Help me find a (setting-only) lookalike for this ring!

posted 8 months ago in Rings
Post # 2
5302 posts
Bee Keeper

Jared [shudders] and since 1910 have something similar.  But your best bet would be to go custom.  You’ll save a fortune if you have it made versus buying retail.

Post # 3
1152 posts
Bumble bee
  • Wedding: September 2010


janeerror :  I would find a local reputable free standing independent jeweler and have them custom make it. My jeweler will make anything you ask for. I mean within reason as long as it is structurally sound. But go custom. ๐Ÿ™‚ And it is not as expensive as you may think a lot of times it can even be cheaper. Best of luck bee. 

Post # 4
471 posts
Helper bee

 I was going to say… maybe check with David Klass for a quote. He’s so reasonably priced. 

Post # 5
30 posts
  • Wedding: June 2019

Kay Jewelers has a Neil Lane that is very similar. They can take the diamond out and put in one you want. Just have to do in store.

Post # 6
33 posts
  • Wedding: April 2020

So if you’re looking for a trusting jeweler to make you a nice affordable setting and use your stone. I personally trust Russells Jewelers on Etsy. He has great customer service and just made my engagement ring. I hope that helps! 

Post # 7
487 posts
Helper bee

My boyfriend and I went with David Klass – even though he is custom, he was way cheaper than all of the jewelers in our city.  We saved well over $1000 (and we also provided the stones).  Custom does not mean expensive.

Post # 8
3489 posts
Sugar bee
  • Wedding: April 2006

I’m another one who says to contact David Klass. Even though he does custom, he does great work and makes it affordably too! 

Post # 9
2493 posts
Buzzing bee
  • Wedding: March 2006

Beautiful setting! I vote custom too. David Klass and Stephanie with Pristine Custom Rings on Etsy are both the most reasonable I’ve found for the quality. Raven Fine Jewelers was a close second and Michael has phenomenal customer service. All three of them do actually. 

Whatever you do, please update with pics! ๐Ÿ˜๐Ÿ˜๐Ÿ˜

Post # 11
364 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: July 2017

Check with some local jewelers. Many will do reasonably priced custom settings. The one you like is fairly simple, so I imagine you could find someone local to make it to your liking. Good luck!

Post # 12
3651 posts
Sugar bee
  • Wedding: June 2017

janeerror :  just get david klass to make it. And stay away from BE – they’re shady AF (my ering is BE and i would never go near them again). 

Post # 13
8 posts




I just wanted to offer input from a jewelry store perspective!


When someone brings in a photo we check for something that matches within our catalog, then offer custom if there isn’t something almost identical avaliable.


Generally ordering a style that is already avaliable is the most affordible, but having something completely custom isn’t going to cause the setting to be unreasonably expensive. One positive about ordering a style that is already offered is you know exactly what it will look like and may be able to see a sample mounting in person before ordering.


One thing to consider when reaching out to jewelers about the mounting is that a small online shop is unlikely to have access to a large catalog while a more established jewelry store should have access to a large catalog.


Both are good options. It just depends on what you’re comfortible with!

Leave a comment

Find Amazing Vendors