Closed) All-inclusive vs. Independent travel

posted 8 years ago in Travel
  • poll: How do you feel about all inclusive resorts?
    I love them all of the time and I'll tell you why : (6 votes)
    15 %
    I love them most of the time and I'll tell you why : (1 votes)
    3 %
    Meh, they're ok : (7 votes)
    18 %
    I really don't like them and I'll explain why : (6 votes)
    15 %
    Honey! I've never been on one and I want to vote! : (19 votes)
    49 %
  • Post # 3
    2475 posts
    Buzzing bee
    • Wedding: June 2010

    I’ve only been to one all-inclusive and I felt pretty much exactly the same way you did.  I’ve also been on a cruise and didn’t like it for many of the same reasons.  It’s just not for me.

    Post # 4
    5496 posts
    Bee Keeper
    • Wedding: April 2010

    Love them! We’re going to one in St. Thomas for our honeymoon. I love knowing all drinks/food/gratuities are already taken care of. If you are the type that wants to venture off and not stay at the resort much, then it’s definately not for you. We plan on staying at the resort most of the time so for us, it’s perfect. Been on two cruises and loved them too! I don’t consider them totally all-inclusive because drinks aren’t included. And you have to pay for meals on the islands/ports when you are off the ship. But it’s still a great value!

    Post # 6
    1757 posts
    Buzzing bee
    • Wedding: September 2010

    I’ve never tried an all-inclusive. However, we’re likely going to one for our honeymoon. I informed my fiance that after planning a wedding (when I am most definitely NOT the woman who’s been planning her wedding since kindergarten), there’s no way in hell that I’m also planning the honeymoon. Suddenly, with him doing the planning, an all-inclusive looked appealing. Of course, when he thought it was going to be me doing the planning, he proposed a multi-country European trip.

    Post # 7
    2397 posts
    Buzzing bee
    • Wedding: May 2010

    I’ve never been to one… yet!  We’re going to one in Playa Del Carmen for our honeymoon though.  We’re planning on leaving the resort for a day to see the town of Playa Del Carmen and take a ferry to Cozumel.  I agree, I want to see the area, but I’m a sucker for the idea of pampering and 24 hour room service!

    Post # 8
    523 posts
    Busy bee
    • Wedding: October 2010

    I find All-inclusive to be worth it. I basically just use them for the food. I usually pick one that is still within easy travel of the nearest town and I go explore the area as much as possible, then still get “home” in time for dinner, or not depending if I want to. The only draw back..wait, hmmm.nope, can’t think of one…

    Post # 9
    581 posts
    Busy bee
    • Wedding: December 2015

    All-Inclusive gal!!!

    Post # 10
    1084 posts
    Bumble bee
    • Wedding: September 2009

    I’vehad the same question.  We’ve only done independent travel, which I love, and ends up being really cheap when I hear what other people spend on an area.   But it isn’t always the easiest to plan, and some of those watersports sound so fun to be able to do it all right there. 

    But I think we’d end up feeling trapped too, even on our ‘laid back’ honeymoon we were wandering everywhere and running around.  I’m also hesitant of the all-you-can eat and drink, is the food good?  I know they try and have local food but does it really compare, for those who’ve eaten both in and out of the resort?

    Post # 12
    306 posts
    Helper bee
    • Wedding: July 2010

    We’ve never done one, but just today booked our honeymoon at Excellence Playa Mujeres. Our honeymoon can’t be very long (6 days) and we really wanted some time to just sit and relax (and drink!) so it seemed like the best option. I’m really really excited for it, but a bit apprehensive of my first “entrapped vay-cay.”  Here’s hoping that trapped w/ the Fiance for a few days will be glorious, not restricting 😀

    Post # 13
    510 posts
    Busy bee
    • Wedding: September 2009

    I Looooove all-inclusives! I love the fact that everything is taken care of…we’ve been on cruises as well…i’ve never felt trapped though…Undecided…and we’ve always gone adventuring when we go on an all inclusive vacay…all the pampering and food at the resort, and if you want to venture out, take a cab/bus/train and go!

    Post # 14
    3871 posts
    Honey bee
    • Wedding: November 1999

    Never been to an all inclusive before…  but in 2 WEEKS, I’ll be going to Cancun!  Can’t wait.

    I’ve been on trips where I have to stay at a hotel and pay for food and activites and trying to do all of that with the money you have. 

    I just can’t wait to sit on a beach chair and not have to worry about money.


    Horchata…. mmmm  yum!

    Serious, you live in Seattle and never had horchata?  Since moving here, I’ve noticed there a ton of mexican places.  Tried my first horchata when I moved out here.  Also, tried indian for the first time too.

    Post # 15
    2208 posts
    Buzzing bee
    • Wedding: July 2010

    Hate all-inclusives. Well, let me slightly condition that. I have been on several all-inclusive guided trips, and two to resorts. All of those times it was in super interesting places (Zambia, India, Egypt, China, Galapagos). Three of the times, I was with a group of students traveling, and the all-inclusive part was just easier for the organizers. In India and China, it was my parents hosting. So, I’m glad I was there and can’t really complain that I got those opportunities. But I left grounds and skipped meals all the time. If I am somewhere interesting, I don’t want to be spoon fed the experience.

    As an anecdote, while in Zambia I got in trouble for running off to Zimbabwe for the day (by Victoria Falls). I just couldn’t take it anymore, and our place was posh! Additionally, my trips to India and China were both part of a bigger backpacking trip. I went for a longer period, and the parents joined me. I enjoyed the independent part more than the high-end guided part. Even though the independent part didn’t always come with toilet paper. Sealed

    So, I didn’t choose to be on the resort, on the tour, on the cruise. I would not choose that. It wasn’t torture, but it wouldn’t be my first, second, or third choice. I am an eat in the market, get low to the ground, embrace the culture shock kind of person.

    Post # 16
    208 posts
    Helper bee
    • Wedding: August 2011

    I am from the islands and have stayed in many hotels. I can tell you that you should go all inclusive always. 🙂 You would hate to be bombarded with having to pay and tip everytime for everything. The only thing you should need your cash for is your sWorry free and all inclusive is souveniers. We islanders always stay all inclusive unless you just want to rough it and just have no other options due to the there being a huge concert or event where you are stuck not being able to because everything is booked. Trust me. The way to go is all inlusive, especially on your honeymoon. You won’t regret it. You can still go to an all inlclusive and go out and see locals and spend money but it is nice to come back to your hotel and not worry. From an island girl who still has a beautiful home in the islands. 🙂

    The topic ‘All-inclusive vs. Independent travel’ is closed to new replies.

    Find Amazing Vendors