(Closed) Have you ever taken home a slice of wedding cake …. how was it?

posted 9 years ago in Food
  • poll: Should Ms.HymanRoth give out a slice of her famous cake for guests to take home ...
    Yes, I would really enjoy eating it in pajamas the next morning! : (15 votes)
    79 %
    No, don't do it. : (2 votes)
    11 %
    I have seen this and everyone loved it. : (2 votes)
    11 %
    Other, I'll explain below. : (0 votes)
  • Post # 3
    246 posts
    Helper bee
    • Wedding: July 2011

    Cake is cake!! even better the next day after a night of dancing and drinks! I think it’s sweet gift for guests to take home. What else are you going to do with all that leftover cake??

    Post # 4
    1980 posts
    Buzzing bee
    • Wedding: March 2014

    I agree! I mean, when you bake a cake at home you don’t eat it all in one day! It will be just fine, and I think thats a great favor.

    Logistically thought, think about how you would get all the cake boxed up and put on the table before the guests left. AND you would have to *plan* on ordering double the cake you normally would, because you would need enough cake for each person twice (once at the reception, and once to take home)

    If its going to be a favor, you need to have enough for every guest.

    Post # 5
    258 posts
    Helper bee
    • Wedding: May 2010

    When we were little my parents would always bring home wedding cake for myself and my siblings. They tucked it under our pillow (wrapped) and we were to dream of the spouse we were to marry. I’m unsure about this strange custom but as a kid, I and my sis & brother  certainly loved eating the cake the next day and…well… I still do. Eat the cake that is, not sleep on it.

    Post # 6
    2470 posts
    Buzzing bee
    • Wedding: September 2010

    My parents always used to bring us a piece back when we were little.

    Now, Fiance and I are going to have a cake buffet with cake boxes for favors. And really, its not your bakers choice, its yours!

    Love those boxes… do you know where they are from?

    Post # 7
    7975 posts
    Bumble Beekeeper

    What does your baker expect you to do with that leftover cake if you’re not allowed to eat it that night? Let the clean up crew binge after the reception clears out?

    Pack it up, send it home! Why waste a good thing???

    Post # 8
    2889 posts
    Sugar bee

    I feel like I never get the wedding cake at the wedding so this would be a nice treat to go home with. Who knows, it may be mmore of a midnight snack than next morning treat for your guests. I would also worry about not having enough for everyone to have a slice at the party and one to take home though. Maybe you could provide the boxes as an option for left overs but not an actual favor.

    Post # 9
    10218 posts
    Sugar Beekeeper
    • Wedding: November 2010

    oh my goodness one of my friends gave her YUMMY amaretto and hazelnut cake out to guests as a favor and it was delicious TWO DAYS later!! I was out of town and brought it home and my sister ate it and was asking for more because it was still so moist and so good….

    Post # 10
    4485 posts
    Honey bee

    I haven’t seen that only because the cake is usually completely devoured before the end of the reception. If it is left behind, it’s either a flavor that no one likes or it’s dry.

    As far as the information your baker has given you, that is false and she knows it. There isn’t a person on the planet who given a cake can finish it in one sitting/day and there’s usually some leftover the next day or 2 days down the road  and it does not turn bad or dry out. I have had frozen cake that tastes dry after it finishes sweating from the thawing process but a freshly baked cake, whether from a grocery store bakery or homemade, 99.9% of the time is still good and fresh 1-3+ days later. However it does need to be kept in an airtight container. At the same time, there are cakes (usually frozen at some point during the baking process) that dry out within an hour or more of cutting them, which is why you don’t want to cut the cake before dinner and then serve it afterward (not to mention, it does not take that long to cut because it sits around the majority of the time waiting to be served after it is cut).

    What you are planning is perfectly fine. Your guests will certainly appreciate it because who doesn’t like cake the next day? That was actually quite common during Victorian England where the whole superstition of the wedding cake being given to single ladies (rather than actually being eaten) to put under their pillows to dream of their future husbands comes from.

    Even if you did have leftover cake, does your baker seriously expect you to toss it straight in the trash? People would only do that if it was bad to begin with. Honestly, if it were me, I would find a different baker asap because this one doesn’t seem to be a good match for you with false information, shady practices, etc.


    Post # 11
    888 posts
    Busy bee

    i think this is a nice idea and i have eaten wedding cake the next day and it was yummy!  of course, it would be hard to wait – id probably juts devour it in the parking lot

    and love the little box – so cute!

    The topic ‘Have you ever taken home a slice of wedding cake …. how was it?’ is closed to new replies.

    Find Amazing Vendors