(Closed) Cake Cake Cake! What to choose…

posted 7 years ago in Food
  • poll: Cake Options! What flavor? What Style is you favorite?

    Pumpkin with Cheesecake Mousse Filling

    Chocolate with Chocolate Mousse Filling

    Chocolate with Chocolate PB Mousse Filling

    Chocolate with Mocha Mousse Filling

    Strawberry with Key Lime Mousse Filling

    Three Tiered Traditional Cake (One Piece/ea Guest)

    Two Tiered Cake w Sheet Cakes (Extra Cake for Cake Lovers)

  • Post # 3
    2089 posts
    Buzzing bee
    • Wedding: October 2014

    @Ms_Purple:  I know is isnt overly helpful but that cake stand is stunning!

    Post # 4
    388 posts
    Helper bee
    • Wedding: December 2013

    Hello, fellow WI bride!  I used to live in Madison, and heard great things about Craig’s Cakes.  I am sure anything they do will be great.

    I choose Pump w/Cheesecake filling.  Sounds seasonally Fall, but delicious.  I also like the idea of the Strawberry w/Key lime.  I sounds like a great Spring/Summer option.  I can’t imagine anyone not liking it.  The Choc w/PB sound like a crowd pleaser.  Everyone seems to love that combo.  I would personally love the mocha filling, but I don’t know that this would be the best choice for a large group.  Kind-of a personal preference sort-of thing.

    When I choose my cake, the baker said it would be best to choose enough cake for everyone to have the same slice.  I don’t know how you are serving your cake, so I can’t really give my opinion on 2 or 3 tiers.  I will only say I would be upset if someone got a piece I wanted but got served something else.

    Good luck!  Looks yummy.  I plan on eating 2 (or 3 pieces) at my wedding, too.

    Post # 5
    107 posts
    Blushing bee
    • Wedding: August 2013

    Oh wow! All of those sound so good! If you go for the option of having extra cake so that people can have seconds then I have a feeling you will end up with lots of left-overs (but maybe that’s a good thing!). 

    I was also thinking that since the peanut butter is not your top favourite, I would pass on it since it’s such a common allergy. Whatever you go with it sounds like it’ll be phenomenal! Enjoy!


    Post # 6
    3101 posts
    Sugar bee

    @Ms_Purple:  I don’t like mousse, so none of those would appeal to me.  Can you do a frosting filling on one?

    Post # 7
    2742 posts
    Sugar bee
    • Wedding: October 2014 - Disney

    I chose the choc pb, choc choc mousse, and the pumpkin cheesecake. The pumpkin being my favorite. I’d go 2 tier with a sheetcake in the back.

    We are requesting from disney for cake flavors:





    And a variety of mousses to try. We shall see how it goes this fall :D.


    Post # 8
    2211 posts
    Buzzing bee
    • Wedding: May 2014

    @Ms_Purple:  I chose the pumpkin w/cheesecake filling, because that sounds AMAZING, as well as the chocolate with PB mousse.  Mmm.  And an extra sheet cake, because I agree:  the only thing better than cake is more cake.  Makes me almost wish we had decided to go with cake instead of cupcakes.

    The sister of one of my high school friends is the head cake designer at Craig’s, and she’s crazy talented.  Getting your cake there, you’ll be able to have whatever design you want on it.  She’s probably the most talented artist I know (she also paints, which makes sense, including body painting!).

    Post # 10
    451 posts
    Helper bee
    • Wedding: November 2014

    You said strawberry with key lime and my mouth watered! I think you ABSOLUTLY need to keep this one. It is fun and different and no one will expect it. I go for my cake tasting tomorrow (first one) and I hope my cakes look as good as yours! p.s. LOVE the cake stand!!!!!

    Post # 12
    2211 posts
    Buzzing bee
    • Wedding: May 2014

    Man, I want some cake so badly now…

    Post # 13
    175 posts
    Blushing bee
    • Wedding: February 2014

    @Ms_Purple:  We are using Craig’s as well, our tasting is next month, can’t wait.  I’m excited about the pumpkin and the strawberry, the pink might be fun for my Valentine’s wedding. 


    Can you give me an idea of what the 2 tier cake cost was, also the 3 tier, would like to have an idea and not get sticker shock.

    And where did you find that cake stand, it is awesome!







    Post # 14
    2450 posts
    Buzzing bee
    • Wedding: October 2012

    i just want to say that our disney wedding cake was chocolate with peanut butter cup mousse. it’s basically peanut butter and chocolate mousse. 

    so that’s what i voted for you too… because it was the best cake i’d ever had in my life. it haunts my dreams…

    Post # 16
    2965 posts
    Sugar bee
    • Wedding: April 2013

    View original reply
    @DomesticDiva:  +1! And it’s only 10AM!!!

    The topic ‘Cake Cake Cake! What to choose…’ is closed to new replies.

    Find Amazing Vendors