Post # 1

Member
6 posts
Newbee
I had my first fitting, and much to my dismay, my wedding dress is too short if I wear the 3.5 inch Badgley Mischkas I had chosen for the day. Kind of a shock as I am only 5’8”, and the bridal salon assured me I did not need to order extra length. Sigh. Anyway, I’m now on the mad hunt for a pair of 2-2.5in super cute heels. Dress is a classic and simple Romona Keveza v-neck in “natural white” with buttons down the back. Budget is under $350 or so. I’m open to a “something blue” shoe. Any Suggestions? Here’s what I’ve found so far:
Benjamin Adams “Celine” (also available in light blue)

2.5 in. Milk and Honey (downside is 4 week min order time)

Also 2.5 in. Milk and Honey
Post # 3

Member
2207 posts
Buzzing bee
Those are cute options! I’m mainly posting so I can see the results. 🙂 I’m planning on no higher than 3 inch heels as well… Although mine is on purpose lol. Sorry you have to scramble now! 🙁
Post # 4

Member
3241 posts
Sugar bee
Post # 5

Member
239 posts
Helper bee
I needed 2 – 2.5 inch shoes too and our ceremony is on grass so I wanted a wedege. I found and ordered these and they are SO cute and a great price! The are City Classified RIGEL Women’s Bow Knot Cork Wedge Ankle Strap Sandals
I got this color

They also have a teal color

But that may not be the look you are going for.
I LOVE theses from Seychelles! But I really wanted to wear a wedge.
Here’s the link: http://seychellesfootwear.com/Home.tpl?page=singleitem.inc&cart=130323601029&sku=triplig9sl&H_P_Special=triplig9sl#

and These are from Zappos: http://www.zappos.com/rsvp-shelby-ivory

Post # 6

Member
658 posts
Busy bee
Post # 7

Member
22 posts
Newbee

Here’s a super cute pair I ordered They come in a few colors, have good reviews, and the heel in under 3″. Plus the heart on the bottom is super cute!!
Post # 8

Member
6 posts
Newbee
Thanks all for so many good suggestions! Dancingfox, I also LOVE those blue Seychelles! I don’t think they are quite as formal as I was going for, but I may order them for another occasion!
LClaire18, where are those shoes from?
Post # 9

Member
6 posts
Newbee
Has anyone tried Rachel Simpson heels? Would have to order from the UK with all the shipping costs associated with that. And, of course, no free returns. I’m so spoiled by zappos, amazon, piperlime, etc.!
Post # 10

Member
1022 posts
Bumble bee
@maggiebee: I like those, and now I”m freaking out that I’l have to wear different shoes too
Post # 11

Member
2335 posts
Buzzing bee
@maggiebee: The shoes that LClaire18 posted are on Amazon, they’re the Luichiny brand. I tried them and they were super uncomfortable on me, but others have liked them.
Nina has some good options at that heel height.
Post # 12

Member
6 posts
Newbee
@BooRadley: Thanks for the tip! Turns out the Luichiny shoes are a bit too high anyway, and I definitely don’t want uncomfortable shoes! I figure if I’m stuck with the low heels, they better at least be super comfy.
@W292737: Sorry you are in the same dilemma! If you have time before your wedding, check out Milk and Honey. Pricey, but soooo many options at a low heel height.
I haven’t heard any comments about the quality/comfort of Rachel Simpson shoes, but I think the look will coordinate perfectly with my lace veil, so I decided to give them a try. Amazingly, they advertise US shipping in 1-3 business days (after they leave the store)! Let’s hope they fit!
Post # 13

Member
301 posts
Helper bee
How about these? They are really pretty in person and I would have gotten these if they had fit my foot shape better! The Nina Crista in Iovry Luster Satin. Also, they are on sale pretty much everywhere so that’s a plus.

Post # 14

Member
115 posts
Blushing bee

These are around 2.5 inch heel height. They are actually from Payless, only $30, and look very nice. Definately not a typical Payless shoe!
Post # 15

Member
237 posts
Helper bee
@maggiebee:
These ones are from H&M. I saw them in the store and I got in line twice before I decided I needed more time to think. These actually match my wedding color perfectly, but I already got my ceremony shoes and can’t return them 🙁 (second photo)


These are actually more greenish turquoise than blue turquoise, which I was disappointed about. But I need the short heel as well.