Post # 1
Member
881 posts
Busy bee
Hey bees!
I have a small dilemma and was wondering if any cruise pros could help me out! We have a chance to go on one of two cruises for our honeymoon
Option 1: Norweigan Cruise for 7 days traveling to florida and two ports in the bahamas
Option 2: Royal Caribean Cruise for 11 days traveling to dominican republic, st, thomas, st. marteen, and st. kitts
I have been on several cruises but only through Celebrity so I do not know about these lines and likewise havent done these iteneraries
Opinions?
ETA: Same cost for both (give or take $50)
Post # 3
Member
1475 posts
Bumble bee
@excitedtobeMRSF: I’ve done Carnival cruises to various spots in the caribbean and it was great! What time of year are you going? It might not be that warm in the Bahamas – you might want to go down a little more south.
Post # 4
Member
4192 posts
Honey bee
- Wedding: July 2012 - Baltimore Museum of Industry
check out cruisecritic.com- great reviews of most lines
Post # 5
Member
2958 posts
Sugar bee
- Wedding: August 2013 - Wynn Las Vegas
I have been on a million (rough estimate 😉 ) Royal Caribbean cruises and I LOVE THEM!
Post # 6
Member
881 posts
Busy bee
@Sea_Ashley: March! My Fiance gets cranky when hot so we were hoping for not too too hot
Post # 7
Member
2585 posts
Sugar bee
@excitedtobeMRSF: Hello,
I have not been on Norweigan, but Royal Carribean was amazing! I would always opt to go more places – more to see, more to do, different experiences! Plus its 11 days!
Post # 8
Member
881 posts
Busy bee
@leisha606: How is the dining on RC? Formal nights?
Post # 9
Member
3765 posts
Honey bee
I would want more stops. We did a 7 day cruise with four stops and it was perfect. I didn’t like spending so much time on the boat.
If you go to St. Maarten make sure to visit the beach right next to the airport. You get to see the planes come in for a landing right over your head! St. Thomas was my favorite stop on our cruise. We took a catamaran to St. John and words can’t describe how beautiful it was! We also had time to shop around St. Thomas, as well. I would return there in a heartbeat!
ETA: We went with a private tour company called Bernard’s Tours on St. Maarten. Highly recommend.
Post # 10
Member
1877 posts
Buzzing bee
@excitedtobeMRSF: I have been on a dozen plus cruises and always love Royal Caribbean! Have fun!
Post # 11
Member
905 posts
Busy bee
@excitedtobeMRSF: I’m not a “cruise pro” by any means (I wish I could afford to be one, tho!) but if you’re just looking for good ports, decent food, and lots of fun, I’d go with Carnival. They’re usually cheaper and my ex and I always had a good time.
Post # 12
Member
881 posts
Busy bee
@littlemisst08: Ah thank you so much! We were really curious about the ports but it sounds like you really enjoyed them!!
Post # 13
Member
279 posts
Helper bee
I would def do the virgin Islands. My husband and I did a cruise for our honeymoon but we made it a 10 day trip with a 7 day cruise.
Flew to Puerto Rico Thursday and stayed until Sunday then left for a 7 day cruise (from Puerto Rico) to St Thomas, Barbados, St Lucia, St Kitts and St. Marteen. The Bahamas is great but the virgin islands were much better.
Post # 14
Member
3765 posts
Honey bee
@excitedtobeMRSF: You’re welcome! Of the four stops we made (Bahamas, St. Maarten, St. Thomas, Grand Turk) St. Maarten and St. Thomas were our favorites!
Post # 15
Member
10291 posts
Sugar Beekeeper
In my experience, Celebrity wins for food and service, and is very quiet if you value your privacy. RC is also very well run and caters to a somewhat younger and more social crowd than Celebrity, but a very nice group of people, not an over the top loud, drinking crowd. I would not recommend Norwegian.
Post # 16
Member
881 posts
Busy bee
@weddingmaven: What about norweigan is a con? I would love specifics if you have any! Like I said I havent been on it so I am very clueless!
