(Closed) Cakes: Fondant vs Buttercream?

posted 9 years ago in Reception
  • poll: Fondant vs Buttercream. What holds up better outdoors in the heat?
    Fondant : (20 votes)
    35 %
    Buttercream : (34 votes)
    60 %
    Other: Please explain! : (3 votes)
    5 %
  • Post # 3
    Member
    700 posts
    Busy bee
    • Wedding: September 2010

    I think fondant would hold up better, but we are doing cheese cake.  🙂 

    Post # 4
    Member
    76 posts
    Worker bee
    • Wedding: February 2010

    I am one hundred million percent for buttercream. While fondant looks lovely, it tastes awful! My mom makes cakes on the side and she cannot stand working with fondant, especially in the heat. You can still achieve the same smooth sleek look with buttercream, plus it’s cheaper and tastes a million times better. Now, you’re concerned about which will hold up better in the heat, and I’m not entirely sure. But if you hear from more than one bakery that buttercream holds up better in the heat, then I would take their expert opinion.

    Post # 5
    Member
    193 posts
    Blushing bee
    • Wedding: August 2009

    The debate over fondant and buttercream… When meeting with cake bakers one of the things that was always on my mind was would I have to use fondant. I have had cake with fondant, and it is not good. It is very chewy and sweet. Yes, it does make your cake look close to perfection, but taste is very imporant too. I was lucky enough to find a baker who makes buttercream look like fondant, no kidding. I was amazed when looking at her pictures, asking her is this fondant, no everytime. With an outdoor August wedding, I would lean towards fondant only because the cakes moisture will hold up better in the heat, but don’t feel like that’s your only option. Go to several bakers and try different fondants, some are way better than others.

    Post # 6
    Member
    400 posts
    Helper bee
    • Wedding: May 2009

    Buttercream tastes much better. You can get buttercream to be very smooth, it just takes time and good practice.

    Fondant dries out, so it doesn’t always taste good. It’s mostly sugar, so it’s usually too sweet for most people to eat.

     Go with what your baker suggests.

    Post # 7
    Member
    168 posts
    Blushing bee
    • Wedding: May 2009

    I’ve heard that fondant holds up better in the heat, but that the flavor isn’t the greatest. I like hearing what the other girls are saying, that if you want the clean look of the fondant you might be able to find a baker who uses buttercream like fondant. If you get a professional baker they’ll also have ideas for keeping the buttercream from having trouble in the heat – not bringing it out until the last minute, cutting your cake earlier in the reception, etc. I’d also ask your baker about an eggless cake and what it would taste like, if it’s a possibility. If it won’t work all that well, it would be a nice gesture to find out your nephew’s favorite dessert and get some made just for him. One of my BMs hates cake, so, inspired by her, I’m having a dessert buffet – cakes, cheesecake, pies, and chocolates.

    Post # 8
    Member
    6009 posts
    Bee Keeper
    • Wedding: May 2009

    I’ve heard that fondant can sweat in the heat.  My caterer also told me about a cake at a wedding she worked where the fondant actually slid off the cake as they tried to cut it because of the heat.  Are there any bakers (or people in the know) out there who can tell us what really happens?  I’m kinda curious about this.

    P.S.  My vote is buttercream, but I love frosting, so there you go!

    Post # 9
    Member
    148 posts
    Blushing bee
    • Wedding: December 1969

    Buttercream tastes soo much better and most bakeries do a lovely job now getting it smooth enough that it loks like fondant. However, holding up in the heat can be a concern (depending on what kind of temps we are talking about here). I have heard about people having a layer of buttercream underneath the fondant so people can peel the fondant off their piece or eat around it and still get some frosting. That may not be a bad option if you still want the yummy taste of buttercream but the fondant on the outside to help protect from the heat.

    Post # 11
    Member
    2681 posts
    Sugar bee

    I absolutely love buttercream and would choose it any day over fondant.  HOWEVER, buttercream and/or whipped cream will melt outdoor in the heat.  If you are set on doing buttercream, have it refridgerated and taken out just prior to the cake cutting.  This may not be ideal if your venue does not a fridge to hold the size of your cake, or they might not want to move it once its delivered.

    Post # 12
    Member
    400 posts
    Helper bee
    • Wedding: May 2009

    There is ALWAYS a layer of buttercream under the fondant (at least at places I’ve gone, or when I’ve made my own). It helps hold the fondant on, and it keeps it slightly moist.

    Most people have to take the fontant off because it doesn’t stay moist unless it is touching the buttercream underneath. For example, the attached cake’s fondant would dry about because of all the fondant. (fondant touching fondant doesn’t stay moist.)

    Having buttercream under the fondant also helps it stay attached.

    [attachment=161220,9787]

    Post # 13
    Member
    209 posts
    Helper bee
    • Wedding: May 2009

    Well, fondant makes for prettier cakes, but buttercream tast SO MUCH BETTER!!! Tast is way more important to me than the look of a cake.

    Post # 14
    Member
    297 posts
    Helper bee
    • Wedding: August 2008

    FOndant is prettier, but buttercream is very tasty.

    As for eggless cakes – it can be done, but you’ll have to shop around for bakeries who will do so. If you can’t, I suggest getting your nephew a cupcake with similar flavours and icing. We did this for my mum who can’t have soy. (Baking an entire wedding cake without gluten, dairy and soy would have been too difficult let alone expensive!)

    Good luck!

    Post # 15
    Member
    360 posts
    Helper bee
    • Wedding: September 2009 - Westwind YWCA camp

    fondant will hold up better in the heat, but doesn’t taste that great.  did you know it’s the same stuff as what’s inside those cadbury cream eggs?  crazy!

    There is another option besides buttercream, though – italian meringue ICING.  

    A lot of bakers offer italian meringue buttercream frosting.  They make the italian meringue icing, and then add a POUND of butter.  Personally, I can’t stomach that much butter.  Italian meringue icing just has added powdered sugar.  It holds up much better than buttercream also (since it’s a meringue, the eggs are cooked) – and much less fat!

    I’ll be blogging about the difference between meringue buttercream frosting and meringue icing, and how to make them both in a week or so.  Till then, good luck!

    Post # 16
    Member
    213 posts
    Helper bee
    • Wedding: January 2009

    I chose fondant because it had the smooth surface. Maybe you can go with what your baker is confident with? I’m sure if one of his/her cakes turned out a disaster, they would have heard from the couple.

    The topic ‘Cakes: Fondant vs Buttercream?’ is closed to new replies.

    Find Amazing Vendors