Post # 30
I prefer the James Allen ring.
I say that because I think the design of the Blue Nile ring leaves something to be desired.
Post # 32
I’m in the minority it looks like- I way prefer the blue nile one!
Post # 33
hafh2016 : since you are in the minority could you explain why you prefer the blue nile?
Post # 34
John427 : Blue Nile for sure!!!
I dont know what is wrong with me, but I despise milgrain. Its just a personal preference. If you could have that removed, I would like the JA one better because it is more unique with the marquise.
Post # 35
- Wedding: June 2018 - Vineyard Lake
I like the detail of the James Allen ring. Can’t go wrong with either of them though. They are both beauties!
Post # 36
John427 : James Allen by a country mile! You seem to be leaning towards the blue nile ring though, any reason for that?
Post # 37
thumperbear : I’m not sure which one i prefer. Blue nile is more standard though and more of a safe pick, james allen is more unusual so maybe more risky. Either way, I’d suggest we go shopping for a ring together if she thinks she might want something else, but still.