Post # 1
We have been looking at rings and I’ve narrowed it down to these two…
They are similar, but different and because they are so similar I’m having a hard time choosing!
The one with the blue star is really nice, but one thing I don’t like is how the band looks rough on the top where the other diamonds are…the picture with the pink star, that ring is so pretty and I love how it looks neat with the neat edges and stuff, but I’m a bit concerned about the thin band and that the main diamond will be top heavy and the ring will wobble or something?
Ugh I don’t know what to do! I read reviews on both rings and both got great reviews, but I’m still unsure!
Post # 3
I’d go with the blue star (first ring) because I prefer 4 prongs to 6 prongs, and I also like the halo better on the blue star.
Post # 4
2nd one, I don’t like how the center stone sticks up away from the halo in the first one, and I prefer 6 prongs to 4 prongs.
Post # 5
2nd. I don’t like rings that are hollowed out on the inside like ring #1.
Plus, 6 prongs are more protective, and I love that!
Post # 6
Thanks for your input! I think I like the 2nd ring more, but it’s still a tough decision!
Post # 7
@almostthere92: I prefer #2 because the first one is cathedral, and I’m not a huge fan of that style.
Post # 9
- Wedding: March 2014 - Chicago, IL
@almostthere92: After having a ring like #1 with shared prong micropave that wasn’t protected and dropped stones, I voted for #2. #2 looks like the stones are more secure in the setting.
Post # 10
Have someone put their hands behind their back with one item in each hand representing each ring. Then choose a hand.
If you are disappointed by which one gets chosen – choose the other!
Post # 11
I personally like the look of the first one more…..can’t really say why..I just like it more. They are both very pretty though and you can’t go wrong with either…I think you should just go with the one you like the look of more….
Congrats and good luck…let us know what you decide!!
Post # 13
I much prefer the blue star ring!
Post # 14
I like the second one best! I think the stones look more secure on the second one and I like the position of the center stone better.
Post # 15
Does it matter to you if your band will sit flush with your e-ring? Because it looks to me (and I’m just guessing!) that your band WOULD be able to sit flush with the blue star, but would not with the pink star.
Post # 16
@almostthere92: If this is of any help, I didn’t even notice the “roughness” of the band – it made me look at mine, and mine is the same! You should definitly go look at them in person, because I dont think you will notice it by looking at it, unless your looking for it