Post # 1
- Wedding: April 2015 - Anchor Inn, MD
So we’re doing a garter toss at our wedding (10 days away!!) and I got a cute Superman garter set from Etsy (https://www.etsy.com/transaction/1020885950) as a surprise to my fiance because Superman is his favorite. It came with a “throw-away” or “toss” garter which is great so I can keep the nicer one. BUT, I’m a little confused how this works… Do I wear both all night? Does he take them both off? Does he just take off the toss garter and not see the real one til that night? Or do I only wear the real one and he takes that one off, and then he just throws the toss one? So confused!
Post # 2
I would say- excuse yourself to the bathroom before all that and replace the garter to the throw away.
Post # 3
- Wedding: May 2015 - Walnut Hill Bed & Breakfast
It was my assumption that you wear both, toss on the bottom, and he just pulls off the bottom one.
Post # 4
I agree with Amber. Wear both, the toss one on the bottom.
Post # 5
Agree! That’s what I did.
Post # 6
OMG! I love that garter. My fiance and I have matching Superman tattoos!!
Post # 7
I wore both. Just make sure to put the one you want tosed at the bottom. I got a set at DB’s and it was just fine. If you chafe a buch use a little deoderant to help.