(Closed) Bees, describe your search for the perfect ring

posted 9 years ago in Rings
Post # 3
586 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: May 2014

I was not involved in shopping for my ring at all 🙂

Post # 4
3525 posts
Sugar bee
  • Wedding: October 2018

I never actually went to a store! But I searched online for months and months until I finally found one that I really loved. There wasn’t a long list of things I wanted, so I’m really surprised it was so hard to find.

Post # 6
663 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: February 2014

We went on one trip and it just so happens that I found the ring I wanted that time. We didn’t buy it that day, though. We waited about three weeks to actually purchase, to make sure we were sure. 

Our specific journey: We went to a mall outside of Pittsburgh called King of Prussia that has, basically, everything. We started at Tiffany & Co. because I said “I want a 1 carat Tiffany solitaire.” I tried it on and wasn’t impressed. We moved on. Although we knew we couldn’t afford it we hit Cartier. I decided I LOVED their solitaire (1889, I think) setting. We weren’t spending $17,000 on a ring, though, so we thanked the nice man and left. Then we went to Baily Banks & Biddle, where I told the lady that I wanted a solitaire that wasn’t boring. She didn’t realize that when I said solitaire I meant “one diamond” not “lots of tiny diamonds encrusted on the setting.” No go. On our way out of the mall we stopped through just one more store: David Yurman. We were unfamiliar with the brand, but it looked like a fancy jeweller, so we went in. I tried on the one solitaire that fit my requirements, and voilá! I’d found my ring. Solitaire, but not boring!

Post # 8
1184 posts
Bumble bee
  • Wedding: June 2013

@ForeverBirds:  SO and I shopped together most of the time.  We started looking in December (2011) in NYC (at Tiffany’s lol) and he ended up buying the original e-ring in February (2012). In that span of time, we went to about 20 different stores and I had tried on a bazillion rings, and was starting to worry I’d never find something I would like.  I knew what I sort of liked, I knew what I did not like, but I hadn’t found the perfect ring yet…until we found the original e-ring.  




Fast forward 14 months later, after a debacle with the original e-ring left me ring-less….we went to a big local jewelry store, I tried on rings, and we found the new e-ring in less than 30 minutes.  At that point, I just *knew* what I liked and what I did not like.  I’m a person who HAS to see the ring on my hand to figure out if I like it or not….  my new e-ring is not similar to my old one at all, but I love it just the same!  It took a LOT of trying on of other rings for me to narrow down in my head what I liked and what didn’t work for me.    Don’t give up, you’ll find it!!  For me, when I kept putting the ring BACK ON and staring at it every chance I got…was the ultimate sign that it was The One for me.   


Post # 9
6317 posts
Bee Keeper
  • Wedding: December 2013

@ForeverBirds:  I’ve always dreamed about my e-ring the same way some girls dream about their weddings so I am quite familiar with the various websites such as Blue Nile. I learned all about the 4Cs and other factors such as fluorescence.

Long story short I thought I wanted a round solitaire until I actually tried one on and was underwhelmed. A beautiful yellow diamond caught my eye at Tiffany’s one day and that is the ring I hope we get.

I’ve been to various high end stores (Tiffany’s, Birks etc.) with my SO and by myself. There are soo many gorgeous rings out there that I’d love to have, but I can’t stop thinking about the yellow diamond.

Post # 10
9168 posts
Buzzing Beekeeper
  • Wedding: November 1999

I knew pretty much what I wanted since I have always wanted a cushion halo with a round diamond  We went shopping at 1 local store and probably visited a half dozen times to look at settings and diamonds before purchasing. I picked out my setting on day 1 but took me a while to commit to it!

He and I only went together – never went with friends or alone or anything. It was such a fun process to go through with him!

Post # 11
434 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: January 2014

I did tons of research about diamonds, e-rings etc. It seems that I know as much as a professional jeweler now..LOL

So after 4 months of detailed research I told my fiance, that it should be set in the yellow gold (cause I like yellow gold jewelry more)..I told him how big my center stone should be…what are the clarity and color minimums..I sent him images of the settings I like, size of my finger..etc. After all that he chose the diamond, setting and ordered it himself..but due to my detailed requests I got exaactly what I wanted. :))))))))))))


Post # 13
1354 posts
Bumble bee
  • Wedding: April 2014

Oh gosh. Where to begin. Well I’d seen tons of rings in magazines that I liked, we often trolled Zales and other, random shops. We went by jewelry stands at faires. I looked online. A lot. Like, all the time. I liked one ring, then another, then another and so on. I kept falling in love with ring after ring. We had almost settled on one until I really researched the quality and it was not up to snuff. So we searched some more. And more! We almost settled on a Moissanite, but I didn’t like the yellow and was deluding myself that I didn’t see it until it became crunch time. Gave up on it. 

Got so disenheartrned that I wrote up a rant about ring hunting here on the ‘Bee and immediately girls jumped on board to help me find something. Many links later, someone pointed me in the direction of this one particular site and I fell in love completely. He ordered it, proposed, and when the ring arrived… The real life color was all wrong.

So he sent it back in exchange for a new color. It arrived, and it was PERFECT.

The End.

Post # 14
73 posts
Worker bee
  • Wedding: April 2014

SO wanted us to pick it out together because he knows how picky I am, haha. But we looked at stores and online for about 6 months before deciding. I chose like 8 different styles before we both fel in love with one. Kinda glad that over but I do love looking at rings;) I’m glad he put up with it for so long though! 

Post # 15
36 posts
  • Wedding: April 2015

Since I knew that I wanted a more ethical ring (conflict-free diamonds or non-diamond, recycled gold, etc), I knew I would be ordering one online since there aren’t any jewellers local to me who offer them, but we went to various jewellery stores to get an idea of what style I liked.

We went to 2 or 3 stores and I tried on various solitaires and three-stone rings which I thought were very pretty, but didn’t feel right at all on my finger. I found all of them much too fussy for me! I would have loved a non-diamond ring, but SO insisted on diamonds so I ended up choosing a beautiful white gold & engraved antique-style half eternity wedding band for my engagement ring from Brilliant Earth. I spent a couple of nights looking for various engagement ring settings at various online stores, but again felt like none were me, and as soon as I considered “wedding” bands I felt more comfortable and chose the ring very quickly!

I suppose I would have liked my mum’s or sister’s opinions, but my SO wouldn’t let me tell anyone!

The topic ‘Bees, describe your search for the perfect ring’ is closed to new replies.

Find Amazing Vendors