(Closed) I don't dislike my ring, but I don't love it.

posted 9 years ago in Rings
Post # 3
476 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: June 2013

Ugh that’s a tough one. Honestly, you sound pretty resentful about the whole thing. Its a beautiful ring and I think that a jeweler should have no problem making a pointed band to go with it, but are you sure that’s what you really want? Would it be possible to keep the ring as a right hand ring and get your own ering? I understand the sentimental value piece of it, but I also understand wanting something that is truly yours and reflects you and your Fiance, not his mother.

Post # 4
4173 posts
Honey bee
  • Wedding: April 2018

@joyfulgirl9682:  You know, I think it’s lovely that your Future Mother-In-Law chose to give you her ring, it’s such a kind and loving gesture, that being said…if she gave it to you, it’s yours, which means that making it something that honors her and appeals to your personal taste at the same time is not only fine, it should be expected….I really think that you should have something you like…and while I understand the ring on your finger is a total departure from what you envisioned…that doesn’t mean you can’t do something with it that catches the spirit of what you were looking for while nodding to the sentimentality of the gift itself.

She can be as upset as she wants…fact is a gift should NEVER have strings attached to it, that’s controlling and manipulative…and completely unrealistic to expect that you wouldn’t want to put your personal touches on something you will be wearing for the REST OF YOUR LIFE…

And let’s not over estimate the significance of a setting, or a ring in the least…at the end of the day, this is metal and rock….something that can be manipulated and changed at any time….you could melt that bad boy down, still have “the ring” in essence, reformed into a solitaire, do a sapphire halo around the diamond and still be wearing “the ring” in a Lazarus Reborn kind of way….

If she’s going to stick on it…give it back to her and say as lovely as it is, and as touching as the gesture was, you would rather have some say in how the symbol of your marriage to her son looks, rather than being a walking, talking display case for her jewelry.

Post # 5
2340 posts
Buzzing bee
  • Wedding: November 2012

If I were in your position I would design or find an amazing stand-alone wedding band with sapphires and after the wedding wear the engagement ring as a right hand ring.




Post # 6
289 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: December 2014

I think the ring is lovely but it is not even close to the ring you wanted. Your Fiance and her mother seem so attached to it though, I do not see how you can make the change gracefully. The ring you like is untraditional as an e-ring though and I don’t see why you can’t still have it as a RHR or possibly an upgrade down the line.

Post # 7
526 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: February 2013

@joyfulgirl9682:  I agree with MidnightSun: Design a stand alone wedding band that you love and transfer the e-ring to your right hand. The first one she posted is AMAZING

Post # 8
89 posts
Worker bee

@6598731ssfse3:  Those are stunning!


Op, I’m not going to lie. I think the ring you are being forced to wear looks outdated and like a spider web. No offence to  your Future Mother-In-Law. She should not be forcing (more like guilting you) into wearing.


See if you can approach her and say that the ring was new to her and brought her many years of happiness and you’d be honored to wear the stone. Tell her that you want it reset it to symbolize YOUR new life with your Fiance and that you don’t wish to offend her. Would that fly?

Post # 9
721 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: January 2015

You’re the one who is going to have to wear it for the rest of your life.

If you aren’t happy with it, maybe keep and wear it as a RHR and get the beautiful ring you really wanted if the budget allows as your ering.  

Post # 10
3108 posts
Sugar bee
  • Wedding: August 2013

That sucks, I’m sorry that happened that way.

I think your Future Mother-In-Law giving her son her engagment ring for you is an incredibly sweet and generous gesture. However, deciding that this would also be YOUR engagement ring without even asking you is pretty crappy. Yes, the ring is just a symbol, but it’s a symbol of your relationship with your Fiance. I think your feelings and preferences should definitely have been taken into account.

Also, with your Future Mother-In-Law upset about you not loving the style — what did she expect? Everyone has different taste, and that’s…..a lot of ring. My Fiance and I had a lot of fun trying on rings and picking out the perfect one for our budget — it was really a bonding experience for us. I’m sorry that your Fiance seems to have decreed what ring you’re supposed to wear for the rest of your life.

Post # 11
4394 posts
Honey bee

@cmbr:  I agree. 

OP, I would either do like midnightsun posted or just tell your Fiance that it’s really not your style. I think you have a right to have your engagement ring be something you love. I know you don’t want to hurt her feelings, but this is one of the smaller issues you two will have to agree upon throughout your lifetime. She should understand that it’s not what you wanted. Good luck!

Post # 12
4194 posts
Honey bee
  • Wedding: May 2010

If I were you, instead of trying to find my ‘dream’ wedding band to match this e-ring, I would pick out my dream e-ring and matching wedding band when going wedding band shopping with Fiance, don’t mention it at all to Future Mother-In-Law and right after the wedding start wearing her e-ring as a right hand ring with your dream e-ring and wedding band on your wedding ring finger.

I would even be very hush hush about the new set to everyone, not just Future Mother-In-Law, until after the ceremony. Just have a trusted friend be the real ring bearer with your new set and switch the old e-ring to your other hand right before walking down the aisle. If anyone asks about your wedding band before the wedding just say “its’ beautiful, but we think it’s bad luck to show it to anyone before the wedding so you’ll have to wait”.

She won’t be able to say anything to you since you’ll be married already and the jewelry is all purchased. I wouldn’t even discuss it with her either, I would wait for her to bring it up and the only response I would give is something along the lines of “I feel so special to be wearing your e-ring along with my own wedding jewelry” so hopefully she gets teh message that the discussion is over, it’s your own jewelry and she cant’ control what you wear.

Post # 13
237 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: April 2013

@beb1972:  +1 to all of this!

If she really wants you to keep the ring exactly as is, then I would give it back.

Post # 14
24 posts
  • Wedding: March 2014

Rock and a hard place hun. I think maybe the best thing to do is be honest with her but word it the right way.


“This is my promise to you of forever, and this is the ring I will be wearing forever, it means a lot to me and I want it but maybe we can have it reset into something more my style.”


If you’re not able or willing to say that then let it go and I think getting a wedding band that is more in your liking is a great idea! 


Or you can go out an buy a wedding band for your Fiance that you know she wont like and see if she gets a sense of how you feel? Evil, but just might work. 

Post # 15
1849 posts
Buzzing bee
  • Wedding: June 2015

i think your Fiance needs to step in here and remind his mother that she actually isn’t a party to the engagement! it’s lovely that she is willing for you to have this family ring – BUT she needs to be realistic – she knows it’s not your style and you’ll need to wear it forever.

I don’t know why your Fiance continued on with the plan to give you the family ring when he knew you wouldn’t like it? is it a budget issue? could you maybe use this ring ‘for now’ until you are able to get a ring that’s about you two?

it just seems like you’re being awfully accomodating of your Fiance and your Future Mother-In-Law, and neither of them seem very concerned about what you like – and you are the one who needs to wear it.

Post # 16
89 posts
Worker bee

I think the stone would look amazing reset like this!


The topic ‘I don't dislike my ring, but I don't love it.’ is closed to new replies.

Find Amazing Vendors