(Closed) I have a hypothetical question, just for fun

posted 4 years ago in Rings
Post # 2
10596 posts
Sugar Beekeeper
  • Wedding: December 2013

Id say yes..enjoy our first night as an engaged couple. Then id definitely tell him the next day that the ring looks just like my old engagement ring my ex gave me and pray that the store its from will exchange it!

Now say its a very common style ring..like a white gold round or princess cut diamond solitaire then id gladly keep the ring!

Post # 3
466 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: October 2015

I’d say yes if I were ecstatic. Perhaps I loved my previous ring and somehow my new SO picked up on my taste in rings. Either way, it’s not about the ring. It’s about the man who gives it to you. I’d say yes to an empty box, so long as I were in love. Sounds all cliche, but I’d like to think I’d react that way. <br /><br />Hypothetically speaking, of course. 

Post # 4
9115 posts
Buzzing Beekeeper
  • Wedding: December 2012

It’s not about the ring. The ring didn’t break your old engagement. I’d say yes, and move on.

Post # 5
3076 posts
Sugar bee
  • Wedding: April 2013 - A court...

I’d be ecstatic then mention it looks a lot like the exs ring but not on the same day. Unless it was an heirloom. 

Post # 6
1044 posts
Bumble bee
  • Wedding: September 2014 - Merritt Winery

Firstly , say yes! Secondly , do you love said ring? If you do, rock it and keep it moving! If you do not love the ring, politely mention that this new ring looks an awful lot like your previous e ring. Ask the Fiance how he feels about that. This conversation should definitely not occur on the same night though. 

Post # 7
2789 posts
Sugar bee

I would look at the ring and notice that that the diamond had a completely different pattern of sparkles.  (Diamonds are like kaleidoscopes where a small movement gives a very different pattern.  A minute change in cut angle causes a noticable difference in sparkle pattern.)  

This would probably be sufficient.

If I felt that the setting reminded me of a previous engagement I would talk to my Fiance about it and then go choose a setting together.

Diamonds are more unique than you might think.


  • This reply was modified 4 years, 3 months ago by  .
Post # 8
1531 posts
Bumble bee
  • Wedding: February 2012

I wouldn’t give it a second thought. You aren’t marrying the stone. Put a big smile on your face and enjoy your new life together. 

Post # 9
1732 posts
Bumble bee

nottoocool4school:  I’d enjoy the ring regardless. It might look like the same ring, but it’s not…

Post # 10
1618 posts
Bumble bee
  • Wedding: October 2014 - Cape May

I totally  get this especially coming from a previous marriage.  Say yes then absolutely explain to him that you’d like a ring that doesn’t quite remind you of the last. My Fiance was really understanding especially to my need for my wedding band to be totally different. 

The topic ‘I have a hypothetical question, just for fun’ is closed to new replies.

Find Amazing Vendors