(Closed) Etsy engagement ring- should I?

posted 6 years ago in Rings
Post # 16
185 posts
Blushing bee
  • Wedding: December 2008

Please post a picture of your ring!! 🙂 I LOVE Artemer. I was literally so close to buying my new wedding ring from them but I went another. I am still planning on getting the rings I wanted from Artemer though, just as a ring hand ring instead. 

View original reply

Post # 17
30 posts

I totally would order from Etsy, its probably generally more reputable than many major chain sites/stores – just read reviews & check out their sales.

Make sure you check out Stacy Kripas, or BelViaggio designs on Etsy. She is a Charlves & Colvard enthuisiast, amazing pieces, amazing reviews – especially if you are interested in moissanite, but she has genuine pieces also & will make anything! SO & I are ordering our pieces from there, very very excited to see.

Post # 19
10286 posts
Sugar Beekeeper
  • Wedding: June 2015

View original reply
ellebea82: yeah, Etsy reviews are pretty useless. that stops me from ordering from them, but you did due diligence and I can’t wait to see your ring! Congrats:-)

Post # 20
752 posts
Busy bee

I am really happy you took the time to look into other sellers. I still like Etsy, I’m just very cautious about it now. I’m glad this company seems a lot more legitimate than the previous one. Please post a picture when it arrives, I’m excited for you! 

Post # 21
274 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: June 2016

We bought my enagagment ring off etsy- I wanted something simple and nondiamond, which was surprisingly difficult to find at local jewelers/box store. It hasn’t arrived yet and I’m super nervous, hope it looks good….

Post # 23
274 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: June 2016


View original reply
ellebea82:  here’s my ring! Haha please ignore the giant hand close up.

It’s 14k rose gold from 360diamonds (they do white sapphires as well) I’m really pleased with it! It’s just what I was looking for And wasn’t finding in person. They also customized the four prong setting to be “t” instead of “x”. 

i am going to replace the sapphire with a difference stone. I was on the fence about blue gemstone with rose gold, and once Fiance showed me purple-hued sapphires he picked out, I realized I’d like that better. The loose stones are also better quality than the one that set. (But again for the price that is what I expected) 🙂

Post # 24
55 posts
Worker bee
  • Wedding: June 2012

I actually bought a beautiful custom made ring from that seller. It was wonderful craftsmanship and the seller was great to work with. I am very picky with my jewelry and I made sure I got what I wanted. I have had it for two years now and all the little pave diamonds have held up well. 

I am sorry that one person had a bad experience with that etsy seller but overall that seller did a wonderful job my amethyst push present/ring. 

Hope this helps!

Post # 25
1 posts
  • Wedding: June 2020

View original reply
adoresanimals :  hello,

We are considering purchasing my ring from TwoPeriDotBirds on etsy. Like you say we have only read one bad review out of many wonderful ones. Just wondering, do you have a picture of your ring so I could see the quality? Are you still happy with your ring from them? 

Thank you 🙂 

The topic ‘Etsy engagement ring- should I?’ is closed to new replies.

Find Amazing Vendors