Baptizing our daughter Catholic when I'm agnostic… questions

posted 2 months ago in Catholic
Post # 2
1657 posts
Bumble bee
  • Wedding: October 2015

hollyberry4 :  I don’t think it should be an issue for you to remain quiet during the recitations as the Catholic church is primarily focused on how the child is being brought up, so if one parents and the Godparents are Catholic it should suffice. 

Post # 3
257 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: September 2017


Post # 4
684 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: February 2015

I just baptised my baby, and my DH is an atheist. He was not present at all at the ceremony so he didn’t have to lie. I think you’ll be ok not saying anything since everybody else is and nobody will be focusing on you. Otherwise not attending could be an option for you too.

Post # 6
305 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: June 2018

hollyberry4 :  My 11 and 12 year olds were just baptized. They started the classes late, so they didn’t do the classes with the other kids, we took them to meet with the instructor individually and they did their workbooks at home. I’m not totally on board with religion in general but my SO is Catholic and I was supportive of what my girls asked to do. If you were in my shoes, you wouldn’t have any problems with the classes/having to pretend to believe or say anything that is untrue. Also, during the baptism and sacraments themselves, I/we didn’t recite or pledge anything. The girls’ sponsors/Godparents did, I think, but we as parents didn’t. I think you should be good, and just be honest without being too honest, if that makes sense. It might also depend on how conservative your priest is. Our church is very modernized compared to the other ones in town, so they haven’t batted an eye at our divorced/children out of wedlock/blended family/living together before marriage situation one time.

Post # 7
411 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: June 2016

I was baptized when I was 10, I remember it all and it was very special to me. Now I teach in a Catholic school. Yes, there are some rotten apples in the church-just like every other religion/organization. Pope Francis has been doing quite a bit of reform in the church, and hopefully it will continue to become a bit more modernized. For the baptism, you should be able to sit in the pews and observe. My mother isn’t catholic, (my father/grandparents/godparents are) and she sat right in front an didn’t say anything. Quite honestly, I usually don’t tell people in my everyday life that don’t know me personally that I teach in the Catholic church. I have been spit on, called a child molester, and a crook.  All you can do is support her and expose her to other religons/cultures! Best of luck, Mom! 

Post # 8
646 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: June 2018

hollyberry4 :  I’m not Catholic so I might be wrong, but I thought that during a Catholic wedding ceremony, you promise to raise your kids in the Catholic church. Maybe not the ceremony, but in the classes before? So if you were married in the Catholic church, you might have already made that promise.

Post # 10
2027 posts
Buzzing bee
  • Wedding: June 2016

hollyberry4 :  I do not know anything about Catholic baptisms, but I think the best thing would be for you to either sit in the audience or not attend at all. I completely agree with you that you should not recite something you do not believe.  But also, standing there in front of everyone and not participating in the tradition would probably look like you’re basically saying “f you” to their religion, traditions, etc., regardless of your respectful intentions. 

Good luck!

Post # 11
4344 posts
Honey bee
  • Wedding: February 1997

Just be aware that one cannot raise a child in the church and then try to claim you will let them choose their own beliefs. Church acts as indoctrination, telling a child that one belief system is the only truth and the only way to be “saved”. That isn’t freedom of thought for me, and as an atheist I’d have a difficult time that my children would be raised to think their own mother needed “saving”. 

But the best approach would be for you to be honest with the priest of your DH’s church and find out what his requirements are. He may be willing to waive some of them for you.

Post # 12
619 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: August 2017

kristin36890 :  in interfaith marriages in the Catholic church, only the Catholic person is asked to raise the children in the church, and even then it’s more something like a “do your best” situation. In the past, the church would not approve marriages unless they promised to raise children catholic, but that has not been the case for a very long time, at least 15-20 years, probably longer.

Post # 13
18 posts

I’m the non-Cathlic in the relationship and for the 3 baptizms for our kids, I just recited what I believed in and skipped the portions I didn’t.

As far as baptizm classes go…it could be really easy.  At our last one, once the couple figured out I wasn’t Catholic I may as well not even been in the room. 

Leave a comment

Get our weekly roundup of the best of Weddingbee.
I agree to receive emails from the site. I can withdraw my consent at any time by unsubscribing.

Find Amazing Vendors